What users are saying about
2 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring#question3' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>Customer Verified: Read more.</a>
Top Rated
835 Ratings
2 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 7.8 out of 101

Basecamp

<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring#question3' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>Customer Verified: Read more.</a>
Top Rated
835 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 8 out of 101

Likelihood to Recommend

AgileCraft

1) Forecasting & Release Planning
2) Scaling Agile at enterprise level
3) To maintain transparency, lot of information radiators, games, reports are available enabling transparency at portfolio level
Sourav Singla ,Safe Agilist, CSP,  ICP-ACC, CSM, CSPO, SSM, LSSG profile photo

Basecamp

If you have a lot of different projects that run concurrently and have a lot of moving parts, I think Basecamp is especially beneficial to help not only the project manager keep track of progress, but for everyone in the group to understand where they are in the process and to make sure goals and expectations and deadlines are clear. It has meant that we have less meetings, which has made us much more efficient. I think if your projects really depend on dependencies, you'll need another program, however. And perhaps if you work at a very granular level, this may not have the level of detail you need
Jessica Meadows Rich profile photo

Feature Rating Comparison

Project Management

AgileCraft
9.2
Basecamp
7.9
Task Management
AgileCraft
10.0
Basecamp
8.9
Resource Management
AgileCraft
10.0
Basecamp
8.3
Scheduling
AgileCraft
9.0
Basecamp
7.8
Team Collaboration
AgileCraft
9.0
Basecamp
8.8
Support for Agile Methodology
AgileCraft
10.0
Basecamp
7.7
Document Management
AgileCraft
7.0
Basecamp
8.1
Timesheet Tracking
AgileCraft
9.0
Basecamp
7.2
Change request and Case Management
AgileCraft
9.0
Basecamp
8.3
Budget and Expense Management
AgileCraft
10.0
Basecamp
7.9
Gantt Charts
AgileCraft
Basecamp
7.7
Workflow Automation
AgileCraft
Basecamp
7.6
Support for Waterfall Methodology
AgileCraft
Basecamp
7.8
Email integration
AgileCraft
Basecamp
8.0
Mobile Access
AgileCraft
Basecamp
6.8

Professional Services Automation

AgileCraft
9.0
Basecamp
7.9
Quotes/estimates
AgileCraft
10.0
Basecamp
8.0
Project & financial reporting
AgileCraft
8.0
Basecamp
8.3
Invoicing
AgileCraft
Basecamp
8.0
Integration with accounting software
AgileCraft
Basecamp
7.2

Pros

AgileCraft

  • Effective Sprint planning : Sprint planning can be done using Planning Poker in AgileCraft by clicking Team > Manage > Other > Estimation Games very effectively for distributed teams.
  • Team Capacity Allocation Report: After tasks are created at team or program level, the report from AgileCraft cab be pulled and can be verified that no team member is under or over allocated. A report can be generated by navigating to Team > Manage > Assign Tasks.
  • Effective Requirement trace-ability: To maintain requirements trace-ability follow the steps below:
  • Upload test cases against the story/requirement. once uploaded test cases will be visible under that story
  • Execute Test cases in AgileCraft and mark them as Pass/Fail based on the actual outcome
  • Based on test results, The acceptance criterion's can be marked as “Pass” or “Fail” & if marked failed corresponding defect can be logged & can be attached with the story
  • So against each story we can easily see whether all test cases been executed or not & which acceptance criterion's are failed & how many defects are in open or close state.
  • Daily Scrum: In AgileCraft, the option to run a daily stand-up is available from Team > Manage > Daily Standups. Selecting the sprint number opens the daily stand-up meeting window in which each team member's tasks are visible and hours can be burned against them. Conduct Scrum meetings in AgileCraft, and burn each associate hour against the tasks created during the meeting. The burn-down chart can be generated & viewed during the stand-up to check whether the team is on track.
Sourav Singla ,Safe Agilist, CSP,  ICP-ACC, CSM, CSPO, SSM, LSSG profile photo

Basecamp

  • Allows for the creation of groups of To Do's under one project.
  • The Activity Feed allows for a great overview of what's happening to be able to quickly see where things are
  • Anyone can create a to do and assign it to anyone, so people are empowered to take ownership over projects.
  • Is pretty easy and straightforward to get started and creating To Do's and Projects
Jessica Meadows Rich profile photo

Cons

AgileCraft

  • Program level metrics & Scorecards: Though we can generate few metrics & scorecards but I feel few more metrics can be added like velocity acceleration , team improvement rate.
  • QA team often come to me regarding the test case tagging, it is very difficult to search particular test case here so I feel advance search feature should be provided.
  • Program Planning: In Agilecraft program tracker if we have lot of multiple dependencies & where situation demands to look at our features holistically across the entire landscape of the solution, it did not provide proper support.
  • Also If I need to take a call at which sprint need to be optimized I did not get that decision making enablement here.
Sourav Singla ,Safe Agilist, CSP,  ICP-ACC, CSM, CSPO, SSM, LSSG profile photo

