What users are saying about

Actian DataConnect

3 Ratings
Score 8.3 out of 101

SAP Replication Server

7 Ratings
Score 8.3 out of 101

Add comparison

Likelihood to Recommend

Actian DataConnect

The choice to use Actian DataConnect really comes down to pricing and the type of integration project you are performing, specifically with the requirements, whether you want the integration to be on-premise or in the cloud, can you install agents on your servers etc. For integration tools it runs head to head with its competitors.
David Byrd profile photo

SAP Replication Server

I asked questions about a warm standby and multicast replication. We ended up using bi-directional replication and a warm standby db. Having 3 or more live OLTP DB's where each was read-write was going to be difficult to manage for contention if the same table was being updated. We stuck with an easier solution to have only two OLTP's, and then used additional DB's as read-only DW's.
Bruce Speidel profile photo

Feature Rating Comparison

Data Source Connection

Actian DataConnect
9.5
SAP Replication Server
9.5
Connect to traditional data sources
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Connecto to Big Data and NoSQL
Actian DataConnect
9.0
SAP Replication Server
10.0

Data Transformations

Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Simple transformations
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Complex transformations
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0

Data Modeling

Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
8.8
Data model creation
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Metadata management
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Business rules and workflow
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Collaboration
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
8.5
Testing and debugging
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
8.5

Data Governance

Actian DataConnect
9.5
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Integration with data quality tools
Actian DataConnect
9.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0
Integration with MDM tools
Actian DataConnect
10.0
SAP Replication Server
9.0

Pros

  • The large connector base for DataConnect is outstanding. However even when they do not have a custom connector, they have a web services Invoker which allows you to connect to any web services.
  • The underlying scripting language is Visual Basic-ish. Very easy to start.
  • The product has been around a long time, through multiple company acquistions, and still is a competitive player via pricing.
  • Support team is awesome.
  • Large user community.
David Byrd profile photo
  • Training was excellent on the product.
  • Great customer service when questions arose.
  • Functionality was awesome.
  • Bringing the main OLTP down for maintenance then allowed down time we could previously never afford to make SLA committments
Bruce Speidel profile photo

Cons

  • Integration Manager needs better scheduling improvements. Like dependencies, and not running a process again if the prior run is still running.
  • New connector development does not seem a priority.
David Byrd profile photo
  • A few bugs existed in the specific implementation we created requirements for, and we had to wait for Sybase to fix those bugs before it went live to production
  • Two way replication had issues where if the same table was being updated by both source and destination, a decision had to made on the "truth". We had to write some special software for specific business requirements.
  • Sometimes RepServer would go down, and we didn't know about it until the next time a healthcheck was performed. We had to write some monitoring software to notify us if things went down.
Bruce Speidel profile photo

Alternatives Considered

As I stated earlier, DataConnect makes a head-to-head run against the others. It has advantages and disadvantages compared to the competitors. The choice really comes down to pricing and specific requirement needs for the project you are planning. Questions such as On-premise or Cloud, Security, and Specific Connectors available will drive your decision.
David Byrd profile photo
Hands down Sybase has the best replication
Bruce Speidel profile photo

Return on Investment

  • Our customer likes the consistent reliable integrations we have built so we [got] a definite return on investment.
  • Problems are fairly easy to handle and rework.
David Byrd profile photo
  • The positive impact was better performance from our application using these new databases available to the business.
  • Negative impact was development time
  • Another negative impact was that Sybase engineering had to patch RepServer to fix a bug we discovered.
Bruce Speidel profile photo

Pricing Details

Actian DataConnect

General
Free Trial
Free/Freemium Version
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No
Additional Pricing Details

SAP Replication Server

General
Free Trial
Free/Freemium Version
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No
Additional Pricing Details