TrustRadius: an HG Insights company

SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors vs. Workday Human Capital Management

Save this comparison

Save this comparison

Add Product

Recommended Comparisons

    Overview
    ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price

    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors

    Score8.6 out of 10
    N/ASmartRecruiters was acquired by SAP in late 2025, and its functionality will be integrated into SAP SuccessFactors HCM. Check out the Sap SuccessFactors HCM listing for the latest updates.N/A

    Workday HCM

    Score7.9 out of 10
    N/AWorkday Human Capital Management is a cloud-native system offering a globally consistent user experience. Workday HCM is part of an intelligent, unified system with other Workday products.N/A
    Pricing
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Editions & Modules
    No answers on this topic
    No answers on this topic
    Offerings
    Pricing Offerings
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Free Trial
    NoNo
    Free/Freemium Version
    NoNo
    Premium Consulting/Integration Services
    NoNo
    Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
    Additional DetailsThe software subscription is determined by the number of a company's full time employees. There is a one time cost to set up software, including customizations, integrations, data migration and training.—
    More Pricing Information
    Community Pulse
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Considered Both Products
    SAP
    Chose SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    Price, configurability, automation capability. At the top with Teamtailor and Workable IMO.
    Incentivized
    Chose SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    Nowhere near as robust a system as SmartRecruiters.
    Incentivized
    Workday
    No answer on this topic
    Key User Insights
    Would buy again
    96%
    Would buy again
    27 Answers
    96%
    Would buy again
    68 Answers
    Delivers good value for the price
    100%
    Delivers good value for the price
    22 Answers
    98%
    Delivers good value for the price
    50 Answers
    Happy with the feature set
    100%
    Happy with the feature set
    28 Answers
    93%
    Happy with the feature set
    66 Answers
    Lived up to sales and marketing promises
    100%
    Lived up to sales and marketing promises
    16 Answers
    87%
    Lived up to sales and marketing promises
    26 Answers
    Implementation went as expected
    94%
    Implementation went as expected
    16 Answers
    90%
    Implementation went as expected
    36 Answers
    Features
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Recruiting / ATS
    Comparison of Recruiting / ATS features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    8.6
    127 Ratings
    8% above category average
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.4
    52 Ratings
    6% above category average
    Job Requisition Management9.8109 Ratings8.949 Ratings
    Company Website Posting9.9114 Ratings8.942 Ratings
    Publish to Social Media7.5112 Ratings7.137 Ratings
    Job Search Site Posting8.0116 Ratings8.943 Ratings
    Customized Application Form9.7104 Ratings00 Ratings
    Resume Management5.6119 Ratings00 Ratings
    Duplicate Candidate Prevention9.7114 Ratings8.843 Ratings
    Candidate Search8.1122 Ratings00 Ratings
    Applicant Tracking9.9126 Ratings8.043 Ratings
    Collaboration9.6117 Ratings00 Ratings
    Task Creation and Delegation9.997 Ratings00 Ratings
    Email Templates9.7114 Ratings00 Ratings
    User Permissions9.7109 Ratings00 Ratings
    Notifications and Alerts9.9119 Ratings8.047 Ratings
    Reporting1.7105 Ratings00 Ratings
    Human Resource Management
    Comparison of Human Resource Management features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    9.1
    100 Ratings
    11% above category average
    Employee demographic data00 Ratings8.985 Ratings
    Employment history00 Ratings8.195 Ratings
    Job profiles and administration00 Ratings8.997 Ratings
    Workflow for transfers, promotions, pay raises, etc.00 Ratings9.092 Ratings
    Organizational charting00 Ratings9.891 Ratings
    Organization and location management00 Ratings9.988 Ratings
    Compliance data (COBRA, OSHA, etc.)00 Ratings8.863 Ratings
    Payroll Management
    Comparison of Payroll Management features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.6
    83 Ratings
    5% above category average
    Pay calculation00 Ratings9.971 Ratings
    Support for external payroll vendors00 Ratings7.159 Ratings
    Off-cycle/On-Demand payment00 Ratings9.021 Ratings
    Benefit plan administration00 Ratings8.966 Ratings
    Direct deposit files00 Ratings9.072 Ratings
    Salary revision and increment management00 Ratings9.069 Ratings
    Reimbursement management00 Ratings7.245 Ratings
    Leave and Attendance Management
    Comparison of Leave and Attendance Management features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.6
    78 Ratings
    4% above category average
    Approval workflow00 Ratings8.977 Ratings
    Balance details00 Ratings8.077 Ratings
    Annual carry-forward and encashment00 Ratings8.963 Ratings
    Employee Self Service
    Comparison of Employee Self Service features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.2
    98 Ratings
    1% below category average
    View and generate pay and benefit information00 Ratings8.087 Ratings
    Update personal information00 Ratings8.096 Ratings
    View company policy documentation00 Ratings7.976 Ratings
    Employee recognition00 Ratings8.959 Ratings
    View job history00 Ratings8.087 Ratings
    Asset Management
    Comparison of Asset Management features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.4
