What users are saying about
56 Ratings
18 Ratings
56 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 7 out of 101
18 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 7 out of 101

Likelihood to Recommend

Alfresco ECM

If you have regulatory or business needs that require saving email into Alfresco and you are using Outlook for Mac, you may need to perform significant customization to make it work. Additionally, if you will have users that will be members to a large numbers of sites over time, you need to thoroughly explore what functionality will be degraded or lost and how to mitigate the impact. Other than these two scenarios, I cannot think of any scenarios where Alfresco would not be well suited to an organization's needs.
No photo available

Magnolia V5+

Magnolia CMS is a great product to develop enterprise websites, extranets and intranets. At the moment, the community is growing day by day but so far not many extensions are available. Magnolia is an enterprise CMS, the initial learning curve takes time, to learn all its functionalities and how to customize it is necessary to know Java. When one wants to develop just a simple website without complexity which doesn’t need any specific features such as workflow, versioning, environment separation between staging and public, etc. it is preferable to choose another CMS.
Maurizio Müller profile photo

Feature Rating Comparison

Enterprise Content Management

Alfresco ECM
7.6
Magnolia V5+
Content capture & imaging
Alfresco ECM
7.2
Magnolia V5+
File sync, storage & archiving
Alfresco ECM
8.0
Magnolia V5+
Document management
Alfresco ECM
8.1
Magnolia V5+
Records management
Alfresco ECM
7.2
Magnolia V5+
Content search & retrieval
Alfresco ECM
7.1
Magnolia V5+
Enterprise content collaboration
Alfresco ECM
7.6
Magnolia V5+
Content publishing & creation
Alfresco ECM
7.0
Magnolia V5+
Security, risk management & information governance
Alfresco ECM
6.6
Magnolia V5+
Contract lifecycle management
Alfresco ECM
7.3
Magnolia V5+
Automated workflows
Alfresco ECM
7.0
Magnolia V5+
Artificial intelligence
Alfresco ECM
8.0
Magnolia V5+
Mobile support
Alfresco ECM
8.0
Magnolia V5+
Integration
Alfresco ECM
9.0
Magnolia V5+

Security

Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Role-based user permissions
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0

Platform & Infrastructure

Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
API
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Internationalization / multi-language
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0

Web Content Creation

Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
6.9
WYSIWYG editor
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
6.0
Code quality / cleanliness
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
6.0
Admin section
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Page templates
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Library of website themes
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Publishing workflow
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Form generator
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
8.0

Web Content Management

Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
6.6
Content taxonomy
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
6.0
SEO support
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Bulk management
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Availability / breadth of extensions
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
7.0
Community / comment management
Alfresco ECM
Magnolia V5+
6.0

Pros

Alfresco ECM

  • Basic workflows are easy enough for casual users to set up and utilize.
  • Cloud sync capability provides a great way to share documents with third parties and to use as a backup system for critical documents.
  • Alfresco mobile app makes it easy for those on the road to access, approve and share documents.
  • Folder rules are easy to set up and make assignment of metadata easier to automate.
No photo available

Magnolia V5+

  • The product allowed the site to be skinned easily.
  • The product allowed developers to create dialogs to enable the content editors to enter content for the website.
  • The product is a powerful content management tool.
No photo available

Cons

Alfresco ECM

  • When users are members of 1000 sites or more, certain features such as sites dashlet do not work properly.
  • There isn't any integration between Alfresco and Microsoft Outlook for Mac. IMAP integration has flaws that can cause loss of email.
  • Mobile app doesn't have a site search feature. this is problematic when you have thousands of sites and you need to access one where you have not saved it as a favorite.
No photo available

Magnolia V5+

  • Magnolia lacks of an administrative dashboard showing all the workflow, possibly in a graphical representation of their status.
  • The audit module only logs in a file: having a dashboard for the audit would be a nice improvement.
  • When the time comes to configure templates and components in the Standard Templating Kit is quite complicated and boring at times. A widget to help the developer would be a very interesting job. In addition, having the possibility to configure template and component in the Standard Template Kit by code would be nice.
  • Implementing a customization in the administrative UI or in the dialogs isn’t simple and the developer must know Vaadin.
  • Migrating from the previous major release is complicated and expensive, since Magnolia 5 isn’t compatible with the old major versions (Magnolia 4).
Maurizio Müller profile photo

Likelihood to Renew

Alfresco ECM

Alfresco ECM 9.0
Based on 9 answers
The business really enjoys this product and we will continue to use it.
No photo available

Magnolia V5+

Magnolia V5+ 9.5
Based on 3 answers
Magnolia is an innovative CMS, for example it is possible to use the ipad to manage the contents. Magnolia’s team works hard to improve the product; the community is small but active and the support for the enterprise version is good. Magnolia’s team asks the users what they think and what they need, and the new functionalities planned for Magnolia 5.3 are very exciting for example the content personalization.
Maurizio Müller profile photo

Implementation

Alfresco ECM

Alfresco ECM 9.0
Based on 1 answer
Process was relatively smooth and overall, downtime minimal. MSI was very responsive to our needs and made the transition easier than it otherwise might have been.
No photo available

Magnolia V5+

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Alternatives Considered

Alfresco ECM

All software has some pros and some cons. Alfresco has some good pluses, and suits our environment very well. It fit perfectly in the place that we are working on. That is why we decided to go with this software. Overall, the kind of content management that needs to be done in an organization is what would determine which software to use.
No photo available

Magnolia V5+

I evaluated many CMS products and I’m continuing to evaluate them to verify the new functionality introduced.I evaluated these products: Alfresco, Apache Lenya, DotCMS, Drupal, Liferay, Hippo, Joomla, OpenCMS. I chose Magnolia because Magnolia offers two licensed community editions and the commercial edition, is written in Java, the solution is open and extensible, it is very simple to use for the contributors, and includes a good set of functionalities out of the box, as well as being secure and scalable. I think Alfresco is a very good DMS but the CMS functionality could be improved.If I had to develop a portal with portlet I would choose, but the portlet needs a lot of system resources, as well as the integration of the external product or legacy data which usually doesn’t support natively the portlet so I haven’t used Liferay in a real project.
Apache Lenya, DotCMS, Hippo and OpenCMS are very good products too, especially Hippo CMS which in the last few years made important improvements. Drupal and Joomla are very simple to use and to develop a small website, and there are many extensions available in the community. On the other hand, customizing or integrating other systems is not so simple.
Maurizio Müller profile photo

Return on Investment

Alfresco ECM

  • Reduce the stress of [making] several copies of paper
  • It transferred the captured document to the proper department
  • Reduce employment rate
Oluwatoyin Adesemowo profile photo

Magnolia V5+

  • Faster to publish content updates
  • Profiling the access at the front end management
  • Only one point to access the content which is also well organized
  • Easy to manage once in production
Davide Dispenza profile photo

Pricing Details

Alfresco ECM

General

Free Trial
Free/Freemium Version
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No

Alfresco ECM Editions & Modules

Alfresco ECM
Additional Pricing Details

Magnolia V5+

General

Free Trial
Yes
Free/Freemium Version
Yes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Yes
Entry-level set up fee?
No

Magnolia V5+ Editions & Modules

Magnolia V5+
Edition
Magnolia Community Edition
$0
Magnolia Enterprise Edition Standard
-2
Magnolia Enterprise Edition Pro
-2
2. per instance
Additional Pricing Details

Add comparison