SAP Transportation Management vs. Trimble Fleet Mobility

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
SAP Transportation Management
Score 8.8 out of 10
N/A
The SAP Transportation Management application integrates fleet and logistics management throughout the user's network, to help reduce transportation complexity. The solution offers on-premise and cloud deployment, transportation and demand planning, interactive freight tendering, and a collaboration portal.N/A
Trimble Fleet Mobility
Score 9.0 out of 10
N/A
N/AN/A
Pricing
SAP Transportation ManagementTrimble Fleet Mobility
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
SAP Transportation ManagementTrimble Fleet Mobility
Free Trial
NoNo
Free/Freemium Version
NoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
SAP Transportation ManagementTrimble Fleet Mobility
User Ratings
SAP Transportation ManagementTrimble Fleet Mobility
Likelihood to Recommend
7.7
(8 ratings)
8.8
(3 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
7.3
(1 ratings)
7.0
(3 ratings)
Usability
7.3
(6 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Online Training
-
(0 ratings)
1.0
(1 ratings)
User Testimonials
SAP Transportation ManagementTrimble Fleet Mobility
Likelihood to Recommend
SAP
In situation such as optimum shipping point given the network complexity, it suggests the best lane to select for the load to transport and its mode, the scope of the less appropriate is visualization with better 3D load plan images to improve user experience to plan with load routes with efficacy
Read full review
Trimble
Appian is well suited for optimization of routes and contrary to what Appian claims, it is not well suited for scheduling.
Read full review
Pros
SAP
  • Capturing Logs and objects of each change/ transport
  • Automatic movement of changes via the SAP Transportation Management queue
  • Setting up workflow to automate the client specific and SID specific movements
  • Express the configuration graphically very well
  • Ease of changing configuration of SAP Transportation Management and moving it through the landscape.
Read full review
Trimble
  • Appian is excellent for use in both the analysis arena and ongoing operations support. The speed to solution and quality of solution is at the top of the market.
  • The configurability of the system gives the user the flexibility to address almost any route problem imaginable. Analysts have the ability to recreate the "world" to fit their customer's needs rather than forcing the customer into a predetermined framework.
  • The installation of the software is flexible and can be structured to fit any work group's format, from a centralized core to a distributed mobile analysis team.
Read full review
Cons
SAP
  • Planning and execution area for carriers is not covered fully. It has scenarious covered, but its mainly manual and not suited for high volumes and loads
  • Intermodal transportation management - absent or inefficient
  • Trailer swap functionality is like 10 steps process, which is highly manually consuming and is not efficient for company operating >5000 trucks and trailers
Read full review
Trimble
  • Transit times are sometimes inaccurate/inconsistent.
  • Software can slow down as a route file undergoes many changes.
  • Large quantity of input files can sometimes create confusion/inconsistency when route files are shared by multiple users.
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
SAP
SAP TM delivers strong value in planning, cost control, and system integration. While complex and sometimes heavy to maintain, its long-term benefits and alignment with SAP’s digital logistics roadmap make renewal very likely.
Read full review
Trimble
Many issues with the system and I will probably recommend other type of software if the question arises. Because of the investment my company has made, I will use the system for now.
Read full review
Usability
SAP
Overall rating is 8 as it is easy to use and navigate, creates purchase requisites and order with less complexity, no complex and analytical training required which helps to onboard the person easily on this software, even if have problem you figure it out by your own by simply searching on net or SAP customer support
Read full review
Trimble
No answers on this topic
Alternatives Considered
SAP
It allows to integrate an e2e flow from business process to finance and people management, which in logistic business are the resources for logistic execution. Analytics are obviously allows us to analyze the metrics and make data driven decisions.
Read full review
Trimble
Appian was best suited for an analysis environment both functionally and from a cost structure standpoint. Other packages are targeting ongoing operations and their cost structures reflect that goal. The purely analytical environment can underestimated in these situations. There is definitely a need for non operation specific analysis tools in the marketplace.
Read full review
Return on Investment
SAP
  • Enables movement of code changes through the landscape seamlessly
  • We have a busy shop and it doesn't matter if a project with 1000+ changes or 100 changes, the system handles it very well. The business is happy that we can move all these changes at one go
  • One feature would be to identify if the changes are to some core objects in the system then take an automatic backup or at least give that option.
Read full review
Trimble
  • Improved service to customers by being more aware of ETA's and how they relate to each store's receiving hours.
  • Reduced transportation costs in dynamic environment where routes are optimized daily using Direct Route.
  • Better customer service to field by generating e-mail notifications for following day's ETA's, along with notifications when trips are behind schedule.
Read full review
ScreenShots