6 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow noopener'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 8.7 out of 100
58 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow noopener'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 8.2 out of 100

Feature Set Ratings

  • SAP Manufacturing Execution ranks higher in 3 feature sets: Customization, Security, Inventory Management
  • Workday Financial Management ranks higher in 1 feature set: Reporting & Analytics

Customization

10.0

SAP Manufacturing Execution

100%
8.8

Workday Financial Management

88%
SAP Manufacturing Execution ranks higher in 2/2 features

API for custom integration

10.0
100%
1 Rating
8.7
87%
4 Ratings

Plug-ins

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
4 Ratings

Security

10.0

SAP Manufacturing Execution

100%
9.3

Workday Financial Management

93%
SAP Manufacturing Execution ranks higher in 2/2 features

Single sign-on capability

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.5
95%
6 Ratings

Role-based user permissions

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
5 Ratings

Reporting & Analytics

8.7

SAP Manufacturing Execution

87%
8.9

Workday Financial Management

89%
SAP Manufacturing Execution ranks higher in 2/3 features

Dashboards

7.0
70%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
7 Ratings

Standard reports

9.0
90%
1 Rating
8.8
88%
7 Ratings

Custom reports

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
7 Ratings

Inventory Management

10.0

SAP Manufacturing Execution

100%
9.0

Workday Financial Management

90%
SAP Manufacturing Execution ranks higher in 4/4 features

Inventory tracking

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
1 Rating

Automatic reordering

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
1 Rating

Location management

10.0
100%
1 Rating
9.0
90%
1 Rating

Manufacturing module

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Manufacturing

10.0

SAP Manufacturing Execution

100%

Workday Financial Management

Feature Set Not Supported
N/A
SAP Manufacturing Execution ranks higher in 6/6 features

Production Process Design

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Production Management

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Configuration Management

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Work Definition

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Work Execution

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Advanced Fulfillment

10.0
100%
1 Rating
N/A
0 Ratings

Payroll Management

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Feature Set Not Supported
N/A
8.1

Workday Financial Management

81%
Workday Financial Management ranks higher in 5/5 features

Pay calculation

N/A
0 Ratings
8.0
80%
4 Ratings

Benefit plan administration

N/A
0 Ratings
8.0
80%
4 Ratings

Direct deposit files

N/A
0 Ratings
8.5
85%
4 Ratings

Salary revision and increment management

N/A
0 Ratings
8.0
80%
3 Ratings

Reimbursement management

N/A
0 Ratings
8.0
80%
4 Ratings

General Ledger and Configurable Accounting

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Feature Set Not Supported
N/A
7.9

Workday Financial Management

79%
Workday Financial Management ranks higher in 10/10 features

Accounts payable

N/A
0 Ratings
7.0
70%
4 Ratings

Accounts receivable

N/A
0 Ratings
7.0
70%
4 Ratings

Global Financial Support

N/A
0 Ratings
8.3
83%
5 Ratings

Primary and Secondary Ledgers

N/A
0 Ratings
8.3
83%
5 Ratings

Intercompany Accounting

N/A
0 Ratings
8.5
85%
5 Ratings

Localizations

N/A
0 Ratings
7.5
75%
3 Ratings

Journals and Reconciliations

N/A
0 Ratings
6.5
65%
4 Ratings

Configurable Accounting

N/A
0 Ratings
9.0
90%
6 Ratings

Centralized Rules Framework

N/A
0 Ratings
8.5
85%
6 Ratings

Standardized Processes

N/A
0 Ratings
8.5
85%
6 Ratings

Order Management

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Feature Set Not Supported
N/A
8.5

Workday Financial Management

85%
Workday Financial Management ranks higher in 1/1 features

Credit card processing

N/A
0 Ratings
8.5
85%
3 Ratings

Attribute Ratings

  • SAP Manufacturing Execution is rated higher in 1 area: Likelihood to Recommend

Likelihood to Recommend

9.0

SAP Manufacturing Execution

90%
1 Rating
8.3

Workday Financial Management

83%
7 Ratings

Usability

SAP Manufacturing Execution

N/A
0 Ratings
7.8

Workday Financial Management

78%
4 Ratings

Support Rating

SAP Manufacturing Execution

N/A
0 Ratings
8.5

Workday Financial Management

85%
4 Ratings

Likelihood to Recommend

SAP

SAP Manufacturing Execution is suitable for desecrate manufacturing. For the complex routing of the product, this software ensures users do not by mistake start executing the wrong steps. This is the best tool to track and work on nonconformance and rework scenarios. This is most suitable when the landscape has SAP ERP in place.
Read full review

