Name: Crucible
Rating: 10 (8 reviews)
Author: Atlassian

Help Desk

Web and Video Conferencing

Customer Support

Batch Management Software

Product Lifecycle Management (PLM)

Development

Business Intelligence (BI)

Collaboration

Digital Rights Management (DRM)

Enhanced 911 (E911)

Facility Management

IP PBX

Operational Analytics

Policy Management

Enterprise

Accounting

Invoicing

Nonprofit Accounting

Subscription Management

Finance and Accounting

Applicant Tracking

Corporate Learning Management

Employee Recognition

Employee Scheduling

HR Management

Payroll

Stock Option Plan Administration

Talent Intelligence

Talent Management

Workforce Analytics

Workforce Management

Human Resources

Application Performance Management (APM)

Archiving

Build Automation

Cloud Cost Management

Cloud Storage

Code Review

Configuration Management Databases

Data Mapping

Density-Optimized Servers

Email Encryption

Firewall Security Management

Fraud Detection

IP Address Management (IPAM)

IT Service Providers

Integration Platform as a Service (iPaaS)

Log Management

Managed DNS

Network Performance Monitoring

Software-Defined WAN

System Monitoring

Web Scraping

WiFi Hotspot

Workload Automation

Information Technology

A/B Testing

Ad Serving & Retargeting

All-in-One Marketing

Audio Editing

Content Management

Email Deliverability

Email Marketing

Marketing Automation

Online Proofing

Search Engine Marketing (SEM)

Social Media Management

Social Media Marketing

Survey & Forms Building

Web Analytics

Marketing

Job Site Management

Project Management

Waste Management

Writing and Proofreading Tools

Professional Services

Customer Relationship Management (CRM)

Product Configuration

Social Commerce

Sales

Laboratory Information Management

Membership Management

Roofing

Vertical-Specific

Find top rated software and services based on in-depth reviews from verified users. 400+ software categories including PaaS, NoSQL, BI, HR, and more.

Atlassian Bitbucket

Atlassian

Upsource

JetBrains

GitHub

Western Digital SSD

Western Digital

SonarQube Server

SonarSource Sarl

GitLab

Beyond Compare

Scooter Software

Codacy

CodeStream

Code Compare

Devart

IBM DevOps Model Architect

Phabricator

Phacility

Pluralsight Flow

Pluralsight

Redgate SQL Prompt

Redgate

CodeRush

DevExpress

### Code Review Tools and Processes
Users generally appreciate Crucible's robust code review tools and processes. The platform's ability to provide a hierarchical view of projects and allow manual selection of files or changes for review is well-received. However, some users have expressed concerns about slow and inefficient polling, occasional bugs that impact change detection, and inefficiencies when handling large changes. Despite these drawbacks, Crucible's code review tools and processes are seen as valuable assets for enhancing code quality and collaboration within development teams.

### Integration with Development Platforms
Users consistently highlight Crucible's exceptional integration capabilities with various development platforms, such as Git and Jenkins, as a standout feature. The platform's ability to link with any version control system and facilitate collaborative code reviews with ease has garnered widespread acclaim. Additionally, the intuitive interface and the option to add evidence like screenshots to code reviews further enhance the integration experience. Users appreciate Crucible's time tracking functionality, which sets it apart from other tools like Github pull requests, making it a preferred choice for efficient code review processes. The platform's unique feature of allowing code from multiple repositories to be added to a single review is also lauded for its practicality and convenience.

### Version Control and Repository Management
Users consistently highlight Crucible's exceptional version control and repository management features, emphasizing its ability to integrate with various version control systems like SVN and Git. The collaborative review process, where team members can easily track changes and add comments, is a standout feature. The intuitive user interface, coupled with the efficient organization of code branches and files, enhances the overall code review experience. Additionally, the time tracking functionality and the capability to include code from multiple repositories in a single review set Crucible apart from other similar tools.

### Project and Workflow Management
Users consistently highlight Crucible's project and workflow management features as robust and user-friendly. The platform's ability to track time, assign moderators, and facilitate collaborative reviews is particularly well-received. Additionally, the hierarchical view of projects and the integration with Jira for bug tracking contribute to a streamlined workflow for developers. The intuitive user interface and the option to add files for review effortlessly further enhance the project management experience within Crucible.

Users have provided several recommendations for Crucible based on their experiences and needs. The most common recommendations include considering other products, using Crucible in a fast-paced CICD environment, and integrating with Jira and an in-house hosted codebase. 

Some users are unsure if there are other code repository tools that can perform code reviews as efficiently as Crucible. They suggest exploring more modern and easier-to-use solutions in order to find a tool that better meets their requirements.