Basecamp

  • No dependencies! I wish so much that dependencies were an option. So often we have to remember to manually assign the next To Do to someone after something has been completed and it's easy to forget this. So that this human error can be avoided, dependencies would help with this greatly.
  • It took a long time for us to figure out how best to fit Basecamp into our work flow, who was responsible for what and how our processes would best work. It's great now but it probably took us a solid year before we got to the point where we had smoothed out the rough edges and felt like our processes worked perfectly within Basecamp.
  • You sometimes have to be careful about where you are placing information: in the comment v. the note v. commenting on the list v. commenting on the To Do. Depending on who has been checked to received a notification, not everyone will receive the information. This isn't necessarily an issue; it just means you have to be very careful about where you are placing information and double-checking that the people you want to be notified will receive it.
Jessica Meadows Rich profile photo

Likelihood to Renew

AgileCraft

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Basecamp

Basecamp 10.0
Based on 27 answers
Fusce ultricies arcu sed sagittis euismod. Duis ultrices ipsum sed mi venenatis, in ultrices neque dapibus. Etiam et eros massa. Nulla ut pellentesque ipsum. Aliquam erat volutpat. Quisque tempus nisl vitae nisi volutpat euismod. Curabitur turpis arcu, blandit at libero a, vehicula pellentesque magna. Donec dui ligula, auctor at condimentum ut, dictum a ligula. Pellentesque convallis metus vitae nulla varius, eget ornare ex malesuada. Quisque nulla nisi, suscipit in scelerisque tincidunt, rutrum in lorem. Donec iaculis congue commodo. Curabitur sagittis nibh non elit venenatis bibendum. Etiam ut mi quis metus hendrerit rutrum interdum vel erat. Vestibulum ullamcorper orci a magna placerat, sit amet tincidunt purus lobortis. Duis tincidunt porta sollicitudin.
Patrick Barrett profile photo

Usability

AgileCraft

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Basecamp

Basecamp 8.8
Based on 7 answers
I find it extremely easy to use, though as a tech-savvy person, it takes some fairly obnoxious software for me to have difficulty. However, I have found that occasionally some clients don't understand how the subject line and discussion body work when creating a new post, and sometimes have difficulty understanding where to respond and will create new threads with feedback, rather than replying on the old one. I don't think Basecamp can help this, however, without severely annoying those of us who find it highly intuitive.
Lisa Keyser profile photo

Reliability and Availability

AgileCraft

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Basecamp

Basecamp 10.0
Based on 5 answers
Over the span of 5 years, Basecamp has been available every single time I have signed on. There has never been an event that has caused a loss of project data.
Ed Lojko profile photo

Support

AgileCraft

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Basecamp

Basecamp 9.0
Based on 4 answers
  • Their self help products like guides and webinars are good.
  • Very quick response time.
  • Almost never need them to begin with.
Ed Lojko profile photo

Implementation

AgileCraft

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Basecamp

Basecamp 7.7
Based on 4 answers
Decide the process before implementation - i.e. when it's due 8/9 does that mean 8am, noon, 5pm, 11:59pm? Check your to-do list frequentlySet-up templates - just not with the dates (they can be funky)
Jenni Waggoner profile photo

Alternatives Considered

AgileCraft

JIRA basic version do not have basic support for test management, capacity planning & forecasting.

Rally is good & rich in features but if you want to implement safe , Agilecraft is definitely a better choice.
Rally supports safe but I did not get good support from technical desk & few features are really cumbersome to use.

HP Quality Center 11 supports agile teams well but I found it pretty costly.
Sourav Singla ,Safe Agilist, CSP,  ICP-ACC, CSM, CSPO, SSM, LSSG profile photo

Basecamp

We stopped using Basecamp and started using Trello instead. Trello works better for us and our agile methodology
Nicolas Costa Ossa profile photo

Return on Investment

AgileCraft

  • Able to forecast & plan releases well using agilecraft leading to quality on time delivery.
  • Distributed teams are able to collaborate well, be it be daily scrum, retrospective, estimation though this. Also team members love the gamification part & they have fun using this tool. Earlier we use to face challenges due to distributed teams but after AgileCraft, collaboration & communication was no longer a challenge & we are able to see improvement not only in team velocity, but also team satisfaction.
  • Simplest tool to implement safe, scaling is always a problem with most of the agile tools but agilecraft helps in smoother implementation of safe practices & principles.
Sourav Singla ,Safe Agilist, CSP,  ICP-ACC, CSM, CSPO, SSM, LSSG profile photo

Basecamp

  • Basecamp has allowed us to work better with third party vendors or suppliers on projects by providing more transparency and in return have seen quicker response times when tasks are relying on one team or the other.
  • The costs are low but they do not outweigh the benefit to use Basecamp as an internal system for project management.
  • The time saved on avoiding wasted meetings for simple updates has been more than beneficial on a time management perspective.
Craig Lockley profile photo

Pricing Details

AgileCraft

General

Free Trial
Free/Freemium Version
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No
Additional Pricing Details

Basecamp

General

Free Trial
Yes
Free/Freemium Version
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No
Additional Pricing Details

Add comparison