TrustRadius: an HG Insights company
Solid Edge Logo

Solid Edge Reviews and Ratings

Rating: 8.1 out of 10
Score
8.1 out of 10

Community insights

TrustRadius Insights for Solid Edge are summaries of user sentiment data from TrustRadius reviews and, when necessary, third party data sources.

Pros

Rendering Feature Efficiency: Users have consistently praised the quick and efficient rendering feature in Solid Edge, noting its significant impact on enhancing the visual representation of designs. This capability has streamlined their design process and allowed for more realistic presentations of their projects.

Compatibility with Peripherals: Customers have expressed high value for Solid Edge's compatibility with multiple peripherals, emphasizing its convenience across various setups and configurations. The seamless integration with different devices has enabled users to work efficiently without facing any technical constraints.

Ease of Tool Utilization: Reviewers have found the tools in Solid Edge to be remarkably easy to use, which has greatly contributed to a seamless design experience for them. The intuitive nature of the software's tools has empowered users to navigate through complex design tasks effortlessly and achieve desired outcomes effectively.

Reviews

16 Reviews

Solid Edge Review

Rating: 10 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

we use Solid Edge for design. we use it do draw and design to our projects

Pros

  • Solid Edge synchronous technology
  • parametric design
  • design development

Cons

  • user interface
  • technical support
  • generative AI
  • integration with other softwares

Likelihood to Recommend

it had a good accuracy and performance regarding the executing time

Vetted Review
Solid Edge
3 years of experience

Full featured CAD system

Rating: 10 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Solid Edge is an excellent Engineering tool that lets us design, simulate, draft and manufacture our customer solutions.

Pros

  • Sheet metal design
  • Assembly design
  • Simulation

Cons

  • Wider industry popularity

Likelihood to Recommend

Large assembly design for machinery works very well, as does the Teamcenter integration

Scaling faster and better with Solid Edge

Rating: 8 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

We use Solid Edge to create new designs and customize existing designs. We work with remote teams that can work on same projects remotely. Solid Edge licence management can be improved to support stand alone computers and multiple users. Like many other start ups we work remotely and don't use internet network to run a licence server. For that we need for each computer a standalone licence to run the software.

Pros

  • Team share center
  • mechanical design
  • rendering
  • FEM analysis

Cons

  • Licence management
  • Not having MAC compatibility

Likelihood to Recommend

Suited for a design needs and remote working conditions.

Not suited for small startups without servers

Solid Edge review

Rating: 9 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

So we were given a challenge in a student-run BEST/EBEC challenge. It was Siemens' sponsored challenge. First, I used Solid Edge to win the local round held at Erlangen, and then we got the chance to participate in the regional round held at TU Delft, Netherlands. We used Solid Edge software to design the task requirements given to us at the time of the challenge.

Pros

  • Generative Design tool box
  • Other CAD Designs compatibility
  • User-friendly

Cons

  • Some times it crashes very easily

Likelihood to Recommend

It's best suited in areas where you need to design something in a light environment.

Point of view from an Administrator

Rating: 8 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Solid Edge is used for building conveyor systems for intralogistics as well as constructing those.

Mostly the users complain about the performance.

Pros

  • Intuitive constructions
  • Assembly conveyors

Cons

  • Performance
  • The new vertical toolbar kills most of the drawing space
  • The context menu icons are pretty small and can't be resized to a bigger size

Likelihood to Recommend

The users that are using NX and Solid Edge simultaneously are kind of happy that both programs look pretty similar, so that can save a lot of time.

The new icons for Solid Edge-only users are difficult to see/differ from each other, especially cause we were moving from SE19 to 23.

Vetted Review
Solid Edge
1 year of experience

View from an Administrator and Developer.

Rating: 8 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

We use Solid Edge to create parts and assemblies of our logistics solutions. Our main issue is the performance of large assemblies in combination with our PDM solution. Simplified parts do not help because then the parts are even slower to download and take longer to open.

Pros

  • It's easy and intuitive to use.
  • You can customize a lot to your needs.

Cons

  • It's hard or sometimes impossible to undo certain operations.
  • Documents get "dirty" even if you just change the view.

Likelihood to Recommend

For simple steel construction, it is great. When you want to do other stuff like electrical wiring, factory planning, etc. it's not great, and the solution you can buy does not fit our needs so we need to develop our own.

Very good design and drafting application.

Rating: 10 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

In our organization total 2 departments are using solid edge, Process and Design. We are using solid edge for general-purpose CAD and for drawing and designing. The main purpose of using Solid edge is to design gauges and tools. We are managing more than 400 types of fixtures. Sometimes we have to make changes in design and need to analyze it through drawings. We also need to update drawings based on customer requirements. Sometimes we are using for creating gauges and fixtures of new product development. We have to perform Design for Manufacturing of new models and need to take look at the assembly of the machine to see if there are any diddictulty in operations. Sometimes design need to produce special models of products in that case we have to help them designing die and manufacturing tools for supplier.

