Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant Services vs. PayPal Payments Pro vs. PaySimple

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant Services
Score 2.1 out of 10
N/A
Fiserv (formerly First Data) and ICICI Merchant Services combined a payment gateway and point-of-sale software and hardware solutions with features such as card & check acceptance, and merchant mobile commerce solutions, and ecommerce gateway. First Data merged with Fiserv in July 2019. Similar capabilities are now supplied by Fiserv Carat.N/A
PayPal Payments Pro
Score 8.1 out of 10
N/A
PayPal Payments Pro is an enterprise-class ecommerce payment solution, that provides payment processing security to build a professional-grade ecommerce site. It can be configured to meet business needs and works across devices. Users can tap into over 390 million active customer accounts around the globe.
$0.02
per transaction
PaySimple
Score 5.8 out of 10
N/A
PaySimple is a payment gateway software solution offered by PaySimple.
$59.95
per month
Pricing
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
QR code Transactions
1.90% + fixed fee
per transaction
Charity Transactions
2.20% + fixed fee
per transaction
Commercial Transactions - In-Store
2.70% + fixed fee
per transaction
Commercial Transactions - Online
2.90% + fixed fee
per transaction
PayPal's pay later offers
2.90% + fixed fee
per transaction
Venmo
2.90% + fixed fee
per transaction
Subscription
$59.95
per month
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Free Trial
NoNoYes
Free/Freemium Version
NoNoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Considered Multiple Products
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant Services
Chose Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant Services
First Data is competive on its rate. Quality is acceptable, but not good compared to its competitors mentioned above.
PayPal Payments Pro

