Mailtastic vs. Newoldstamp

I would recommend it for anyone who bases their initial setup on Microsoft 365 environment as it is the easiest way to manage licences and users. It is intuitive to set up and use, signatures appear instantly, campaign updates are live, and metrics can be nicely reported. There are not so many points that one can complain about in regards to Mailtastic, maybe some OS or platforms have lack of support, but that is it.

Incentivized

I actually recommend Newoldstamp to colleagues quite often. It is an excellent and simple product that does exactly what is promised. On the rare occasion that technical support was needed, the support team was very quick to respond, knowledgeable and able to resolve my issue promptly every single time. It seems as though I have been working with the same technical support people as well which I would assume means they have a high employee retention rate, this is always a plus.

• Signature Management Organization wide
• Time based campaigns
• Signature data reporting and metrics
• Campaign dashboards
• Device Adaptivity

Incentivized

• Numerous template options for signatures
• Easy to add social media handles
• Get a report based on signature clicks. Helpful to see how the signature is performing.

Incentivized

• Formatting per email client/mailbox provider
• Wider pricing options or Plans not per user
• Wider MacOS support
• MacOS integration done not via apple mail signatures
• Unified and automatic integration for all Mail app versions (online, mobile, desktop app)

Incentivized

• Would like an option to purchase one or two signatures additionally rather than just in bulk; as a small company, when we hire people, we just need one or two additional signatures
• Allow us to design our own banners in the platform itself using our own pictures

Great tool to use in every aspect. There are apps for PC and Mac OS, extensions for Outlook, online versions support. There are tons of materials and FAQs on how to Mailtastic setup for a platform or environment. It takes off a lot of time from administrator of the product as users can connect themselves to this system.

Incentivized

Creating, updating, duplicating, and organizing signatures is effortless. While we're good designers and could create HTML signatures ourselves, we don't need to. Newoldstamp does it for us.

Great product at a fair price. Does what it promises. Easy to use. Great customer support. Checks all the boxes.

I'd previously tried to use email signature generators purchased from Graphiriver with little success (too fiddly). Also used the HubSpot free offering but that had severe limitations.

• More leads and interactions originating from emails
• Tracking email interactions
• Requires upkeep and internal management

Incentivized

• Helped the team to appear more professional by having a clean looking email signature
• Has helped clients, vendors, etc. find us easily and know how to contact us via email or phone number

Incentivized