    25 Ratings
    5% above category average
    Tracking of all physical assets00 Ratings8.425 Ratings
    HR Reporting
    Comparison of HR Reporting features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    7.4
    82 Ratings
    3% below category average
    Report builder00 Ratings8.978 Ratings
    Pre-built reports00 Ratings6.180 Ratings
    Ability to combine HR data with external data00 Ratings7.068 Ratings
    Onboarding
    Comparison of Onboarding features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.9
    60 Ratings
    10% above category average
    New hire portal00 Ratings8.955 Ratings
    Manager tracking tools00 Ratings8.956 Ratings
    Performance and Goals
    Comparison of Performance and Goals features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.9
    64 Ratings
    10% above category average
    Corporate goal setting00 Ratings8.954 Ratings
    Individual goal setting00 Ratings8.963 Ratings
    Line-of sight-visibility00 Ratings8.954 Ratings
    Performance tracking00 Ratings8.962 Ratings
    Performance Management
    Comparison of Performance Management features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.0
    67 Ratings
    1% above category average
    Performance plans00 Ratings8.066 Ratings
    Performance improvement plans00 Ratings8.058 Ratings
    Review status tracking00 Ratings8.062 Ratings
    Review reminders00 Ratings8.061 Ratings
    Multiple review frequency00 Ratings8.054 Ratings
    Succession Planning
    Comparison of Succession Planning features of SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors and Workday Human Capital Management
    Feature
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactors
    -
    Ratings
    Workday Human Capital Management
    8.0
    44 Ratings
    2% above category average
    Create succession plans/pools00 Ratings8.038 Ratings
    Candidate ranking00 Ratings8.038 Ratings
    Candidate search00 Ratings8.042 Ratings
    Candidate development00 Ratings7.940 Ratings
    Best Alternatives
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Small Businesses
    Crelate
    Score9.1 out of 10
    UZIO
    Score9.3 out of 10
    Medium-sized Companies
    CareerSiteBuilder
    Score10 out of 10
    Zoho People
    Score8.5 out of 10
    Enterprises
    JobDiva
    Score8 out of 10
    PeopleStrong
    Score10 out of 10
    All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
    User Ratings
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Likelihood to Recommend
    7.9
    (129 ratings)
    8.1
    (134 ratings)
    Likelihood to Renew
    6.0
    (15 ratings)
    9.0
    (18 ratings)
    Usability
    9.1
    (12 ratings)
    8.0
    (15 ratings)
    Availability
    9.0
    (1 ratings)
    6.6
    (8 ratings)
    Performance
    10.0
    (1 ratings)
    7.3
    (7 ratings)
    Support Rating
    9.0
    (10 ratings)
    8.0
    (27 ratings)
    In-Person Training
    -
    (0 ratings)
    9.6
    (6 ratings)
    Online Training
    -
    (0 ratings)
    7.0
    (7 ratings)
    Implementation Rating
    9.1
    (2 ratings)
    8.0
    (11 ratings)
    Configurability
    -
    (0 ratings)
    7.5
    (2 ratings)
    Ease of integration
    7.1
    (12 ratings)
    8.2
    (1 ratings)
    Product Scalability
    9.0
    (1 ratings)
    7.3
    (1 ratings)
    Vendor post-sale
    -
    (0 ratings)
    7.0
    (1 ratings)
    Vendor pre-sale
    -
    (0 ratings)
    5.0
    (1 ratings)
    User Testimonials
    SmartRecruiters, now part of SAP SuccessFactorsWorkday HCM
    Likelihood to Recommend
    SAP
    SmartRecruiters has allowed us to enable our hiring managers to self-service their requirements for recruitment, simplifying our internal processes. We have visibility of recruitment requirements and significantly improved our approvals process using the software. We have been able to configure our hiring processes relevant to different areas of the business. Collaboration for our hiring teams (managers and business partners) is simple and effective. Candidate experience is enhanced and engaging. The platform has brought many benefits to our Resourcing business partners and hiring managers. We have visibility and insightful data which has integrity, allowing us to make informed business decisions. Our offer process has seen significant improvements and provides an engaging candidate experience, previously this was a labour-intensive process that is now streamlined and automated. The recently launched Community for collaboration amongst customers is very helpful and insigtful for how other people are using the software and exploring ideas with each other
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    Large organizations with extensive back-office support functions. With that in mind, WD is a great HCM system for mastering and controlling downstream data and providing strong support. Where WD falls short is the front-end user experience. If your intent is for the average Jane/Joe to use the system, you will find them frustrated or disappointed.
    Read full review
    Pros
    SAP
    • Job Referrals - can easily refer others to a job posting and view the status
    • Job Postings - can easily search for job openings and read job description and criteria
    • Application online - Can easily apply for the job directly and see who the hiring manager and hiring recruiter is
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    • I think what it does is not having worked on the side of talent acquisitions. Whenever we have a job interview, for example, you can go right there, you can put in everything in Workday Human Capital Management. If I need to go in and see what a coworker put in or notes all that, I can document everything there in Workday Human Capital Management. I think the other thing that makes it a lot easier is for performance management, goal setting. All these things can be done right there in the platform and it just makes it easier. So to store documents, I can do that. I mean it is like a one-stop shop all in one, so it's excellent.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Cons
