AppFolio Property Manager vs. PayHOA

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
AppFolio Property Manager
Score 8.2 out of 10
N/A
AppFolio Property Manager is a cloud-based property management software that allows multifamily and single-family, commercial, student housing, homeowners and condo association, and mixed portfolio property managers to market, manage and grow their business. AppFolio includes accounting and property management functionality, including the ability to: provide instant access to reports & statements, post & market vacancies, apply & lease online, screen residents, streamline rent collection, and…
$0.85
per unit/per month
PayHOA
Score 8.5 out of 10
N/A
PayHOA is software for HOAs and association managers. The software provides free on-boarding, free unlimited U.S. based support and no
$44
per month
Pricing
AppFolio Property ManagerPayHOA
Editions & Modules
Community Associations
$0.85
per unit/per month
Plus - Community Associations
$0.85
per unit/per month
Student Housing
$1.25
per unit/per month
Residential
$1.49
per unit/per month
Commercial
$1.50
per unit/per month
Plus - Student Housing
$3
per unit/per month
Plus - Residential
$3.20
per unit/per month
Plus - Commerical
$3.20
per unit/per month
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
AppFolio Property ManagerPayHOA
Free Trial
NoYes
Free/Freemium Version
NoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
AppFolio Property ManagerPayHOA
Considered Both Products
AppFolio Property Manager

No answer on this topic

PayHOA
Chose PayHOA
We wanted to use CINC Systems (not mentioned above) but we're not yet at the scale where we can afford their higher cost.

TownSq and FrontSteps were also beyond our budget due to smaller <500 unit count.
Best Alternatives
AppFolio Property ManagerPayHOA
Small Businesses
Dotloop
Dotloop
Score 7.1 out of 10
Condo Control
Condo Control
Score 9.0 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
Condo Control
Condo Control
Score 9.0 out of 10
Condo Control
Condo Control
Score 9.0 out of 10
Enterprises
Accruent Lucernex
Accruent Lucernex
Score 7.9 out of 10

No answers on this topic

All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
AppFolio Property ManagerPayHOA
Likelihood to Recommend
5.9
(17 ratings)
8.5
(2 ratings)
Usability
10.0
(2 ratings)
9.0
(1 ratings)
Support Rating
1.0
(6 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
AppFolio Property ManagerPayHOA
Likelihood to Recommend
AppFolio Inc.
We have 6 apartment buildings that we manage. Every month we were having to drive to each location to collect rent checks. Since using appfolio, we only have a couple of renters that still send in a paper check, the rest pay online, so we are ensuring that our renters are paying on time. Once we have an applicant apply, the old way was to take their scanned application, review, and then pay to have a background check conducted. Now, with appfolio, we are able to have them apply, sign off on the background check, and pay their deposit all in one shot. It has allowed our property managers to focus on other property items rather than conducting background checks.
Read full review
PayHOA
PayHOA may be well suited to small self-managed associations with only very basic needs. If you're looking for a association management software with proper accounting features and functionality, PayHOA will disappoint you as it has disappointed us
Read full review
Pros
AppFolio Inc.
  • Prior to purchasing AppFolio Property Manager we used a texting app so we could mass text tenants. AppFolio allows us to text them by their unit along with their guarantors (if needed.) We use this feature daily. It is so convenient when we need to reach out residents quickly.
  • The online payment system makes it easy for our commercial and residential tenants to make rental payments. The system has also lessened the work of out Account's manager since it's all in once place now and we do not have to enter payments into a separate system.
  • Navigating AppFolio Property Manager is extremely easy. When we have new hire, it does take any time for them to become comfortable with the system. The main page dashboard makes it simple to get from point A to point B and beyond. The Search engine on AppFolio Property Manager is so efficient. You can search almost anything- phone number, first names, last names, addressed, license plate numbers to successfully find what you are needing.
Read full review
PayHOA
  • Handles all of the accounting
  • Communication with homeowners
  • Banking
Read full review
Cons
AppFolio Inc.
  • Customer support is horrendous. It can take weeks to get a live person on the phone and once you get someone, they typically will need to escalate your issue.
  • If you have multiple bank accounts at different banks, the bill-paying feature has trouble properly defaulting to the right bank account.
  • Multiple bank accounts also have issues tying incorrectly to the Cash section of the balance sheet.
Read full review
PayHOA
  • Poor documentation
  • Unreliable lockbox processing service
  • Owners unable to access their own invoices online
  • Limited accounting functionality
  • No real A/P: cannot enter vendor bills separately
  • Duplicate field names that don't replicate correctly across the software
  • All owner payment options have additional charges
Read full review
Usability
AppFolio Inc.
The system is so intuitive and easy to use. There’s almost nothing in the system that can’t be undone if you make a mistake. Important things also have their own tabs. It’s also easy to use from the resident side which is helpful for in a world where everyone is not tech-savvy.
Read full review
PayHOA
It is simple enough for users with little to no accounting experience with enough features for seasoned accountants to be able to do more.
Read full review
Support Rating
AppFolio Inc.
The few times that we have had training with AppFolio, they were SO helpful and quick to answer any questions we may have. Because of their promptness, it shows what a great product they have. If they were not able to figure something out, they would follow up with us within a few days or so, which is so important in a software program!
Read full review
PayHOA
No answers on this topic
Alternatives Considered
AppFolio Inc.
This was our old program and it was not user friendly and very inefficient to use. We was never able to answer a question for an owner or a tenant very easily and many times we had to ask for them to let us call them back while we research their question because it was so difficult to maneuver in the program.
Read full review
PayHOA
We wanted to use CINC Systems (not mentioned above) but we're not yet at the scale where we can afford their higher cost. TownSq and FrontSteps were also beyond our budget due to smaller <500 unit count. We had a misperception that Buildium would be too expensive as well, but with our frustrations we reached out to Buildium and learned this was not necessarily the case. At the time, we selected PayHOA due to cost being within budget and having the appearance of being a comprehensive association management software. However the further we got into use of the software, the more issues, limitations, and frustrations we encountered. If it was not such a big effort to onboard the association already, we would have already switched to Buildium
Read full review
Return on Investment
AppFolio Inc.
  • As far as positive impact, we are much more organized as a company as far as accounting, maintenance, and managing tenant issues. We are all on the same page and know where to find notes, emails, letters, information, etc... and can be more self-sufficient and self-directed. I think this is a major plus as far as business goes, as time is money. The more efficient you can be, the more time that is saved, the more money that's saved, period.
  • I don't work in Accounting and I haven't had any discussions regarding negative impacts in regards to this program. However, we've been using this since 2013 and we're on our 6th year as a business and I've heard others in our organization saying how much AppFolio has improved over that short time and how it keeps getting more intuitive and better with time. At no point have our leaders considered getting rid of the program or implementing a different program.
Read full review
PayHOA
  • Good ROI as a whole
  • Some of the add on services are not worth the cost (ie, sending physical mail is overpriced).
Read full review
ScreenShots

AppFolio Property Manager Screenshots

Screenshot of Screenshot of Screenshot of Screenshot of Screenshot of