It gets the job done
February 16, 2024

It gets the job done

Anonymous | TrustRadius Reviewer
Score 5 out of 10
Vetted Review
Verified User

Software Version

WAVE Browser Extensions

Overall Satisfaction with WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool

We use this for very basic accessibility testing for our websites and applications and is by no means a comprehensive breakdown of the state of accessibility.
  • Identifies contrast errors
  • Identifies skipped headings
  • locates hidden or empty containers
  • It uses pt VS px. Nobody outside of print is using pt
  • It has some tools and they are incomplete at best
  • misidentifies inputs as needing labels (like a submit which does not require a label)
  • It's free, so it certainly does help
  • It gets the low hanging fruit quickly

Do you think WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool delivers good value for the price?

Yes

Are you happy with WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool's feature set?

Yes

Did WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool live up to sales and marketing promises?

I wasn't involved with the selection/purchase process

Did implementation of WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool go as expected?

Yes

Would you buy WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool again?

Yes

This is pretty middle of the road. It does a good job of picking out some of the low-hanging fruit, but it's not going properly evaluate semantic structure and will pop several false positives. Additionally, the tools are incomplete. For instance, the contrast editor will allow you to test your colors with sliders so you can get the closest color that passes; however, that isn't how color palettes work, you generally don't get to change a companies palette without a lot of pain; furthermore, there is no ability to adjust the font-size and both font-size AND color are used to determine contrast requirements. Oh, and they use points VS pixels...nobody is using points on the web even if the ADA uses them in their fairly dated guidelines. Text from the actual contrast editor "Text is present that has a contrast ratio less than 4.5:1, or large text (larger than 18 point or 14 point bold) has a contrast ratio less than 3:1.". 14pt = 18.66 pixels, so I can see their logic even if I don't agree with it.

WAVE Web Accessibility Evaluation Tool Feature Ratings

Accessibility Scanning and Assessment
7
Issue Ranking
8
Manual Auditing Services
5
Compliance Reporting and Tracking
2
Color/Contrast Analysis
6
HTML and CSS scanning
6