Reviews.io vs. Stamped vs. Trustpilot

Reviews.io is a great option for any ecommerce site that is looking to gather company and product reviews to help make the customer purchasing decision easier. Their BCC integration appears to make it possible to use their services with any platform so long as you can edit the email order confirmation templates.

Incentivized

If you want to generate valuable content that you can use on your website that provides a positive image of your business, Stamped.io can do it. We had absolutely no buyer feedback prior to Stamped.io. We have seen in actual customer reviews that the Stamped.io reviews are being read by customers and they consider them valuable.

Incentivized

Unfortunately, Trustpilot's disingenuous pricing habits and communication methods are the reason we ultimately ended our 3 year relationship with the company. In 2023, we signed a 1 year agreement for their basic plan (product reviews, Q&A, etc) at $3,800/year... Fair enough. In 2024, the price jumps to $5,040/year... Okay, steep - but we're still seeing good use of the tools, sort of justified? For 2025 it skyrockets to $8,976/year (+78% from prior)... But, after a month of haggling and threats to cancel, they 'graciously' drop it to $7,569/year. Now for 2026, Trustpilot is demanding $9,576/year for the EXACT SAME PLAN. That's a 152% increase since we started, with zero added value.

• Widget library with customizable, mobile-friendly widgets.
• Custom widgets can be built for you.
• WYSIWYG and HTML email templates.
• Instagram and UGC gallery included.
• Sync your product catalog via Merchant Center.

Incentivized

• Ease of use.
• Integration with the BigCommerce feedback and review system.
• A full-featured product suite that will meet the needs of most small to medium-sized eCommerce shops.

Incentivized

• Completing the review for the customer is a simple process which enables us to receive more feedback.
• The Trustpilot account management team is a true partner working with each department to help with adoption across the company.
• The Trustpilot development team is a trusted partner with our own internal development team, assisting them with implementation as well as integration with their API.

Incentivized

• Setting up isn't hard, but the documentation conflicts with itself sometimes.
• They reference a BigCommerce app that isn't available (yet).

Incentivized

• We haven't generated a whole lot of data as of right now, even being in business for two years, so a pain point for me is the analytics and trying to identify improvements. This is not really a deficiency of the software, just a lack of data.

Incentivized

• Allow you to highlight sections of the review and respond
• Stop reviews from unverified purchasers
• Searching for a review can sometimes be hit or miss

Incentivized

It's expensive and customer service is not the best.

Incentivized

Simple user interface - easy to understand with high level overviews, but also getting into the detail with questions for those who want it. The only issue I have is the connection with LinkedIn - sometimes it fails and makes you re-enter details again which can be a bit frustrating!

Incentivized

We had to reach out a few times during the setup process and we never had to wait more than a few minutes to get a response via their online chat. When a more in-depth answer was required they followed up via email and pulled in other team members when necessary.

Incentivized

Support is flat out awesome, super responsive and have always addressed my questions quickly and thoroughly.

Incentivized

I've rarely had issues and needed support. During the implementation phase we relied on their support heavily and they were very knowledgeable, responsive and helpful. Any questions I've had have been answered promptly by my account manager. They also have a great knowledgebase for self-service support.

Incentivized

Reviews.io has a similar product offering as the other well known review collection companies. However, they are much more competitive in terms of pricing and that was a big influence on our decision to go with them. They also have a library of widgets you can choose from and customize to make publishing reviews on your website very easy. It's not a cookie cutter solution, which we really like.

Incentivized

The only other service we used that's similar to Stamped.io is Feedback Five. That service is only similar in that it facilitates soliciting feedback. We use it for our marketplace business, not our website. I can say that Stamped.io is much more robust and valuable. The interface is more user-friendly, the campaigns are easy to set up, and working with customers directly in the UI is super simple.

Incentivized

Selected Trustpilot because of superior integration with the website and Google SERPS. Again, my only complaint would be Trustpilot was relatively more expensive than the other technologies.

Incentivized

• Increased customer trust through verified company and product reviews.

Incentivized

• Positive increase of over 80% in feedback responses.
• Trust is everything in our business and user reviews have contributed to a conversion increase of over 50%.

Incentivized

• Helps us to determine what our customers care about.
• We have been able to modify our marketing points based on what customers seemed confused about or the aspects of our business that they appreciate.

Incentivized