Watch for your integration, if you have a big customer base.
February 09, 2025

Watch for your integration, if you have a big customer base.

Anonymous | TrustRadius Reviewer
Score 4 out of 10
Vetted Review
Verified User

Overall Satisfaction with Dotdigital

In the past two years in our organization, we have been consultants for an integration between CIAM software and DotDigital. The idea is that the purpose of the CIAM is to collect user data, while DotDigital works as a marketing/engagement platform. The original customer base is millions of records worth, and we had serious issues with the integration.

Pros

  • Segmentation
  • Mail templates.

Cons

  • API limits: There is a hardcoded limit on how many API calls you can make per hour, and to raise it, you have to pay.
  • The API set is very limited in general.
  • The API set is very limited in general
  • Maintenance costs due to integration limits.
  • API tiers (now formalized in the documentation) were discovered after the initial purchase, so there are more recurring costs.
  • In general, a raise of costs in the IT compartment, while it can benefit marketing.
The user interface offers nothing more and nothing less than its competitors (except for mail templates, which are nicely done). If we extend the term "usability" in IT usability, even if the APIs are well written, the score goes way down due to the features above.
Regarding pure mail sending/deliverability, DotDigital and Mailgun are on par. Mailgun is more focused on the actual "mail delivery" part, while DotDigital offers a complete marketing package, even if Mailgun quickly caught up at the time of this review (not two years ago when we started). MailUp is okay, but it is behind these two competitors.

Do you think Dotdigital delivers good value for the price?

No

Are you happy with Dotdigital's feature set?

Yes

Did Dotdigital live up to sales and marketing promises?

No

Did implementation of Dotdigital go as expected?

No

Would you buy Dotdigital again?

No

The platform is very similar to many of its competitors, and the only reason why some people chose this over others is its natural integration with Magento. For its limits, it is worth investing in an integration with another platform to save money in the long run.

Comments

More Reviews of Dotdigital