athenaOne vs. eClinicalWorks

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
athenaOne
Score 7.3 out of 10
N/A
athenahealth headquartered in Watertown offers athenaOne, an integrated suite of its products providing a total medical practice management solution.N/A
eClinicalWorks
Score 5.8 out of 10
N/A
eClinicalWorks headquartered in Westborough offers their EHR / EMR solution, which can be upgraded to a full practice management solution at higher pricing tiers.N/A
Pricing
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Free Trial
NoNo
Free/Freemium Version
NoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Top Pros
Top Cons

No answers on this topic

Features
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Billing and Claims Management
Comparison of Billing and Claims Management features of Product A and Product B
athenaOne
-
Ratings
eClinicalWorks
4.7
18 Ratings
51% below category average
Real-time eligibility verification00 Ratings4.717 Ratings
Claims management00 Ratings4.315 Ratings
Coding00 Ratings5.216 Ratings
Patient billing00 Ratings5.216 Ratings
Financial Reporting00 Ratings4.315 Ratings
Patient Scheduling
Comparison of Patient Scheduling features of Product A and Product B
athenaOne
-
Ratings
eClinicalWorks
3.5
22 Ratings
78% below category average
Rule-based scheduling00 Ratings4.421 Ratings
Automated appointment reminders00 Ratings4.517 Ratings
Automated patient check-in00 Ratings2.217 Ratings
Multi-location support00 Ratings1.720 Ratings
Calendar interface00 Ratings4.817 Ratings
Electronic Medical Records
Comparison of Electronic Medical Records features of Product A and Product B
athenaOne
-
Ratings
eClinicalWorks
3.3
25 Ratings
78% below category average
Charting / document management00 Ratings2.725 Ratings
Templates00 Ratings4.023 Ratings
Patient portal00 Ratings3.920 Ratings
Mobile/tablet support00 Ratings6.115 Ratings
Fax integration00 Ratings3.022 Ratings
Integration with other EMR and PM systems00 Ratings1.618 Ratings
Workflow automation00 Ratings1.523 Ratings
Speech recognition00 Ratings5.115 Ratings
Customization00 Ratings2.220 Ratings
E-prescribing00 Ratings2.723 Ratings
Medical Security and Privacy
Comparison of Medical Security and Privacy features of Product A and Product B
athenaOne
-
Ratings
eClinicalWorks
3.9
23 Ratings
73% below category average
HIPAA compliance00 Ratings8.041 Ratings
Role-based permission levels00 Ratings3.222 Ratings
Data backups and redundancy00 Ratings3.220 Ratings
Local mode / networking failsafe00 Ratings1.317 Ratings
Workflow and Scale
Comparison of Workflow and Scale features of Product A and Product B
athenaOne
-
Ratings
eClinicalWorks
2.2
22 Ratings
113% below category average
Task tracking00 Ratings2.219 Ratings
Specialty-specific workflows00 Ratings2.220 Ratings
Multi-office / multi-physician capabilities00 Ratings2.221 Ratings
Best Alternatives
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Small Businesses
Kareo Practice Management
Kareo Practice Management
Score 7.6 out of 10
athenaClinicals
athenaClinicals
Score 7.3 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
CareLogic EHR, by Qualifacts
CareLogic EHR, by Qualifacts
Score 8.4 out of 10
athenaClinicals
athenaClinicals
Score 7.3 out of 10
Enterprises
Epic
Epic
Score 8.0 out of 10
Allscripts Professional EHR
Allscripts Professional EHR
Score 8.9 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Likelihood to Recommend
10.0
(1 ratings)
1.9
(25 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
-
(0 ratings)
2.0
(1 ratings)
Usability
-
(0 ratings)
2.2
(4 ratings)
Performance
-
(0 ratings)
4.0
(2 ratings)
Support Rating
-
(0 ratings)
1.0
(4 ratings)
In-Person Training
-
(0 ratings)
2.0
(1 ratings)
Implementation Rating
-
(0 ratings)
4.0
(2 ratings)
User Testimonials
athenaOneeClinicalWorks
Likelihood to Recommend
athenahealth
Very well suited for outpatient multi-specialty clinics. May not be perfect for hospital based practices, but I am not in a position to say that with conviction as we are not hospital based organization.
Read full review
eClinicalWorks
eClinicalWorks should be used in most medical situations. The program generally speaking works the way it should keeping track of patient records and the like. They have recently added an inpatient module for ASCs. Seems to work pretty well for smaller practices that don't require a lot of additional features or integrations.
Read full review
Pros
athenahealth
  • Very easy to keep track of quality measures.
  • Easy to track suspect conditions, care gaps.
  • Easy to review performance of providers across the whole organization.
Read full review
eClinicalWorks
  • One of the strengths of ECW can also be a weakness depending on the user's perception. ECW has a lot of redundancies. There are multiple pathways to perform a task. It can be appealing to advanced computer users because of the versatility. I have found that it tends to confuse lesser experienced computer users.
  • The creation of templates is very easy and any provider in our system can create one. It definitely makes documentation more efficient. By creating a set of templates for the clinic, we are able to standardize the orders/procedures along established guidelines.
  • We have converted our scheduling to open access. ECW allows us to set the follow up time and the end of the visit and then an alert is created. Front office staff can run the report and schedule patients closer to the actual time. It has improved our no show/cancellation rates.
Read full review
Cons
athenahealth