Many users highly recommend using Crucible in a fast-paced Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment (CICD) environment. They view it as a mature tool that provides most of the necessary features for efficient code reviews and code management.

Users who have an in-house hosted codebase and already use Jira recommend using Crucible. They highlight the seamless integration between the two tools, making it a convenient choice for managing code reviews. However, some users mention that Crucible may be less suitable for reviewing documentation.

Overall, users find Crucible to be a valuable tool for code reviews, particularly in Agile development environments. They appreciate its flexibility, interface, filtering capabilities, and searching tools. While some recommend exploring other options, many believe that if they already use Jira, integrating with Crucible is a logical choice.

Detailed Reports and Analysis: Many users have expressed their appreciation for the detailed reports and analysis provided by Crucible during the code review process. This valuable feature allows users to identify problems and make improvements, enhancing the overall quality of their work.

Hierarchical Project View: The hierarchical view of projects in Crucible has received high praise from users. Resembling a file explorer, this organized structure provides an intuitive way for reviewers to navigate and review code, making the process more efficient.

Clear and Easy-to-Use Interface: Users find the user interface of Crucible to be clear and easy to use. This intuitive design allows them to focus on reviewing code without any distractions, ensuring that they can provide insightful comments on the right elements. Additionally, even complex reviews with multiple editions are easily understandable thanks to the well-designed interface.

Cons:
1. Non-intuitive user interface: Some users have mentioned that they struggle with finding certain functions or features within the software due to its non-intuitive user interface. This lack of intuitiveness can result in a steep learning curve for newcomers and hinder their productivity.
2. Lack of unique features compared to competitors: Several reviewers have pointed out that while the software offers essential functionalities for code reviews, it lacks distinctive features that set it apart from competing tools like Bitbucket and Github. This perceived lack of innovation raises questions about whether the software provides enough value relative to its alternatives.
3. Inefficient code review progress reset: A notable issue highlighted by users is that when new files are added during an ongoing code review, it resets everyone's progress on reviewing existing files. This setback forces reviewers to start over and disrupts their workflow, causing unnecessary delays in completing code reviews efficiently.

Crucible is a versatile software that addresses the needs of developers and teams by providing an efficient platform for code reviews and collaboration. With easy access to requested files, users can review changes and suggest modifications through comments, streamlining the review process. Integration with Jira further enhances the workflow by generating links to Crucible directly from Jira tickets, enabling seamless code review and issue tracking.

By leveraging Crucible, developers benefit from enhanced collaboration and improved prioritization of their work. In-person code reviews become redundant as Crucible enables remote collaboration, eliminating geographical limitations. This is particularly beneficial for multi-geographical teams who need 24x7 access to code review capabilities. With its ability to handle large codebases effectively, Crucible simplifies code management, tracking, and teamwork.

One of the key advantages of using Crucible is its facilitation of continuous integration through code reviews. By ensuring code quality and catching bugs early in the development process, Crucible contributes to delivering the best possible product to customers. Peer code review helps improve software quality and conformity to coding standards, making it an essential tool for software projects.

Moreover, Crucible reduces risks associated with software releases and supports maintenance by ensuring logical and maintainable code changes. It also provides visibility across the team for code reviews and collaboration, allowing for traceability and linking of reviews to relevant Jira issues. Whether it's daily code reviews in agile teams or department-wide formal reviews, Crucible proves to be an indispensable solution for sharing code changes among team members and maintaining coding standards throughout the development process.

Bitbucket is a Git repository and code collaboration platform, featuring automated testing and code deployment. Bitbucket Cloud Premium provides AI-powered development, more granular access controls, and enforced code quality, and Bitbucket Data Center provides a self-hosted option.

Bitbucket Data Center

Free

Standard

Premium

Redgate's SQL Toolbelt Essentials includes industry-standard tools for SQL Server development & deployment, enabling users to include SQL Server databases in agile processes and enabilng developers to embed robust and scalable development practices.

Redgate SQL Toolbelt Essentials

Crucible

Code Review tools are designed to help developers improve software quality. Using these tools, software developers review each other's code before releasing software to QA. The goal is to identify bugs and create more maintainable code.

GM818CR Demo- Crucible furnace for melting borosilicate and soft glass

Glass Blowing Demonstration: The Crucible

Kier Lugo's Crucible is a live demo of the ancient art of glass blowing, shown at Maker Faire Bay Area 2011. Glass is an amorphous solid that formed into layers and shapes when heated. As the material is manipulated and cooled, more layers and elements can be added to the work. 

http://thecrucible.org/
http://makerfaire.com/pub/e/5435

Voice Over Demo: "The Crucible"-TITUBA (Jamaican Accent)

Likelihood to Recommend

Support Rating

Atlassian is a global software company that provides software development and collaboration tools to help teams conceive, plan, build and launch great products. The company says more than 20,000 organizations of all sizes use Atlassian's issue tracking, collaboration and software development tools to work smarter and deliver quality results on time.

