Name: Icinga vs Nagios - What's the difference?
Uploaded: 2010-05-21T14:31:58.000Z
Duration: 9 min 4 s
Description: Icinga vs Nagios - What's the difference?

Help Desk

Web and Video Conferencing

Customer Support

AI Code Generation

Continuous Integration

Product Lifecycle Management (PLM)

Development

Business Intelligence (BI)

Case Management

Collaboration

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)

Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)

Traceability

Enterprise

Accounting

Financial Close

SaaS Spend Management

Finance and Accounting

Applicant Tracking

Corporate Learning Management

HR Management

Job Board

Payroll

Talent Intelligence

Talent Management

Time Tracking

Workforce Analytics

Workforce Management

Human Resources

AIOps

Bug Bounty

Cloud Management

Cloud Storage

Composable Infrastructure

Data Center Backup

Data Center Networking

Email Encryption

Embedded Database

Fraud Detection

Graph Database

Integration Platform as a Service (iPaaS)

Managed Hosting

Message Oriented Middleware

Mobile Application Performance Monitoring  (APM)

Network Function Virtualization (NFV)

Network Performance Monitoring

Process Mining

Rack Servers

Runtime Application Self-Protection

Secure Access Control

Security Validation

Service Desk Outsourcing

Storage Management

Value Stream Management

Information Technology

A/B Testing

Ad Serving & Retargeting

All-in-One Marketing

Content Management

Customer Journey Analytics

Customer Journey Mapping

Email Marketing

Influencer Marketing

Marketing Automation

Social Media Analytics

Social Media Management

Survey & Forms Building

Web Analytics

Marketing

Project Management

Professional Services

Customer Relationship Management (CRM)

Sales Content Management

Sales

File Integrity Monitoring

Security

Agriculture

Clinical Data Management

Insurance Underwriting and Rating

Jail Management

Mental Health

Travel Agency

Warranty Management

Vertical-Specific

Find top rated software and services based on in-depth reviews from verified users. 400+ software categories including PaaS, NoSQL, BI, HR, and more.

Prometheus

Open Source

Zabbix

Nagios Core

Nagios Enterprises

OpenNMS Meridian

The OpenNMS Group

Centreon

Datadog

Nagios XI

LogicMonitor

Veeam ONE

Veeam Software

Splunk Infrastructure Monitoring

Splunk

Zenoss

TrueSight Operations Management (discontinued)

Discontinued Products

Azure Monitor

Microsoft

### Infrastructure Monitoring
Users generally praise Icinga's robust infrastructure monitoring capabilities. They appreciate the ease of monitoring large networks and services, as well as the detailed insights provided by the platform. The flexibility and customization options offered by Icinga make it a valuable tool for monitoring various aspects of their infrastructure. Additionally, users highlight the reliability and stability of Icinga compared to other monitoring solutions they have used in the past. The ability to monitor a wide range of devices and services within their organization has been a significant benefit for many users.

### Network Monitoring
Users consistently praise Icinga's network monitoring capabilities. They highlight the ease of use, comprehensive documentation, and the ability to monitor a wide range of network devices and services effectively. The TLS encryption for secure communication and the support for distribution monitoring modeling are particularly appreciated features. Users find that Icinga allows for efficient monitoring of system, services, and network devices, enabling quick issue resolution and proactive maintenance. The platform's user-friendly interface and scalability make it a valuable tool for both small and complex network environments.

### Server Monitoring
Users generally believe that Icinga excels in server monitoring capabilities. The tool's client/server architecture allows for comprehensive monitoring of various server metrics, including CPU, RAM, processes, and more without the need for SNMP. TLS encryption ensures secure communication between the client and server, enhancing data protection. Users appreciate the ability to monitor Linux servers, Windows servers, databases, and network services efficiently, enabling quick issue resolution and proactive problem-solving. While some users found the documentation for setting up Linux server monitoring challenging, overall, Icinga's server monitoring functionality is praised for providing valuable insights and preventing system downtime effectively. The distributed monitoring feature and time-based notifications further enhance the tool's utility in ensuring continuous server performance and availability.

