TrustRadius: an HG Insights company

Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches Reviews and Ratings

Rating: 8.6 out of 10
Score
8.6 out of 10

Community insights

TrustRadius Insights for Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches are summaries of user sentiment data from TrustRadius reviews and, when necessary, third party data sources.

Pros

Reliable Performance in Extreme Temperatures: Users have consistently reported experiencing reliable performance, noting that the device operates reliably even under extreme temperature conditions, surpassing its limits effectively. This durability ensures continuous operation in challenging environments and enhances user confidence in the product's resilience.

Enhanced Functionality with Compatible Software and Sensors: Customers appreciate the device's compatibility with Layer2 nat and Cybervision sensor, which significantly enhances its functionality and versatility. The seamless integration of these features expands the device's capabilities for various applications.

Efficient Networking and Security Management: Reviewers have praised the device for its efficient networking capabilities, robust security management features, and comprehensive network planning options. The combination of these aspects streamlines operations, strengthens data protection measures, and facilitates strategic network development.

Reviews

8 Reviews

My IE journey

Rating: 9 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

SCADA networks in hydro power plants.

We need high redundant Networks in form of MRP rings together with a DC power Terminal and a signal contact.

We use features like MAB and Dot1x for client authentication and use some switches with additional modules to gain more Ports. The Scope is to connect all industrial controllers to a centralized monitoring station

Pros

  • Modulare Cards / additional Modules
  • Form Factor / Din Rail mount and DC Power
  • The Featureset of modern IT Switches

Cons

  • MRP Ring buggy in the beginning
  • at least one more SFP Port on base model
  • complicated licensing

Likelihood to Recommend

Everything in the OT Sector works well with it - it is not really useful for big IT Networks or Rack deployment.

They are very useful to mount in Electrical Cabinets in the filed and in harsh environment. Alarming with the signal contact works very well. The design without fans is very important for us

Vetted Review
Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches
2 years of experience

Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches for industrial environments

Rating: 8 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Deploy Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches as part of the Cisco SD-Access solution, for cabinets with limited space where enterprise grade switches don't fit.

Pros

  • Small form factor
  • Integrate as part of Cisco SD-Access solution

Cons

  • Only supported as policy extended node in Cisco SD-Access

Likelihood to Recommend

Suits for smaller cabinets where enterprise switches don't fit, or harsh environment where rugged devices are needed. Only support as policy extended node in SD-Access solution.

Vetted Review
Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches
2 years of experience

Cisco Review

Rating: 9 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

We use this product in our agriculture and education environment. Because that environment is not cooled, so we needed something that could handle being in the California heat and it has just continued to chug along. Provides all the POE I need out in that facility.

Pros

  • It runs no matter how hot it gets. It's actually operated at times when it was exceeding its operational limits and continued to work.

Cons

  • N/A

Likelihood to Recommend

It's most appropriate in spots where you don't have active cooling of your network equipment. And it performs very well in those environments. It's a little bit less appropriate for high-density environments due to the limited number of switchboards and the limited POE on the switch.

Vetted Review
Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches
3 years of experience

3400 switches - a way of providing multiple NAT instances all with one switch

Rating: 8 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

We use the switches as layer2 NAT devices for multiple production lines

Pros

  • Layer2 nat
  • Can also run a cybervision sensor
  • Runs on 24v dc provided by DIN rail system

Cons

  • If used for running a cybervision sensor it runs off an as card. Would be nice if it could run on internal flash
  • Would be more convenient if it came with 110v to 24v power supply
  • Not the cheapest switch but quality is important to maintain.
  • We originally wanted to use layer3 router to solve our problem. An inexpensive 2port could also have been used for what we needed.

Likelihood to Recommend

Very good for clean room environments. Haven’t tested in other environments.

Effective Risk Assessment and New Networks Creation and Distribution System.

