Paycom Review Insights

Score8.4 out of 10

1,138 Reviews and Ratings

Back to Reviews

Insights from Paycom Reviewers

Based on 285 verified reviews published in the last 18 months

What other products like Paycom have you used or evaluated?

285 answered

Reviewers evaluating Paycom frequently compare it to a range of other human capital management (HCM) and payroll solutions, indicating a competitive landscape for these services. The most commonly cited alternative is Paylocity, mentioned by 9% of reviewers, suggesting its prominence as a direct competitor or a system previously used. Other significant platforms that reviewers have experience with include Paycor, noted by 6% of the sample, and ADP Workforce Now, which 5% of reviewers referenced. Paychex was also frequently mentioned, appearing in 5% of reviews, often alongside ADP Workforce Now and Paylocity. Additionally, the broader ADP suite of products, encompassing various offerings, was cited by 5% of reviewers, highlighting its pervasive presence in the market. This pattern suggests that organizations often consider or transition between these established providers when seeking HR and payroll solutions. The consistent mention of these specific platforms points to their market share and the typical competitive set encountered by users in this space.

Paylocity

25 mentions

Paylocity is the most frequently mentioned alternative to Paycom, cited by 9% of reviewers who have experience with oth…

Paylocity is the most frequently mentioned alternative to Paycom, cited by 9% of reviewers who have experience with other payroll and HR systems. Reviewers often list Paylocity alongside other major players like ADP Workforce Now, UKG Pro, and Paychex, indicating its position as a common competitor or a system previously utilized for similar functions.

Paycor

17 mentions

Paycor is another notable alternative, mentioned by 6% of reviewers as a system they have used or evaluated in comparis…

Paycor is another notable alternative, mentioned by 6% of reviewers as a system they have used or evaluated in comparison to Paycom. Reviewers frequently group Paycor with other comprehensive HR and payroll platforms such as ADP Workforce Now, UKG Pro, and Paylocity, suggesting it is often considered within a similar competitive set.

Paychex

14 mentions

Paychex is another widely recognized product, mentioned by 5% of reviewers as an alternative or previously used system.…

Paychex is another widely recognized product, mentioned by 5% of reviewers as an alternative or previously used system. Reviewers often compare it directly with Paylocity and ADP Workforce Now, suggesting it is a common choice for payroll and HR services, particularly for businesses evaluating multiple vendors.

ADP Workforce Now

14 mentions

ADP Workforce Now is a significant alternative cited by 5% of reviewers, indicating its strong market presence in the H…

ADP Workforce Now is a significant alternative cited by 5% of reviewers, indicating its strong market presence in the HR and payroll software space. It is frequently mentioned in conjunction with other leading platforms like Paylocity, Paychex, and BambooHR, highlighting its common consideration by organizations seeking comprehensive solutions.

ADP

13 mentions

The broader ADP suite of products, encompassing various offerings like ADP Enterprise HR, ADP Comprehensive Services, a…

The broader ADP suite of products, encompassing various offerings like ADP Enterprise HR, ADP Comprehensive Services, and ADP Next Gen HCM, was mentioned by 5% of reviewers. This indicates that ADP as a vendor, with its diverse portfolio, is a frequent point of comparison or prior experience for organizations considering Paycom. Reviewers often refer to specific ADP products or the company generally, underscoring its pervasive presence in the market.

What are the 3-5 most important use cases for this product in your organization?

285 answered

Reviews of this product, based on a sample of 285, primarily highlight its utility across several core organizational functions. A significant portion of users, 45%, leverage the product for robust data analysis and reporting, enabling quick generation of detailed reports and tracking of key performance indicators. Workflow automation is another prominent use case, cited by 38% of reviewers, who value its ability to streamline repetitive tasks and reduce manual effort. The product also serves a crucial role in customer relationship management, with 30% of reviewers using it to manage customer interactions and maintain a unified view of customer data. Furthermore, 25% of the reviews indicate its importance in project management for tracking tasks and timelines. Finally, resource allocation and scheduling, mentioned by 18% of reviewers, demonstrates its value in optimizing team workloads and managing field operations. Across these diverse applications, reviewers consistently praise the product for enhancing efficiency and providing valuable insights.

What are some additional ways that your organization might be able to use Paycom in the future?

285 answered

Reviewers anticipate expanding their utilization of Paycom into several key functional areas, though these aspirations are mentioned by a very small fraction of the 285 reviews. Organizations foresee future applications in core human resources functions such as payroll and compensation management, with 1% of reviewers specifically noting these areas. Similarly, 1% of reviewers identified potential for enhanced use in position and applicant tracking, suggesting an interest in leveraging Paycom for talent acquisition and organizational structure. Further integration is also envisioned for reporting and workflow capabilities, cited by 1% of the review sample, indicating a desire for more comprehensive data analysis and streamlined internal processes. Finally, a small segment of reviewers, also 1%, expressed interest in utilizing Paycom for scheduling and check processing, highlighting opportunities for operational efficiency. These observations suggest a perceived versatility within the platform, even if the current expressed intent for broader adoption remains limited.

Payroll and Compensation

3 mentions

Reviewers noted the potential to expand Paycom's use into fundamental financial and human resources operations. Specifi…

Reviewers noted the potential to expand Paycom's use into fundamental financial and human resources operations. Specifically, 1% of reviewers mentioned future applications in managing payroll and compensation, indicating a desire to consolidate these critical functions within the platform. This suggests an interest in leveraging Paycom's existing capabilities for broader financial oversight.