### Alerting and Notifications
Users generally find Icinga's alerting and notifications capabilities to be a valuable asset in their monitoring experience. The ability to generate error notifications on networks swiftly and effortlessly, along with the convenience of generating documentation with a single click, enhances the software's utility for effective network management. Additionally, the platform's integration with outbound platforms like Slack and ServiceNow enables users to take prompt actions based on customized notifications. Despite some users expressing a desire for additional capabilities such as Mail notifications and PagerDuty alerts, the overall consensus leans towards the effectiveness and simplicity of Icinga's alerting and notifications features.

### Configuration Management
Users generally acknowledge the robust configuration capabilities of Icinga. While some users appreciate the flexibility and ease of configuration using files, others find the .conf file configuration to be outdated and challenging, especially for non-Unix users. Despite the availability of extensive documentation, there are mentions of the initial complexity and time-consuming nature of configuring Icinga, which may require significant effort to align with specific business requirements. Additionally, there are mixed opinions on the user-friendliness of the visual configuration tools like Icinga Director, with some users noting limitations in certain functions such as configuring regular maintenance time slots or dependencies of entities.

### Installation and Setup
Users have varying opinions on Icinga's installation and setup process. While some find it easy to set up and navigate through the GUI, others express concerns about the complexity of the architecture installation and the resource consumption by the Icinga agent. The availability of extensive documentation is highlighted as a helpful resource for users encountering installation challenges. Despite mixed feedback, the general consensus is that Icinga's installation and setup may require some level of technical proficiency and patience to ensure a smooth deployment process.

### Plugins and Extensions
Users generally praise Icinga's extensive support for plugins and modules. The platform's ability to integrate with various systems for monitoring networks, network components, notifications, alert levels, and interfaces has been well-received. Many users appreciate the significant improvements over Nagios and the compatibility with its modules. However, some users have expressed concerns about the lack of frequent updates and extensions, as well as the outdated user interface. Despite these drawbacks, Icinga's plugins and extensions capabilities seem to be a strong point for users who value customization and flexibility in their monitoring solutions.

### User Interface and Customization
Users generally appreciate Icinga's robust user interface and extensive customization options. While some reviewers have highlighted the need for improvements in the user interface, others have praised the platform for its beautiful web interface and high level of configurability. The ability to customize and scale the system according to specific needs has been a key selling point for many users. Additionally, the secure connections and data queuing features have been commended for enhancing the overall user experience. Despite some mixed opinions, the general consensus leans towards Icinga offering strong user interface and customization capabilities.

### Automation and Scripting
While some users find Icinga's automation and scripting capabilities to be a strong point, others express concerns about the ease of integration with Windows systems and the complexity of the documentation. The ability to automate tasks using various scripting languages like PowerShell, Perl, and bash is highlighted as a positive aspect by many users. Additionally, the platform's support for distributed monitoring and integration with configuration management tools like Ansible is praised for enhancing automation processes. Despite some challenges, Icinga's automation and scripting features appear to offer a mix of benefits and areas for improvement according to user feedback.

High Learning Curve: Several users have found the initial setup of Icinga to be challenging for beginners, requiring a significant amount of time and effort to understand and navigate.

Difficult Configuration Process: Some users have expressed frustration with the configuration process of Icinga, particularly non-Unix users who find the learning curve intimidating. They mention that adding new hosts and services through the web UI is not straightforward and relies heavily on config-file based configuration, which they find difficult and arcane.

Limited Customization Options: Users have mentioned difficulties in customizing the front end of the user interface in Icinga. Specifically, they note limitations in copying and pasting certain elements, making it challenging to tailor the interface to their specific needs.

Icinga has proven to be a versatile and effective network monitoring solution, catering to the needs of various organizations. It has been widely implemented throughout entire enterprises, allowing users to gain insights into device functionality and promptly address any failures. With its ability to monitor critical assets, Icinga has become a valuable tool for ensuring the smooth operation of systems and services in both legacy and modern environments.

One of the key use cases of Icinga is its role in the proactive management of incidents. Hosting and support teams have found great value in utilizing the platform's dashboard to monitor ongoing incidents in real-time and receive warnings before they escalate into major issues. This feature has enabled them to take immediate action and prevent potential service disruptions. Additionally, Icinga offers certificate monitoring services, enabling users to keep track of their certificates' status and validity.

