After 4 years, still not convinced ...
Updated May 07, 2014
After 4 years, still not convinced ...
Score 4 out of 10
Vetted Review
Verified User
Software Version
8.0
Modules Used
- IBM Unica Campaign
Overall Satisfaction with IBM Unica
It is used by 2 departements.
It is used to "program" campaigns. 2/3 of the campaigns are one shot, 1/3 is recurrent. 1/2 are commercial campaigns, 1/2 are administrative campaigns to inform clients of p.e. changes in interest rates and so on.
It is used to "program" campaigns. 2/3 of the campaigns are one shot, 1/3 is recurrent. 1/2 are commercial campaigns, 1/2 are administrative campaigns to inform clients of p.e. changes in interest rates and so on.
- The most powerful in Unica are the audience swaps. They are very helpful for cleaning up audiences like households, if one of the members of a household has a product, you can easily exclude the whole audience.
- When working with segments in a flow, this goes really fast.
- The use of templates is easy and helps to standardise the working process.
- The mappings of tables can be different in every campaign
- Logging is not easy to read and is incomplete. It has a lot of information i'm not interested in, but the queries that really interest me, p.e. the queries used for calculation of derived fields are missing. I also miss the queries that add the result of the derived field to the final selection.
- Difficult to document a flow in a good manner.
- No way to search in a flow. and over all the flows where something is calculated.
- No way to have a good overview of what is happening in a flow or a process in a flow.
- The calculation of derived fields is far too slow.
- You can not make decisions in a flow based on data.
- You have to promote flows by copying them manually from a test environment to a production environment.
- This might lead to inconsistence over the environments.
- We are only using Unica for the selection part of campaigns, I think things go twice as slow as before when we were working in SAS, but it is difficult to compare, as the people doing the work in SAS had all up to 20 years of experience and those working with Unica now are all new people. The people who liked to do the campaign selections with SAS did not like to work with UNICA, so they left, and with them also their experience.
The consultants of UNICA where very good at their job, fast and efficient. They always had a very convincing answer to our questions.
Using IBM Unica
14 - selections for sending emails, letters. Providing calls to the internal and external call centers, and to the survey agencies we work with.
2 - It people to install new release and resolve really technical issues.
- Selections for the call centers
- Sending email messages
- Selections for surveys
- none
Evaluating IBM Unica and Competitors
Yes - SAS base, the decision was made on group level, their was no really a need for it in our branch, we were very well organised.
- Product Reputation
- Positive Sales Experience with the Vendor
The consultants who demonstrated the product where very good and convincing.
I think we did right at that time. But the timing was not right. We should have waited a bit longer.
IBM Unica Implementation
- Vendor implemented
- Implemented in-house
Yes - 3 phases:
- technical test fase
- user test fase
- production test fase
- technical test fase
- user test fase
- production test fase
- The design of the underlying datamart
- The difficulties of setting up response tracking
IBM Unica Support
Pros | Cons |
---|---|
Quick Initial Response | Slow Resolution Poor followup Escalation required Difficult to get immediate help Need to explain problems multiple times Support doesn't seem to care |
Yes - It took a long time to resolve
Not really, or exceptionally bad support (no experience with IBM, only in the period before IBM bought UNICA)
Using IBM Unica
Pros | Cons |
---|---|
Relatively simple Easy to use Technical support not required Well integrated Consistent Quick to learn Convenient Familiar | Do not like to use Feel nervous using |
- If you don't make complex selections, the interface is simple to use.
- With few explanations, you can make simple selections.
- the use of date functions in selections
- the right way of mapping the used tables seems to be difficult for beginning user