dbForge Studio (Edge) vs. MySQL Workbench

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
dbForge Studio (Edge)
Score 8.0 out of 10
N/A
dbForge Studio is provided by Devart and is a universal front-end client for database management, administration and development. Devart's GUI tool provides utilities to compare, synchronize, and back up databases (e.g. MySQL, Oracle, SQL Server, PostgreSQL, etc.) with scheduling, and includes the possibility to analyze and report MySQL tables data. For example, dbForge Studio for MySQL works with any MariaDB database servers, and supports all MariaDB objects types. This solution enables users…
$9.95
per month
MySQL Workbench
Score 7.6 out of 10
N/A
MySQL Workbench is a unified visual tool for database architects, developers, and DBAs. MySQL Workbench provides data modeling, SQL development, and comprehensive administration tools for server configuration, user administration, and backup. MySQL Workbench is available on Windows, Linux and Mac OS X. It is available free through its Community edition, and an Enterprise edition is available for a commercial license as well, supported by Oracle.
$0
Pricing
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Editions & Modules
Standard (subcription)
$9.95
per month
Professional (subscription)
$19.95
per month
Enterprise (subscription)
$29.95
per month
Standard (subcription)
$99.95
per year
Professional (subscription)
$179.95
per year
Standard
$199.95
Enterprise (subscription)
$229.95
per year
Professional
$349.95
Enterprise
$449.95
Community Edition
$0
Enterprise Edition
licensed through Oracle
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Free Trial
YesYes
Free/Freemium Version
YesYes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Considered Both Products
dbForge Studio (Edge)
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
dbForge Studio (Edge) has much more features than other multi-platform database user interfaces, such as DBeaver or HeidiSQL, and all those features are accessible from a single user interface. SSMS is good only for MS SQL Server, so it's not good for managing multiple RDBM …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
dbForge [Studio for SQL Server] is far superior in its features, capabilities, ease [of] use, menu layout, and sophisticated design.
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
Before choosing dbForge Studio I evaluated at least a dozen tools, especially on the Visual Query Builder function. For now, I have identified only one product that has a better Visual Query Builder than dbForge Studio. This other product also manages UNIONs, while dbStudio …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
[dbForge Studio for MySQL is] easy to understand and use because it has a sample UI. We can visibly see database tables and their relationships. We can automate queries according to our use and give access according to their use. Not everyone can delete the table or modify it. …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
I would say that dbForge equals or beats most of the abilities of the other tools I evaluated at the time. dbForge had better support (Devart), and regular feature updates. dbForge has better tools for data comparison and import/export. The price tag is slightly higher, but …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
Prior to dbForge Studio for SQL Server, I have only ever used SQL Server Management Studio to manage SQL Server databases. dbForge software, in my experience, is much easier to use, more intuitive, and hence more productive, speeding up most database-related tasks such as …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)

Although we had to pay licensing fees to use dbForge, one of the main reasons we chose dbForge is compliance-related: we did not want to use freeware to analyze our database, since we are a utility company that has personally identifiable information in our databases.