As a world-class monitoring system, Icinga has gained popularity among several companies for its wide range of monitoring capabilities. Its client/server nature allows for comprehensive monitoring of various elements, including CPU usage, memory utilization, and processes. It offers an internal monitoring user interface that seamlessly integrates with PagerDuty, facilitating the receipt of critical service notifications. While initially adopted by technical operations teams, more departments have started using Icinga for increased monitoring responsibilities. Furthermore, it has served as the core monitoring platform for non-Windows systems, with plans to expand its implementation to include Windows systems as well.

Overall, Icinga's robust capabilities have positioned it as an indispensable tool for network and system monitoring across diverse organizational landscapes. It empowers users to maintain optimal performance levels, mitigate risks, and proactively address potential issues before they impact business operations.

User-Friendly Configuration Language: Many users have found the configuration language of Icinga to be understandable and easy to grasp, making it simple to add additional hosts and services. This suggests that the configuration language is user-friendly and facilitates the setup process for reviewers.

Scalability and High Configurability: Reviewers appreciate the scalability and high configurability of Icinga, as it can accommodate growth and adapt to different monitoring needs effectively. This ensures that the system remains flexible and capable of meeting evolving requirements for a significant number of users.

Beautiful Web User Interface: The visually appealing web user interface of Icinga has been praised by reviewers, enhancing their overall experience with the platform. Its attractive design contributes to a positive user experience by providing an aesthetically pleasing environment for monitoring and managing systems.

Icinga is an open source network monitoring platform. It includes automation, modularized integration packages, and prebuilt alerts and reporting capabilities.

Microsoft System Center Suite is a family of IT management software for network monitoring, updating and patching, endpoint protection with anti-malware, data protection and backup, ITIL- structured IT service management, remote administration and more.

It is available in two editions: standard and datacenter. Datacenter provides unlimited virtualization for high density private clouds, while standard is for lightly or non-virtualized private cloud workloads.

Datacenter Edition

Standard Edition

Microsoft System Center

Logz.io in Boston offers their enterprise-grade log analytics application, oriented towards providing data security and eliminating the need for capacity management.

Log Management - Community

Log Management - Pro

Log Management - Enterprise

Infrastructure Monitoring - Pro

Cloud SIEM - Enterprise

Distributed Tracing - Pro

Logz.io

Icinga

IT infrastructure monitoring tools  Infrastructure monitoring platforms may also perform threat detection, provide analyses and alerts to preempt critical events.

IT Infrastructure Monitoring

demo icinga2

icinga demo

More details at https://github.com/Icinga/icinga2-api-examples

Icinga Camp Berlin Icinga 2 API Clippy Demo

Video Demo : Giám sát mạng bằng phần mềm Icinga

Likelihood to Recommend

Likelihood to Renew

Icinga GmbH

Icinga vs Nagios - What's the difference?

Icinga and Nagios - What's the difference? 
From the system architecture, core and web interface to documentation, development style and community, we answer the ever so common question - what's the difference between Icinga and Nagios?

PRTG Network Monitor

Apache HTTP Server

NGINX

Ubuntu

Microsoft Windows

Ubuntu, duplicate

IT-Administrator

Icinga 2023-12-23 10:48:05

pfSense

Cloudflare

Untangle NG Firewall

HAProxy Community Edition

Dynatrace

Checkmk

infastructure consultant

Icinga 2021-10-22 10:32:45

New Relic

Red Hat Ansible Automation Platform

Progress Chef

Retrace

Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2)

Senior Infrastructure Engineer

Icinga 2016-06-10 09:36:14

Zoom Workplace

Expensify

Progress WhatsUp Gold

Microsoft 365

Icinga 2019-01-30 08:26:39

Trellix Endpoint Security ENS

Eclipse

Kemp Flowmon ADS

Palo Alto Networks Cortex XDR

System Administrator

Icinga 2015-12-11 07:40:23

TrustRadius is a technology and business research firm based in Austin, Texas. The company is known as a review platform for verified B2B technology and software reviews through a proprietary algorithm and human verification.

Icinga

Overview

What is Icinga?