Workday

Financial reporting is sometimes tricky in our field because
some oil and gas fields are depleted, and the standard methods of activating
abandoned oil wells will have high-cost variability. Therefore, in this scenario, Workday Financial Management made internal financial reporting statements pretty seamless, where initial
bid and field cost can be incorporated very easily in an asset-wise manner.
Also, cloud-based sharing was never a problem, and our lease operators never had
a problem understanding which reports belong to which asset.
Read full review

Pros

SAP

  • Visual routing ensures the production line layout is as appropriate as shown on the application.
  • Production house needs a lot of data to do an in-process inspection of the product. ERP might not need that. SAP ME provides that place to do every data collection.
  • Nonconformance functionality ensures when needed the product goes to the appropriate station to get repaired. Also, data collection can raise NC and can move the product to a particular station to get an issue corrected.
  • All the information is well integrated with SAP ERP and makes SAP ME more valuable for the organization.
  • SAP MII also comes along with SAP ME helps to get the application well integrated with the shop floor equipment.
Read full review

Workday

  • Workday is very organized and user friendly. I haven't heard this from any of my co workers that they faced a hard time navigating around or getting technical support.
  • The platform offers variety of options for the company to offer to their employees. This includes easy access to their time off balance, hours they have worked, and accessing pay stubs any time.
  • One of the biggest thing I notice on a lot of technical platforms is that they don't notify their users of any updates they may be making on their website but workday does a great job of notifying its user way ahead of time of any updates they may be doing
Read full review

Cons

SAP

  • ODS or the BI part of the ME needed more improvement.
  • The archiving job needs to be more robust.
  • Database indexes need to me more analyzed and setup as per the organization requirement.
  • SAP MII UI integration plugin to be developed for increased usability of this application.
Read full review

Workday

  • We were surprised by the lack of user guides and supporting information for day-to-day users. Granted, we could find this, but our users like guides.
  • The system could improve with contact help and chat functions if you need the answers quickly. We figured this would all have been built in.
  • Quite surprised by the lack of treasury management functionality. SAP and Oracle have it, although their modules are not that comprehensive or user friendly.
Read full review

Pricing Details

SAP Manufacturing Execution

Starting Price

Editions & Modules

SAP Manufacturing Execution editions and modules pricing
EditionModules

Footnotes

    Offerings

    Free Trial
    Free/Freemium Version
    Premium Consulting/Integration Services

    Entry-level set up fee?

    No setup fee

    Additional Details

    Workday Financial Management

    Starting Price

    Editions & Modules

    Workday Financial Management editions and modules pricing
    EditionModules

    Footnotes

      Offerings

      Free Trial
      Free/Freemium Version
      Premium Consulting/Integration Services

      Entry-level set up fee?

      No setup fee

      Additional Details

      Usability

      SAP

      No answers on this topic

      Workday

      Workday is easy enough navigate, as long as it is properly set up. With that said, it can be put together in a modular fashion as well, allowing for a very high degree of flexibility in terms of design and process delegation. Finally, it makes consolidation achievable in times previously unthinkable.
      Read full review

      Support Rating

      SAP

      No answers on this topic

      Workday

      Our support team has been awesome. They are extremely knowledgeable and have been able to guide us through all of the challenges we have faced. Workday's community online is also extremely helpful with many trainings and help topics that can be reviewed at your convenience.
      Read full review

      Alternatives Considered

      SAP

      There was no product evaluated before using SAP ME. This replaced the custom homegrown MES system. The custom MES system had a lot of issues with the integration with SAP ERP. While evaluating the situation, SAP MII was the initial tool used to create the integration of the custom MES. We later found the fully functional tool SAP ME off the shelf had several functionalities out of the box.
      Read full review

      Workday

      I miss using Workday Financial Managment, and if I moved departments or took on more responsibilities with the financials I would definitely recommend it!
      Read full review

      Return on Investment

      SAP

      • Production house is more efficient now.
      • Less paperwork improved means less unproductive work on the shop floor.
      • Regulatory audits are more efficient.
      Read full review

      Workday

      • Quick and non-glitchy financial reporting.
      • As more people use it, inter-department talks are always there as HR and Project managers are talking about the same software.
      • The disturbance in service is no longer the problem as It integrates the three different sectors of financial reporting.
      Read full review

      Add comparison