Likelihood to Recommend Codeship is extremely well suited for projects that are version controlled on public hosting such as Github or Bitbucket, and for situations where you need to pick up code from these systems and deploy it to different cloud environments. For example, we had two projects for the same client that were hosted on Github and needed to be deployed to AWS and Heroku. The native CI/CD tools of these cloud environments could not provide a holistic solution to deploy to both environments the way Codeship did.
Read full review Though it has a few setup issues, once you are done with setup it works like charm so one time setup issues won't bother. Reporting, version tracking, debugging everything is helpful and more clear and it reduces effort, in our scenario our QA team integrated their script with Hudson so that after every release it will get triggered automatically and developers will know if there is any major issue.
Read full review Pros Codeship provides a set of tools for quickly creating and building our deployment artifacts and push them to the designated servers. Codeship's hooks allows our developers to simply push tags from our git repositories to initiate a deployment of code to a server. No one outside of the devops team needs any expertise to get our code packages delivered. Codeship allows us to tie in behat and unit tests easily to prevent delivery of buggy code. Read full review Oracle Hudson UI provides a simple setup and integration with SVN and other version control tools. The user control provides various operations to users through which it's easy to control the CI deployment process. It handles Performance testing and Automation testing, provides and accepts user interaction. Allows them to schedule jobs Read full review Cons I would like to see a little bit more than the green/red status. If there are tests, it would be good to see how many have failed on a red build. To improve build times (and reduce feedback times), it would be good to see how long build, tests, and deployment take over time. An overview like that could very easily point to potential areas of improvement. I think Codeship users do not want to bother with the build process, but, if there is anything to improve and increase productivity it's very unlikely that users wouldn't want to do this. Read full review The setup needs to be more user friendly, currently for first time users CI doesn't provide more guidelines. JMeter tool can be integrated but it's not easy, user has to follow and do research before setup. A simpler way would help make the process more user friendly. Selenium tool like JMeter can be integrated, if its Webservice it's easy but for UI automation integration not enough information is provided. Read full review Alternatives Considered Our company uses
Jenkins for all internal deployment processes for one very important reason - it's hosted internally. But Codeship is great for personal use - it has intuitive UI, easy setup and tons of integrations.
Read full review Oracle CI in terms of setup lags behind all above products, but then its use is also limited to release management so we can't really compare. Majority of organizations have dedicated team to help with CI Process so they take care of managing all jobs and setup.
Read full review Return on Investment Having the code tested thoroughly. While it's obviously a part of the job that still requires the developer to sit down and to actually have some decent and thorough tests implemented, by using codeship we were able to guarantee 100% that our code was being tested each and every time it got commited and pushed onto our repositories. Leading to a faster, shorter and sure implementation iterative cycle. Fewer 'man in the middle' processes which required more steps and people involved just to get the code shipped onto our deployment servers. Almost inexistent learning curve. Codeship is simple to use and very intuitive. Nobody in our development department had a hard time figuring out how to have it properly configured for each new project created there. Read full review Provides an easy way to deployment process Centralizes control for all release management Secured process, a user can only check errors and release management can take control of deployment. User roles are provided. Read full review ScreenShots CloudBees Codeship Screenshots