No answer on this topic

PaySimple
Chose PaySimple
I found PaySimple through another company. They offered integrated platforms for invoicing and follow-up questionnaires with our clients. I would never recommend PaySimple to a friend. In my experience, customer service could care less about helping you with a simple name …
Features
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Payment Gateways
Comparison of Payment Gateways features of Product A and Product B
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant Services
-
Ratings
PayPal Payments Pro
-
Ratings
PaySimple
1.0
1 Ratings
151% below category average
Fraud Detection00 Ratings00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
API or SDK00 Ratings00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
Recurring Payment Support00 Ratings00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
Billing and Invoicing Support00 Ratings00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
Global Support00 Ratings00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
Payment Form Acceptance00 Ratings00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
Best Alternatives
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Small Businesses
Apple Pay
Apple Pay
Score 8.9 out of 10
Apple Pay
Apple Pay
Score 8.9 out of 10
Apple Pay
Apple Pay
Score 8.9 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
Apple Pay
Apple Pay
Score 8.9 out of 10
Apple Pay
Apple Pay
Score 8.9 out of 10
Apple Pay
Apple Pay
Score 8.9 out of 10
Enterprises
Adyen
Adyen
Score 8.7 out of 10
Adyen
Adyen
Score 8.7 out of 10
Adyen
Adyen
Score 8.7 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Likelihood to Recommend
4.7
(7 ratings)
8.2
(72 ratings)
3.0
(13 ratings)
Support Rating
-
(0 ratings)
2.3
(9 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
Fiserv (First Data) - ICICI Merchant ServicesPayPal Payments ProPaySimple
Likelihood to Recommend
Fiserv
The software which is web-based offers our employees access the portal for reporting, credit card processing remotely. This feature has been very useful during the current Covid environment.
Read full review
PayPal
Paypal is great for personal payments as well as business payments for ecommerce of for paying monthly memberships. It is a user friendly software that needs little expertise to get used to. For larger payments, the fees become high therefore it is more suitable for payments of upto few hundred dollars.
Read full review
PaySimple
PaySimple has made it next to impossible to become PCI compliant unless we purchased a separate computer for the sole purpose of invoicing. We switched to Chase Bank who does not store sensitive info on our computers allowing us to accept credit cards and still remain PCI compliant. Our money is available much faster by not using the 3rd party. Additionally, a simple company name change required more paperwork than closing the account and setting up a new one even when the same bank account was going to be used. This was the primary reason to shop around. We happily contacted Chase Bank and now save $125 a month and receive access to our funds faster. I cannot believe I stayed with PaySimple as long as I did. It's amazing anyone would jump through the hoops of PCI compliance when the technology exists to keep sensitive information off your small business computers. If this review stops anyone from paying those monthly fees, the time was well worth it! PaySimple, requires business owners to fill out forms that make no sense in laymens terms. Chase Bank fills them all in for you and highlights the areas that need to be signed and initialed. PaySimple, charges excessive fees and in my opinion has very emotional customer service reps. Chase Bank, was eager to help and get things rolling so you can focus on your business. I would never recommend PaySimple.
Read full review
Pros
Fiserv
  • Securely stores data on FirstData's servers so that I don't have to worry about the technical details there.
  • Integrates well with WordPress and WooCommerce and provides a seamless user experience.
  • Allows customers to pay while staying on site, rather than leaving and coming back like PayPal.
Read full review
PayPal
  • PayPal offers me the option of converting my currency deposited in my account to another currency, so I can complete all kinds of payments and send money to employees who are in another country for business reasons.
  • The mobile phone application is too fast, I can make payments to my employees in a matter of seconds without having to wait for the web version to load.
  • Scheduled payments are great. PayPal allows me to add a list of contacts to my PayPal Business account, and after adding the contacts, I can schedule payments for a specific day and time. It's easier to make automated payroll payments with PayPal.
Read full review
PaySimple
  • PaySimple is awesome for recurring payments. It's easy to set one up and make changes as needed. Without this feature, our business would be dead. Being able to easily set up recurring payments for our retainer is a must and PaySimple does it beautifully.
  • The payment portal feature is also really good fro collecting payments of differing amounts. We setup a single portal where customers enter the payment amount accessed from a link in the invoice email. This feature has transformed out collections and cut down our time to get paid significantly.
  • If you do have product type offerings, it's easy to setup individual products or an entire store.
Read full review
Cons
Fiserv
  • They're too big of a company, each division seems to know only about their own area to such a specific degree that if we make an inquiry about how another division integrates with whoever we're talking to, we're told to contact the other team.
  • Constantly finding out there is yet another team that we need to work with to troubleshoot an issue.
Read full review
PayPal
  • Sometimes the UX flow would not deliver the customer back to our site, leaving orders in limbo "Pre-approved" status. The customer would call days later asking why we hadn't shipped it.
  • The PayPal logo on the checkout page can be kind of large and obtrusive.
  • They mention new features and programs on their login page, but it's hard to find any details on them deeper in the software.
Read full review
PaySimple
  • More proactive and empowering role in merchant fee's and alternative processors. Transparency is challenging in understanding Paysimple's role and relationship to the processors.
  • Identifying areas for further value to clients.
  • More targeted small to mid-size business perspective to anticipate growth challenges and prevent blocks on funds for legitimate sales and growth.
Read full review
Support Rating
Fiserv
No answers on this topic
PayPal
Customer service representatives were unable to explain why customer in Australia were unable to make payments using our link. It turned out that customers in Australia must create an account. PayPal's user interface did not reveal this to our customers in Australia. There was plenty about this issue appearing in online forums and PayPal customer service couldn't explain this. This change in PayPal's usability happened between April and May of 2021 and was done without notice to vendors (like us).
Read full review
PaySimple
No answers on this topic
Alternatives Considered
Fiserv
First Data is competive on its rate. Quality is acceptable, but not good compared to its competitors mentioned above.
Read full review
PayPal
I don't think there's really any competition here. There's Venmo (also owned by PayPal) who is now offering business accounts, but it still isn't quite the same. The closest thing in terms of ease of use would be Apple Pay or Google Pay (and there are a handful of others out there, but we offer Apple and Google Pay). As a business, I prefer Apple or Google Pay to PayPal Payments, but we offer either Google or Apple Pay, PayPal, and credit card options and PayPal is always right up there with credit cards. I don't foresee us ever getting rid of PayPal Payments as an option, but we do try to only offer it on request for higher ticket items or high dollar installment purchases.
Read full review
PaySimple
Authorize.net and a handful of other merchant processors and gateways. Most payment gateways (online portals to process payments) are rudimentary and not extremely intuitive. PaySimple is not and they are constantly coming up with new ways to improve upon an already very impressive platform.
Read full review
Return on Investment
Fiserv
  • Our ROI has been very positive
  • Our company has been able to process cash receipts remotely
  • Our processing charges have been lower
Read full review
PayPal
  • Our daily revenue has been increased when started PayPal Payments as the payment gateway.
  • Refund rate and recurring revenue is stable and disputes are handled properly.
  • Forex Fluctuations is controlled and solved the buying experience for few users.
  • Solved problem for different currencies and retained our users.
Read full review
PaySimple
  • Because we've got a really awesome rate with them it's definitely a positive ROI. I can't say what that figure is but it's pretty good. Also, our customers have a huge ROI over their prior way of getting payment from their customers.
Read full review
ScreenShots

PaySimple Screenshots

Screenshot of PaySimple DashboardScreenshot of Online InvoicesScreenshot of Web Payment FormsScreenshot of Point of Sale (POS)Screenshot of Mobile AppScreenshot of Collect payments on the go.