Great at forms, not so great at grants and data management
May 28, 2024

Great at forms, not so great at grants and data management

Anonymous | TrustRadius Reviewer
Score 6 out of 10
Vetted Review
Verified User

Overall Satisfaction with Submittable

Submittable is a good basic grant application intake and processing tool. The forms builder is excellent and easy to use with drag and drop functionality. You first build your form and then a "project" that it will be part of. The forms support branching logic and you can customize the confirmation messages for different types of forms. Once you have an application submitted, you can reopen it for editing so that the applicant can make corrections. There is also a good messaging tool built into the submission review process that allows you to keep communications about a particular submission connected to that submission and not in a separate silo in Outlook. There are some good basic reporting and filtering tools too. Where Submittable comes up short is in acknowledging and fixing software bugs. The reflexive response from customer service seems to be that everything is fine, so you have to be persistent to get them to see why a malfunctioning date filter is a big problem when you need accurate data in your reports for payments or to analyze your data. New features roll out regularly but fixes for ongoing issues are much slower. Submittable is slowing becoming a better platform for foundations but new features (such as linking submissions to an agency UEI/EIN) don't apply to previously submitted forms and applications, so you will always have an incomplete picture of the relationship in Submittable. Advanced reporting looked promising but in actual use it's a kludge with data field labels that require so much manual work that it's usually just easier to download your data to Excel on work on it there. If you are a small foundation with a simple process flow that is just getting started with an online grant application system, Submittable could be a good starting point and is much better than just using Microsoft/Google Forms. You can upgrade to something more advanced and purpose built later if needed. We've outgrown Submittable and its limitations but it helped us clarify what we need in a grants management system.

Pros

  • Online forms

Cons

  • Data reporting
  • Customer support
  • Implementing software fixes
  • Faster launch of forms
  • Better applicant experience
  • Easy to troubleshoot and fix form issues quickly
Forms and projects are great and easy to use with lots of features and options that are easy to understand/use. Reporting is a weak spot and is neither intuitive or even functional in some cases.
Submittable isn't in the same league as these other platforms. It's trying to get there but it's been a rocky road. Neither customer support nor the account people we've dealt with at Submittable seem particularly knowledgeable about how the product actually works for foundations and can't provide detailed recommendations for how to use the product more effectively. The decision to use Submittable was made before I came on board. We are moving to another platform next year, probably SmartSimple.

Do you think Submittable delivers good value for the price?

Yes

Are you happy with Submittable's feature set?

No

Did Submittable live up to sales and marketing promises?

I wasn't involved with the selection/purchase process

Did implementation of Submittable go as expected?

I wasn't involved with the implementation phase

Would you buy Submittable again?

No

Good if you are just getting started with online application forms for grants. Not so good if you have more advanced needs for data reporting. Also not great to be a fairly long term customer who can't take advantage of recent changes, because they provide no automatic or even manual way to link older submissions to the new grantee profiles based on an applicant's UEI/EIN.

Comments

More Reviews of Submittable