Bonterra DonorDrive vs. Tiltify Catalyst

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
Bonterra DonorDrive
Score 10.0 out of 10
N/A
Bonterra DonorDrive is an online fundraising solution. Some key features include: Mobile Donations, Custom Profile, and Personal Campaigns.N/A
Tiltify Catalyst
Score 8.2 out of 10
N/A
Tiltify Catalyst is a community-driven peer-to-peer fundraising platform designed to help nonprofits turn supporters into active fundraisers and expand donor reach. Built for modern fundraising strategies, Catalyst supports DIY fundraising, team campaigns, fitness challenges, corporate engagement initiatives, livestream fundraising, and large-scale peer-to-peer events. Catalyst prioritizes the volunteer fundraiser experience with built-in engagement tools that…N/A
Pricing
Bonterra DonorDriveTiltify Catalyst
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
Bonterra DonorDriveTiltify Catalyst
Free Trial
NoNo
Free/Freemium Version
NoYes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
YesYes
Entry-level Setup FeeRequiredNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
Bonterra DonorDriveTiltify Catalyst
Best Alternatives
Bonterra DonorDriveTiltify Catalyst
Small Businesses
Bonterra Network for Good
Bonterra Network for Good
Score 9.4 out of 10
Bonterra Network for Good
Bonterra Network for Good
Score 9.4 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
Bonterra OneCause
Bonterra OneCause
Score 8.9 out of 10
Bonterra OneCause
Bonterra OneCause
Score 8.9 out of 10
Enterprises
Blackbaud Enterprise Fundraising CRM
Blackbaud Enterprise Fundraising CRM
Score 7.6 out of 10
Blackbaud Enterprise Fundraising CRM
Blackbaud Enterprise Fundraising CRM
Score 7.6 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
Bonterra DonorDriveTiltify Catalyst
Likelihood to Recommend
9.0
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
Bonterra DonorDriveTiltify Catalyst
Likelihood to Recommend
Bonterra
I have used many fundraising and giving platforms over the years, and DonorDrive is by far the easiest and most comprehensive. I try to utilize all of the features and find that I am regularly expanding my custom reporting for outreach, prospecting, and forecasting. It is even better now that it is linked directly with Salesforce.
Read full review
Tiltify Catalyst
I mean, I love having any and all non-profits use Tiltify! From a fundraising standpoint —having all my favorite orgs easily accessible for fundraising across my platforms is SO NICE. That said, I've also worked with orgs that are just getting into the space, and they really struggled with getting set up due to a lack of resources. Yes, I can walk them through everything and encourage the use of all of Tiltify's features, but there isn't a readily available/accessible source to learn what's available to them and how it works.
Read full review
Pros
Bonterra
  • Does data calculation of key KPIs for you as soon as you pull up the event.
  • Your data is at your fingertips. Want to contact a current walker, all the info you need is right in the dashboard. No having to look the constituent up, pull a report, etc.
  • They have a great online support (chat and email features) as well as great how to videos. Saves me time as well because I can send my users there instead of having to help them troubleshoot.
Read full review
Tiltify Catalyst
  • Fundraiser & donor data collection.
  • Customizable pages & features per event.
  • Toggle-able options for non-profits to use based on their core audience and what makes the most sense for them.
Read full review
Cons
Bonterra
  • I wish that there were more standard reporting options; many of the reports I regularly use are considered "custom" by DonorDrive.
  • I wish that reports and event information were not archived so soon.
Read full review
Tiltify Catalyst
  • (1) How Tos for the charity, please! Donors/fundraisers have them available, which we LOVE, but not having a "How Set Up An Event" or "How To Use Your Reporting" for the non-profits, I feel, is a bit of an oversight, as, you know, they're users too!
  • (2) Event Page Design: Under the Fundraiser Rewards section, there is a tiny corner of pixels that pokes out from behind the "Top 100" or "Raise $200.00" labels, and it BOTHERS ME TO NO END. I understand the labels over the rewards images have curved corners, and the rewards have the hard 90-degree corners, which is why it happened. It's just like when someone goes to erase what's on a whiteboard but leaves a single line in the middle. My current solution has been to just cut that corner off my rewards images prior to upload —anyways, super tiny and just a pet peeve.
  • (3) Event Page Design: You've given us so many customization options, and I'm not taking those for granted. I would love the option to change the color of the buttons, just as we can change the color of each individual section.
  • (4) Branding, Social Links: Two things. "Twitter" is still on there (I know it's annoying, but "X"). Would love a "Bluesky" option.
  • (5) Event Options, Lifetime donor rewards: Is there something we could get for Lifetime Fundraiser rewards?
  • (6) Reports: When I download the Donations report is has the Date & Time of donation in a single column. I don't know how other people use this report, but I usually have to download the donations, create a new column, delineate the data for date/time, then pivot table from there. Plus, the "time" data we receive is delivered in a way that's borderline unusable. Example: 2023-12-31 07:46:07.667963Z -- *I* know to read this as December 31, 2023 @ 7:46:07 AM , but do we *really* need the ".667963Z" ? All it does is mess up any automated data analysis.
  • (7) Repots: Could we get a disclaimer at the top of the page that says if you don't toggle the UTC, the reports pulled will be from the time zone of the user pulling them? It took *way* too long to figure out why the report pulled by my colleague in Pacific time was different than the report pulled in Central time.
Read full review
Usability
Bonterra
I use DonorDrive daily and find it easy and efficient, but I wish many of the custom reports I run were standard and easier to run. I also wish that archived events stayed live or were open for longer. Otherwise, compared with past platforms, I much prefer the value of DonorDrive and the ease of use, and the Salesforce integration has been a game-changer.
Read full review
Tiltify Catalyst
Again, as someone who has been on this platform for a very long time, I find it easy to use. Where I find myself mostly having issues: Navigation. I have built out 40+ events & campaigns over the years (both on the fundraiser & charity side) and still find myself getting lost in the language hierarchy and difference between Setup/Event detail/Brand & marketing/Options (like those all feel semantically the same??).
Read full review
Alternatives Considered
Bonterra
I have used Blackbaud's Kintera, Team Raiser, and a few more versions
Read full review
Tiltify Catalyst
No answers on this topic
Return on Investment
Bonterra
  • Very large ROI! Our numbers grew by 17% in online fundraising in year one, and we are well on our way to seeing that increase or more in year two.
Read full review
Tiltify Catalyst
No answers on this topic
ScreenShots

Tiltify Catalyst Screenshots

Screenshot of Modern peer-to-peer fundraising pagesScreenshot of the set-up, designed to turn supporters into volunteer fundraisersScreenshot of leaderboards that keep fundraisers and donors active, engaged, and energized