Additionall…

Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
We haven't tried any other tools that do comparisons like Data Compare does. Our method prior to buying this tool was to manually run queries on each database and compare the output using text compare or by eye.
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
While DBeaver ended up being the goto for our development team, everyone else is going to be using dbForge Studio. The UI was hands down much easier to get used to, and the sorting/filtering options make it super easy for anyone to view the data the way they needed it. You …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
We found dbForge Studio for Oracle to be more stable and easy to use than both Toad for Oracle and RStudio, among others. There is still room for improvement, such as the MySQL debugger. In the past, we used MySQL Workbench, but the flexibility and robust tool set of dbForge …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
I did not make the decision to choose dbForge Studio for SQL Server. I personally like dbForge Studio because of my familiarity with the SQL server and the UI.
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
  • Much more stable than MySQL WorkBench
  • Has the power tools a db designer wishes for but lacks in free clients like HeidiSQL
  • Is being improved regularly
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
We used MySQL Workbench tool before dbForge Studio for MySQL and it did not work well. dbForge Studio for MySQL was a much more complete and flexible solution to resolve our development and administration problems. dbForge Studio for MySQL not only resolved our problems it …
Chose dbForge Studio (Edge)
I chose dbForge Studio for MySQL instead of MS SQL Server because:
1) For the most part I don't like Microsoft products. Their UIs are notoriously bad, and you never know when a product tweak will create incompatibilities that will require an expensive upgrade.
2) Since our …
MySQL Workbench
Chose MySQL Workbench
It's like comparing a VW to an performance car like a Ferrari. If you need the performance, bells and whistles you'll want PhpStorm. If you just need to get from one place to another, MySQL Workbench will do just fine.
Chose MySQL Workbench
phpmyadmin is way better only when local database is concerned but MySQL Workbench is way better then SQLyog because of the more cleaner UI and cost. SQLYog does not have any open-source featuring whereas MySQL Workbench has open source edition with lot of good free features. …
Chose MySQL Workbench
I found Azure UX easier, menu items are more obvious, but it still also requires preparation to use.
Features
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Database Development
Comparison of Database Development features of Product A and Product B
dbForge Studio (Edge)
8.4
Ratings
1% below category average
MySQL Workbench
9.2
Ratings
8% above category average
Version control tools8.00 Ratings00 Ratings
Test data generation7.00 Ratings00 Ratings
Performance optimization tools9.00 Ratings00 Ratings
Schema maintenance9.00 Ratings8.50 Ratings
Database change management9.00 Ratings10.00 Ratings
Database Administration
Comparison of Database Administration features of Product A and Product B
dbForge Studio (Edge)
7.0
Ratings
14% below category average
MySQL Workbench
8.2
Ratings
2% above category average
User management6.00 Ratings9.00 Ratings
Database security6.00 Ratings8.50 Ratings
Database status reporting7.00 Ratings7.50 Ratings
Change management9.00 Ratings8.00 Ratings
Best Alternatives
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Small Businesses
DBeaver
DBeaver
Score 8.5 out of 10
DBeaver
DBeaver
Score 8.5 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
DBeaver
DBeaver
Score 8.5 out of 10
DBeaver
DBeaver
Score 8.5 out of 10
Enterprises
DBeaver
DBeaver
Score 8.5 out of 10
DBeaver
DBeaver
Score 8.5 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Likelihood to Recommend
9.8
(0 ratings)
7.5
(0 ratings)
Usability
-
(0 ratings)
8.6
(0 ratings)
Support Rating
8.0
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
dbForge Studio (Edge)MySQL Workbench
Likelihood to Recommend
Whenever a user or DBA wants to compare schematics between two environments, dbForge is extremely helpful. This is useful during version or framework upgrades, a database upgrade, patch implementations, service package implementations, or any time to environments would be different. The time it would take to write and execute queries, and then compare is exponentially longer than it takes with dbForge, where this is done and you have an application that allows you to quickly identify incongruities.
Read full review
It works best when you need to create basic queries or manage an simple MySQL schema. For more complicated data modeling, I'll use another tool. You can't beat the price though.
Read full review
Pros
  • Compare entire or subset of MySQL tables between databases
  • Configure comparison rules
  • Sync data between compared databases depending on differences
  • Save comparison rules for reuse and sharing
  • Break down differences between missing/new records, or different records
  • See differences highlighted per field
  • Execute sync immediately, or save as an SQL script file
  • Command-line tool that can be used to add comparisons to deploy scripts
Read full review
  • Send queries to DB
  • Export results in csv
Read full review
Cons
  • [The] installation error I've already reported (ABARTN).xml [could use some improvement]. This has to do with Windows Defender (the default Windows anti-virus) not allowing the installation on the default installation directory of dbForge Studio [for SQL Server], thus the error. [With] the workaround, [I] was to disable the anti-virus for the duration of the installation, then turn it back on when the installation [was] been completed.
  • [I would like to see] better defined licensing models for larger teams (seated vs. name licenses).
Read full review
  • On the Mac version, quitting always throws an exception. More of an annoyance but still. This should have been fixed a long time ago.
Read full review
Usability
dbForge Studio (Edge) has a great UI and it's versatile, but it still has some glitches. Its multiple database support makes it possible to stick with only one UI to handle different RDBM systems, even though you have to redefine user credentials for each new connection (no copying/cloning feature for database connections). The Edit View and diagramming features also could be improved.
Read full review
Quite complicated. It's unrealistic to use without prior preparation (guides on youtube or colleagues' help).
Read full review
Support Rating
Although experience here is limited, as only one question has been asked and answered promptly, the registration and licensing process was very smooth and professional. There are forums online that discuss dbForge issues, as well as a Facts and Questions section on dbForge's website, so product support does seem to exist if needed.
Read full review
No answers on this topic
Alternatives Considered
I would say that dbForge equals or beats most of the abilities of the other tools I evaluated at the time. dbForge had better support (Devart), and regular feature updates. dbForge has better tools for data comparison and import/export. The price tag is slightly higher, but renewals rates are pretty good. It's a quality tool that still is well worth the cost.
Read full review
phpMyAdmin is way better only when local database is concerned but MySQL Workbench is way better then SQLyog because of the more cleaner UI and cost. SQLyog does not have any open-source featuring whereas MySQL Workbench has open source edition with lot of good free features. So MySQL Workbench is powerful than SQLyog.
Read full review
Return on Investment
  • We perform better and faster syncing analysis between databases.
  • We update running mysql databases faster and more efficiently.
  • Especially with MySQL Workbench we had immense irritations due to all the crashes during the day. With dbForge Studio we finally had a power tool which is stable and does not crash constantly.
Read full review
  • It provides good features and saves the time.
  • When we use remote server, we can connect without using ssh etc. so saves the time and easy to understand.
  • Do not have to write the queries to check the schema, so saves the time.
Read full review
ScreenShots

dbForge Studio (Edge) Screenshots

Screenshot of Code CompletionScreenshot of Schema CompareScreenshot of Database DiagramScreenshot of Data ExportScreenshot of Database design & developmentScreenshot of Visual query building