    SAP
    • Settings page can be difficult to navigate & find what you're looking for
    • Job approval chains would be better with additional qualifying fields so that we can segregate different areas of the business better
    • The ability to edit an existing offer template in-system would improve the experience, rather than having to edit offline and upload a whole new version.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    • Should have more option in time sheet like choose project code or something.
    • On The pay page, it should have options to view past salaries; it may be there already but not in the version that I use.
    • The employee information page does not have a back button to navigate to the previous page.
    Read full review
    Likelihood to Renew
    SAP
    I thoroughly enjoy using SmartRecruiters and have shared this feedback with those responsible, however I am not a decision maker in the process. I understand that at the moment there are lots of factors affecting the economy and business outcomes, so I cannot comment with certainty on the renewal of SmartRecruiters at this time, not involved in the confirmation of renewal.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    It is work to make one system the source of truth for our data, but now that it is done, there is less work involved in staying on this path. This means for us that maintaining and/or implementing new modules like performance, finance, talent, etc. is simple. It's a no-brainer
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Usability
    SAP
    I would give this rating as overall it a great combo of all your problems. With just one click you can get away with all your problems such as recruitment, candidate update, Interview scheduling, updating candidates, reports of a job perspective, and recruiters perspective. Usability is worth of SmartRecruiters. The dashboard is also very attractive and once you open you will love working on this platform again and again. I would say it is the best platform to use once for smooth work in your organization.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    Workday's on a great path in terms of user experience. Their goals is to deliver a use experience that doesn't require training or instruction, like Amazon on the consumer side for example. That's hard to do when you're talking about complex business processes and important and sensitive employee information, but they're doing it well
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Reliability and Availability
    SAP
    Rarely is there an issue and if the product is down, it typically is restored quickly.
    Read full review
    Workday
    In 2014, Workday has changed the update process. There will be two updates a year; the updates will be delivered to customers typically in a 24 hour window during these two weekends a year. They also keep the Community up-to-date about any planned outages, etc. There is weekly scheduled downtime on Friday night.
    Read full review
    Performance
    SAP
    I have no complaints about performance. The system works virtually flawless.
    Read full review
    Workday
    From my perspective, the system runs like a well oiled machine and I have not had any issues with customers complaining about speed. If a report is taking long to run, the report can run in the background and you can go about your business. For larger enterprises, there is additional space and machines to process the application in what Workday refers to it as Extended Configuration Tenant
    Read full review
    Support Rating
    SAP
    Response is normally very fast. There are times, however, when the response is not useful. It is difficult to work with the reporting and the offer letter templates, and the front line support agents usually are not very knowledgeable. Second, if there are any issues with integrations, the regular support agents will not be able to help you. You'll have to create that ticket and ask them to escalate it to an integration specialist.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    Workday is still learning about the needs of higher education. I have seen rapid improvement in support and knowledge over the last year so am confident this will continue to improve. Overall however, I have found the Support Team to be extremely responsive and Workday offers the advantage of having support across several timezones so that we never wait more than a few hours for a response.
    Read full review
    In-Person Training
    SAP
    Quick and easy to learn.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    Some training is offered online. Cost is per-person. This also gets quite expensive. Training doesn’t follow a logical path A to B. Starts in middle. When you try to do it afterwards at your desk, difficult.
    • Training scenarios are not very real
    Read full review
    Online Training
    SAP
    No answers on this topic
    Workday
    I have done for report writing and mass imports (EIBs). They give materials and you run through examples, i.e. you don’t just watch them do tasks, so that is helpful. Training is expensive – a single reporting writing class is $600 per person for virtual training
    Read full review
    Implementation Rating
    SAP
    It really was a painless and easy process to switch to SmartRecruiters.
    Read full review
    Workday
    It was implemented before my joining the company. At my last company, we used Workday professional services.