Systems Administrator/Programmer

Crucible 2019-02-21 09:47:06

Zoho Desk

NGINX

Crucible 2020-04-23 18:51:18

Crucible 2019-12-26 12:13:38

IntelliJ IDEA

WebStorm

PyCharm

Crucible 2018-01-16 13:47:17

TeamViewer

Chrome Remote Desktop

Concur Expense (module)

Crucible 2018-02-27 11:40:03

TrustRadius is a technology and business research firm based in Austin, Texas. The company is known as a review platform for verified B2B technology and software reviews through a proprietary algorithm and human verification.

TrustRadius

Customization features

New tab

Bit slow

Slow to load

Creation process

Code review

Use improvements

24 7

Different team

Integration with jira

Email notifications

Team members

End to end

Valuable features

Feature is excellent

Development experience

Quickly share

Home

Code Review Tools

Developers use Crucible. Peer code review online allows new developers to quickly conform to firm software coding standards and methodologies in a quick and most often friendly manner. Peer review improves the software. When developers know their code is likely to be reviewed they tend to conform to standards and write more maintainable software.

Easily add comments, identify defects, gather peer input.
24/7 input from peers eases developer schedules and location independence.
Email notifications filtered by group or individuals provide control of who gets notifications, and who can submit comments.

An embedded drawing tool would help with clarity.

Extremely effective ROI -- the product is inexpensive.
Proven ability to increase compliance to standards.
Online peer software review most often does not take much time.
Ability to peer review 24/7 increases efficiency.

Crucible is used as the main code review tool for our software projects. Team members use Crucible to review each other's work to make sure the same coding standard is applied, code changes are logical and easy to follow, and all these can be done online and allow members to collaborate together by leaving comments.

Supports all major source control systems such as SVN and Git.
Integration with Jira, Bamboo, Bitbucket, to have a complete end to end development experience.
Easy to use UI/UX for reviewing code changes amongst different team members.

Occasionally has performance loading issues, especially with big code bases.

Improving code quality through code review.
Improving code base maintainability by ensuring standards are followed.
Improving team member collaboration and sharing/learning from each other.

Crucible is being used as the formal code review platform. Crucible is used in our entire Technology department for all software development projects. Crucible allows developers to share their projects and source code changes with team members and managers. Crucible reduces the risks associated with software released into Production and eliminates time and efforts to support maintenance issues for the business.

Crucible integrates with SVN very well allowing transparency on projects and enhancements.
Crucible offers many valuable features that enable developers to quickly share their source code modifications, add comments and present issues where emphasis and further discussion is necessary.

Crucible notifications of changes or updates to the code review are delayed as well as loading more source code is slow.
Crucible is formatting could use improvements for viewing customization features. For instance, allowing the user to create a new tab per file to be reviewed would be nice to have.

I am not involved in the acquisition of Crucible so I cannot comment on the financial investment but I believe it is a necessary tool to have in any software shop, small or big.
As a developer, having Crucible as the code review process is a great asset and will save time and reduce risks which I believe is a positive return of investment.

Crucible is being used by my currentl client across their organization within development teams. Its primary use is for competing code reviews. My team uses it for this purpose within the test automation space, where it not only ensures that branches are following coding standards, but also that automated tests actually capture the validations that are intended.

Compares exact branch changes to the master branch
Comment feature is excellent for enabling conversations about code
Seamless integration with git

The frame for viewing code has a scrolling issue, where it jumps to the top when you scroll slightly outside of the window
Code shows as updated with other users' contributions if changes in master are pulled into the branch currently under review
There is a latency with commits being available to add

Has ensured consistent coding across the team
Has facilitated discussions on refactors
It can sometimes lead to frivolous comments if there is friction on a team

IntelliJ WebStorm, IntelliJ IDEA, PyCharm

We use Crucible for our initial code reviews that are done with each defect or feature that we work on. It is used primarily by our department. I am not sure if it is used by other departments or not. It facilitates the reviewing of your peers work.

It shows revisions very well. You can easily see what was changed on each commit.
I like that you can see how much time someone has spent reviewing your code.
Seeing a percentage of things reviewed is also very helpful.

It can sometimes be a bit slow to load. A server reboot for us tends to solve that issue. I'm not sure if it is a server issue, or maybe Crucible may have some caching issues.
I wish that you could easily stop the review creation process, rather than abandoning it.

It has had a large ROI for our team, as it has helped us find issues sooner than we would have had we not reviewed things properly.

Chrome Remote Desktop, TeamViewer, Concur Expense

Crucible

Overview

What is Crucible?