Rating: 9 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Easy networking and network performance management product. The easy to plan network and network security control using Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches is impressive. Dataflow management security with great data threats management functions. This Cisco platform helps generate perfect data analytics and feedback gathering features are nice and data processing tools are perfect.

Pros

  • Networking.
  • Security management.
  • Network planning.

Cons

  • Only setting the interface security.
  • Managing various networks traffics.
  • Advance features setting when new to the system.

Likelihood to Recommend

Amazing network management and extremely perfect network security production and its notification options are very responsive. Creating real time analytics and the visualization capability is fantastic. This Cisco Catalyst platform has effective insights gathering tools and its data quality control functions are good and quick on process reports preparation and workflow easy management product.

IE3400, worth the bucks for you or not?

Rating: 7 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

Used as an access-switch (with POE) for connecting all the systems needed for Road and car-tunnels. Common protocols used in the tunnels are Profinet and Modbus/TCP, Radar data-streams and Multicast for video. The IE3400 switches are connected in a double star Singlemode fiber architecture to distributions switches (also Cisco).

Pros

  • Excellent installation (DIN)
  • Good software (normal IOS configuration)
  • Good temperatur range

Cons

  • The portdensity is poor (when compared to competition) which means that the IE-switches takes more space then competition.
  • The price is not competitive, only possible to ship/sell to customers that are set on the Brand. To say that Cisco has more features (to motivate that these units cost more then the double) is not correct, the competition solves the same stuff differently.

Likelihood to Recommend

In industrial environment where you are using Profinet and/or Modbus/TCP and have a need for extended temperature/humidity the switches are a good choice. Architecture-wise they match ring-topology design and should be used for that kind of network-design.

Do be aware that there is a fierce competition, many rugged switches from competiting brands can do the same thing for less then half the price. So if budget is tight, this is not the best choice.

Vetted Review
Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches
5 years of experience

Industrial Network with Cisco Catalyst IE3400

Rating: 10 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

This series of switches is used by one of our customers in their production lines. All in an industrial environment where the good performance of these devices is very important. There is no room for failures since if so, production is interrupted. These switches have been operating correctly. In addition, the Cisco Industrial Network Director software is used in conjunction to monitor this network effectively. These switches are compact in size. They have no moving mechanical parts, such as fans, so the body of the device itself works as a heat sink. All of this helps with tight spaces in industrial cabinets

Pros

  • Excellent performance in industrial environments
  • There is the possibility to save the configuration on an SD card. If the need to change the switch arises, simply insert the SD card with the saved settings into the new switch
  • monitoring of processing, temperature, cpu, etc. through its web interface is very simple
  • Express Setup feature makes the job of initial switch configuration much easier

Cons

  • The switch gets very hot, but this is normal because the body of the device acts as a heat sink. You just have to be careful if you are going to touch the switch when it is running
  • I haven't really found anything to improve, having the Catalyst ios everything works fine

Likelihood to Recommend

Cisco Catalyst IE3400 Rugged Series Switches is perfect for industrial environments where OT devices are connected. In the scenario where we are using them, a ring-type topology was used with the REP protocol. A scenario where it may not be the best option is in office or IT environments, because a special rail is needed to be mounted in cabinets, and due to its physical characteristics it is not appropriate to coexist with non-industrial switches.

Found it worth to use.

Rating: 9 out of 10
Incentivized

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

We always trust Cisco switches when it comes to the smooth operation of IoT devices; from quick switching to delivering a continuous connection, they are experts at what they do. They are very expandable and provide with the excellent care, and they are, without a doubt, Cisco products. We've used these catalyst switches for a long time and have never had a line go down.

Pros

  • Stable connection.
  • Better optical fiber connection output.
  • Easy configuration.

Cons

  • Added mobile interface.
  • Control gain feature.

Likelihood to Recommend

The primary switch and support switch are excellent and have numerous features. It takes a while for the Switch to boot up, but once it does, it runs practically flawlessly. Cisco Catalyst switches are best suited for critical scenarios that require superior efficiency and connectivity for vital applications.

Video reviews