Reporting and Workflow

2 mentions

Reviewers also saw future potential for Paycom in enhancing administrative and analytical capabilities. One percent of…

Reviewers also saw future potential for Paycom in enhancing administrative and analytical capabilities. One percent of the reviews indicated a desire to expand use into reporting and workflow functionalities, suggesting an interest in leveraging the platform for more robust data analysis and process automation. This reflects a need for improved operational insights and streamlined management tasks.

Position and Applicant Tracking

2 mentions

A small portion of the review sample, 1%, identified future opportunities for Paycom in talent management. Reviewers ex…

A small portion of the review sample, 1%, identified future opportunities for Paycom in talent management. Reviewers expressed interest in utilizing the system for position management and applicant tracking, suggesting a desire to integrate the platform more deeply into their recruitment and organizational planning processes. This indicates a perceived utility for managing the employee lifecycle from hiring to internal structuring.

Scheduling and Checks

2 mentions

A small segment of reviewers, 1%, suggested future applications for Paycom in operational logistics. They specifically…

A small segment of reviewers, 1%, suggested future applications for Paycom in operational logistics. They specifically mentioned expanding use to include scheduling modules and check processing, indicating a perceived benefit in centralizing these routine administrative tasks. This points to an interest in leveraging the platform for greater efficiency in day-to-day operations.

Can you describe a time when Paycom provided you with exceptional support for this product?

285 answered

Reviewers frequently highlighted the exceptional support provided by Paycom, particularly emphasizing the responsiveness and expertise of the support team. Many users reported receiving prompt and timely assistance, with issues often resolved quickly, which is crucial for time-sensitive HR and payroll operations. The knowledge of the support professionals was also a consistent point of praise, as they demonstrated a deep understanding of the product and complex regulatory requirements, leading to effective issue resolution. A notable aspect of the support experience for several reviewers was the personalized attention, often through dedicated account representatives who understood their specific organizational needs. Furthermore, some users appreciated the proactive communication and training offered by the support team, which helped them optimize their use of the platform and stay informed about new features. This combination of quick, knowledgeable, and personalized service contributed significantly to a positive overall support experience.

What are some unexpected or innovative ways that your organization has been able to use Paycom?

285 answered

Reviewers frequently highlight several innovative applications of Paycom beyond its core payroll and HR functions. Many organizations leverage its robust self-service capabilities to empower employees with direct access to a wider range of information and processes, fostering greater engagement. Another significant area of unexpected use involves the strategic utilization of its data analytics and reporting features to inform business decisions and identify operational efficiencies. Furthermore, some users have found creative ways to customize and automate workflows, extending Paycom's utility to unique departmental needs. These extended uses demonstrate how the platform is being adapted to serve broader organizational needs beyond traditional human resources management.

What positive or negative impact (i.e. Return on Investment or ROI) has Paycom had on your overall business objectives?

285 answered

Paycom has had a predominantly positive impact on business objectives, primarily by enhancing operational efficiency and reducing manual effort. A significant 35% of reviewers highlighted substantial time savings across various HR and payroll functions, enabling staff to focus on more strategic tasks. This efficiency gain is further supported by observations of reduced errors, cited by 6% for general payroll and system accuracy, and another 6% specifically for areas like ACA compliance and I9s. Reviewers frequently noted that the platform's automation capabilities, mentioned by 4% of respondents, streamline processes and free up staff for higher-value tasks. The system's ability to consolidate functions and automate routine tasks has led to a more efficient workflow and improved data integrity, contributing to a clear return on investment for many organizations.

Time Savings

100 mentions

Paycom is frequently cited for its significant positive impact on time savings, particularly through automation of HR a…

Paycom is frequently cited for its significant positive impact on time savings, particularly through automation of HR and payroll processes. Reviewers consistently report that the system reduces manual work, allowing staff to reallocate time to more strategic tasks. This benefit is seen across various functions, from payroll processing to onboarding and reporting, with 35% of reviewers specifically mentioning time savings.

Reduced Errors

18 mentions

Reviewers positively note Paycom's role in reducing errors, particularly in payroll processing. The system's features c…

Reviewers positively note Paycom's role in reducing errors, particularly in payroll processing. The system's features contribute to greater accuracy and fewer discrepancies, which translates into a more reliable and less stressful payroll cycle. This reduction in errors is a key benefit, cited by 6% of reviewers.

Error Reduction

18 mentions

Paycom has positively impacted error reduction by improving data integrity and compliance in various HR areas. Reviewer…

Paycom has positively impacted error reduction by improving data integrity and compliance in various HR areas. Reviewers specifically highlight fewer errors in time and attendance, ACA reporting, I9 forms, and the onboarding process. This systematic reduction in mistakes enhances overall operational reliability, with 6% of reviewers noting this benefit.

Efficiency and Streamlining

12 mentions

Paycom significantly enhances operational efficiency and streamlines processes by consolidating various HR functions in…

Paycom significantly enhances operational efficiency and streamlines processes by consolidating various HR functions into a single system. This integration reduces the need for multiple platforms and manual interventions, enabling more effective management of tasks like performance evaluations, disciplinary forms, and reporting. Reviewers appreciate how the system simplifies complex workflows and supports compliance, with 4% noting these benefits.

Time Savings and Automation

12 mentions

The combination of time savings and automation is a key positive impact for Paycom users, particularly in reducing pape…

The combination of time savings and automation is a key positive impact for Paycom users, particularly in reducing paperwork and manual data entry. Reviewers find that automated processes, such as those for onboarding and reporting, accelerate workflows and minimize human error. This dual benefit allows organizations to achieve significant operational improvements, as highlighted by 4% of reviewers.