    Based upon my experience at my last company, I would rate the implementation experience an 8/10. There are different ways to set things up and we had different people telling us different things. It set us back a couple of times.

    Regarding configuration advice, we could set things up where every manager has supervisory organizations, or have it financially based i.e. aligned to cost center/department. We chose the individual manager path and I think we should have chosen a department route. Going down the individual manager path, to maintain the information, we have to inactivate a supervisory org whenever a manager changes/leaves.
    Read full review
    Alternatives Considered
    SAP
    I've really enjoyed using SmartRecruiters, but these other ATSs that we've checked out offer better reporting features and price points. Over time, we may be transitioning off of SmartRecruiters to one of these ATSs because the price is a set price where SmartRecruiters has employee-based pricing model. Also, these other software products offer better reporting features that would eliminate some of our manual tracking process that we're currently doing.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    Workday is an incomplete product, by this I mean it must work alongside other products and does not work by itself. Trying to make several different products work smoothly together becomes very challenging. As compared to ADP products, when purchased all together work very well all together. Also, ADP has extensive Training programs and extensive Customer Support. So ADP's products are far superior to Workday's products in my opinion.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Scalability
    SAP
    No explanation really, just a great product.
    Read full review
    Workday
    Workday has released Financials and is continuing to develop it's Human Capital Management footprint with the addition of Workday Recruiting. I think customers will find that is easy to add on additional functionality in the system. Workday does make it easy for customers to make changes without relying on IT resources. The Business Process framework is a visual tool that allows functional resources to make changes and see the flow of the transaction
    Read full review
    Return on Investment
    SAP
    • In terms of ROI, SR helped our business greatly in returning precious time to my productivity in business management, as well as my team's, so that we could get back to the main work we were hired for. The SR process did most of the heavy lifting.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Workday
    • To get the most value out of all possible automation in Workday you really need to use a lot of their modules, otherwise you may not be able to solve for some pretty important and necessary needs.
    • The system maintenance is way more than what I have seen with some other systems and therefore you need a quite large team dedicated to it.
    • The ability to automate a lot of administrative tasks and the ability for employee and manager self-service definitely create a lot of opportunity for HR to spent time and effort elsewhere. A lot of the automation that can be leveraged in Workday also allows for eliminating third party vendors as well as the cost of their maintenance and integrations.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    ScreenShots

    Workday HCM Screenshots

    Screenshot of Workday Human Capital Management HomepageScreenshot of Workday Human Capital Management Manager Insights HubScreenshot of Workday Human Capital Management HR Partners HubScreenshot of Workday Human Capital Management Expense AnalysisScreenshot of Workday Human Capital Management Skills DashboardScreenshot of Workday Human Capital Management HR Operations and Compliance Dashboard