  • At this point I can not think of anything that I am missing.
Read full review
eClinicalWorks
  • Meaningful Use Reports should be capturing data in real time and generated fairly quickly instead of the MAQ dashboard extraction process.
  • Their support teams are not very helpful at certain topics such as the definition/logic of Meaningful Use calculations. These are generally difficult to determine but several cases in regards to Meaningful Use take several days before it gets addressed.
  • Training videos would be helpful on their support website.
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
athenahealth
No answers on this topic
eClinicalWorks
If we had an option to easily switch to another EMR product we would. However, an EMR keeps you invested solidly in it - once you've started you're then going to be stuck with it. The investment into the data in the system are such that you have no real option to back out of what you are in and move into something else. Again, if we could, we would immediately move to another EMR. The ability to use it and be supported by the vendor has decreased nearly to the point of inability to use.
Read full review
Usability
athenahealth
No answers on this topic
eClinicalWorks
[In my opinion] the features allowed by the system are not designed for providers. [I think] the systems are inefficient, and new features tend to be "bolt on" features either as products purchased and added from other providers or simply a module created and strapped onto the software. There doesn't seem to be much idea around making things easier for the provider, though they like to state that provider burnout is something they are working on.
Read full review
Performance
athenahealth
No answers on this topic
eClinicalWorks
I often cannot assign a proper diagnosis under the assessment section; and as mentioned, sometimes (about once a month) the dictation just freezes because "the request has timed out" (even restarting the iPhone/ laptop does not help).
Read full review
Support Rating
athenahealth
No answers on this topic
eClinicalWorks
You put in support cases through a support portal. [I believe] for no apparent reason, the company decided that their support cannot have access to actual patient records and as a result, it's required that they have to connect remotely to a computer system in our network, and log in as one of our users to do anything. This also entails that they are completely incapable of diagnosing problems and require significant amounts of user input and time to try and begin any sort of work on the problems. [In my opinion] this takes away from patient care and other concerns. Also, while you can put in as detailed a ticket as you want, when you are called, you have to go over the ticket again, as they don't seem to read or care what you put in, as it's more important to them to go over everything in painful detail. Often times you must explain to the tech how the process works. In the past month, we were upgraded overnight with zero warning, which caused issues the following day as we had to update every single computer in our network (over 300) and it requires administrative privileges so couldn't be done by a user. This also doesn't update any information in the programs list, so there's no way to tell whether the update happened or not.
Read full review
In-Person Training
athenahealth
No answers on this topic
eClinicalWorks
Paid for training, did not help. They trained prior to go-live, but it was so long ahead that users weren't able to function well when it actually happened, they seemed unable to provide adequate support. [In my experience] further support is typically very boilerplate, and is thus not useful, and has additional cost.
Read full review
Implementation Rating
athenahealth
No answers on this topic
eClinicalWorks
It's very important to limit your schedule during the weeks after go live but it is equally important to have a resource that is the lead at the practice that ensures that milestones are met leading up to the go-live date. Someone must be the point person at the practice otherwise milestones will be missed and the implementation will run into problems.
Read full review
Alternatives Considered
athenahealth
SOAPWARE, Centricity, Amazing charts
Read full review
eClinicalWorks
I was attracted by the final note format of ECW. I said then and still say that most EMR's clinical notes are terrible to try to read and follow in orderly fashion by comparison...BUT the devil is in the data entry and that is where "you live" as a clinician. Incredibly frustrating software because of inflexibility and restrictions of multi level data fields that can only be opened one at a time (i.e. no "toggling" between windows... ooen read and close...then reopen other data entry window....then close and repeat if you need to refer back to original window of data. This applies throughout the software and is due to its reliance on SQL architecture from what I have been told). Kills productivity.
Read full review
Return on Investment
athenahealth
  • At least 2-3% increase in revenue collection.
  • Timely note completion rate went up.
  • Increase in payments from insurers for P4P.
Read full review
eClinicalWorks
  • I will just share one area that our organization saw the ROI in a very short time period. That is the elimination of a dictation service for most of our specialty group doctors when we introducec Dragon Medical. This functionality brought a tangible benefit and a significant ROI in a short time period.
Read full review
ScreenShots