TrustRadius
Magnolia V5+ Review 3 of 5
Magnolia V5+ Review: "Magnolia CMS, great on his purpose, less on documentation"
https://www.trustradius.com/cmsMagnolia (V5 and later versions)Unspecified7.218101
Davide Dispenza profile photo
March 08, 2014

Magnolia V5+ Review: "Magnolia CMS, great on his purpose, less on documentation"

Score 8 out of 101
Vetted Review
Verified User
Review Source

Software Version
4.4
Modules Used
Standard Templating Kit, Magnolia Cache Module, Magnolia DMS Module, Google Sitemap Module, RSS Aggregator, Magnolia Workflow Module, Magnolia Templating Module

Overall Satisfaction

We use it to manage the sites of the customer I work with. We use as a front end application, with a custom module we made. We don't use the authentication module to let the users login, but our secure servlets. the product lets us solve the problem of finding a templating system and a CMS application to not let IT employees change the contents of the web pages.
  • Easy to use for end users
  • You can use both jsp and ftl
  • It lets you easily develop a site for both mobile and desktop (V5 only)
  • Nice templating mechanism
  • Uninstalling modules it too messy
  • Almost no documentation
  • It uses 2 dbs (one on filesystem) and so it is impossibile to get back in case of errors when publishing new version of self made modules
  • Faster to publish content updates
  • Profiling the access at the front end management
  • Only one point to access the content which is also well organized
  • Easy to manage once in production
Next version seems to be largely improved, but managing the update will be challenging. I think that a big company needs a CMS like this for their websites. Also it is always good to have a CMS that gives you also the possibility of managing the publishing for different devices like in V5.
It is a great CMS for websites of large companies, but not suited for small companies nor blogs or simple services websites. Not so good for selling sites or intranet sites. Still good for documentation pages, showing images and videos, commercials, informative persistent sites, governative sites and so on.
I think it is still a little bit tough to update from one major version to another due to the lack of documentation.