Pros

  • It has very good user interface in classic or ordered environment.
  • In 2D or drafting, you can give any Geometric tolerancing and symbols to any dimension. There is a wide range of options available.
  • You can convert any files in step file (.stp) and can open it in other designing applications easily.
  • After converting 3D drawings in 2D you can make changes in 2D drawing by converting it in the draft. You can also add details like cross-sections and detailed view.
  • You can directly make threads without creating holes.

Cons

  • You can not create holes in cylindrical or curved surfaces directly. First, you will have to create a plane, and then only you can create holes or threads.
  • In synchronous mode, if you have created a drawing and then extruded it, later if you will edit the drawing there won't be any changes in subsequent parts.
  • There are some errors switching between the synchronous and ordered mode.
  • Their pattern command is a little complicated you need to see the tutorial for curved pattern.

Likelihood to Recommend

Solid edge is well suited in an industry where you have to make frequent changes in drawing and you have to keep a record of it. If you want an application for only drafting then go for Autocad. Solid Edge is not well suited for drafting because it is 3D oriented application. If you have to make a new drawing or design of things or product and then you have to analyze it for assembly and another compatibility then there is an option available for it also. It is not well suited for plant layout or other layout drawings or structural drawings.

Solid Edge for top level engineers

Rating: 8 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Solid Edge is used as the CAD software for all of the company's designs for different types of furniture. It's being used at all factory and engineering locations where both advanced designs and reverse engineering take place. It has many options to facilitate the user with a wide variety of tools to make the job a lot easier. Files are not huge so it makes it easier to run on both medium to high-end computers, therefore, companies do not have to spend thousands of dollars in equipment to be able to run this program.

Pros

  • Easy rendering
  • Fast plane selection
  • Multi-peripheral compatibility
  • Easy to use tools
  • Onsite and webinar training available

Cons

  • The ability to share files to previous version users
  • Importing more extension types
  • More training facilities worldwide

Likelihood to Recommend

For anything related to 2D or 3D design, [Siemens] Solid Edge is the tool to use. It is simple and has the best tool selection in the market. It easily transforms into CAM software by adding a few plugins. The support team is always available, on the phone or by email. Quick response time is essential for all types of business where designs are a top priority.

Vetted Review
Solid Edge
5 years of experience

Solid Edge, pioneers of designing world.

Rating: 10 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Solid Edge is an engineering software [that] provides a great plate form of 3-D designing. In our organization, new products are developed through CAD CAM analysis and this plays a vital role to produce the prototypes for analysis, coding conversation with the CNC and running MATLAB. This software is easy to use and provide[s] a great online support for any issues if generate[d] within the system.

Pros

  • It is a powerful tool for 3-D model base design
  • Customized step by step files of design
  • Easy sketch pad

Cons

  • Manu[al] tabs are should be like CATIA software

Likelihood to Recommend

It is best suited for automotive sectors for designing vehicle parts and their simulation. It is also best suited for designing process layout for all kind[s] of manufacturing industries in which processes need to be defined and displayed on the shop floor for their smooth production.

Vetted Review
Solid Edge
9 years of experience

Operationally Functional but Flawed by Design.

Rating: 7 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Siemens Solid Edge is used across out organisation as the primary Computer Aided Design package with which the company models our products in 3D and produces 2D drawings (drafts) to aid in the manufacture of products. By using a single CAD package across the whole organisation, the company is able to enforce standards and best practice on all designers. The whole organisation makes use of the product and is integrated into the Siemens Team Centre PLM suite.

Pros

  • Integration with Siemens Team Centre suite, as well as other PLM solutions.
  • Parameterisation of CAD models to allow a single design to be used in multiple applications.
  • License management which allows multiple users to be allocated a fixed number of licenses, thus saving on operational costs and meaning that costly licences are not going unused.

Cons

  • The usability of Solid Edge does not compare well to a product like SOLIDWORKS. Being a high-end CAD package, it is assumed by Siemens that training will be undertaken to learn to use the product, and thus the interface is not as user-friendly as it could be.
  • Workflows in Solid Edge are not very easy to follow and require previous experience with a specific tool to be able to figure out how to use it. Contrasted to a product like OnShape, which utilises an intuitive workflow process, Solid Edge is a challenge to get to know.
  • The cost of a Solid Edge license is not justified by the functionality that it offers. In my opinion, for the cost, there are better packages out there. With Solid Edge, you are paying for the luxury of being able to integrate into a variety of other software offerings, many of which the standard user will never touch.

Likelihood to Recommend

Well Suited for:

<ul><li>Integrated designs performed by multiple designers simultaneously (designs requiring a Product Lifecycle Management system);</li><li>Designs requiring a high degree of parameterisation;</li><li>Large companies where specific standards and best practices are applied to all models and drawings created.</li></ul>Not Well Suited for:

<ul><li>Personal use in designing one-off models and drawings;</li><li>Small business use where very few of the expensive features are actually used.</li></ul>

Vetted Review
Solid Edge
5 years of experience