ATOmate vs. Klippa vs. SAP Concur

ATOmate has automated so many processes and we are now able to assign staff to more meaningful tasks rather than sorting out paper documents.

In saying that, there are times when manual intervention is required like sending out a big payment required.

Incentivized

Klippa does well with invoices without graphics and logos. If you can convince your suppliers to remove their branding and submit plain company names it will perform better. One issue that I could not overcome was when a supplier used "SO" (for Sales Order) as the prefix for an invoice. Every time the OCR ran it deciphered this as "S0" S-Zero. I wouldn't downgrade my rating based on that though. My one significant disappointment was I was led to believe that they would tailor the template for us. There was some minor work around our local tax rules but when it got to specific coding for our purchase order numbers the work ceased. To be fair, I may have misunderstood the scope of what changing these templates was included in the agreement. Either way, we could work around it so it wasn't a major flaw.

Incentivized

SAP Concur is great for large organizations because of it's built in approval process functions. It is great tool for expense reports and any company where employees need to book travel. I imagine that the tool would be more tricky to use for those who are less technically savvy since there are many tabs and it is sometimes tricky to navigate.

Incentivized

• They are at the forefront of any changes with the way the ATO is working
• The pro-actively find solutions for problems that could arise
• They keep us informed of any downtime with their product or the ATO
• They get almost all documents from the portal without any input from us.

Incentivized

• Identifies invoice numbers.
• Extracts text from any angle - 45 degrees and upside down.
• Extracts line items from a printed invoice.

Incentivized

• Self service and easy to navigate
• Available on all mobile devices
• Provides travel options such as airlines for the destination with several options
• Automatically define check in and check out dates and time for hotels
• Reminds users to book other travel related activities

Incentivized

• Sometimes the ATOmate web portal is very slow
• There is a lack of logging of events that we as users can see
• We should be able to assign a partner to documents where the client is unknown

Incentivized

• More flexibility in tailoring the templates to suit individual customers.
• Better documentation around the API; as I recall it was hard to find.
• Commercial follow up. No one has contacted me since my initial purchase.

Incentivized

• For a new user of SAP Concur, it becomes difficult to file the first reimbursement as that person is new to the application and probably, one needs to to go through the instructions to get used to it. So, user interface can be improved and could be tried to make more interactive. Other than that, it's all good to go.

Incentivized

Now that we are fully on Concur, switching is not an option. Concur has become ingrained in our expense reporting process. Furthermore, Concur continues to improve its offering. Each month, they release updates and changes, many of which were client requested. Concur's constant evolution means it is adapting with my business

Incentivized

I think it is very easy to use, especially once you are acquainted with it. I think the UX could be improved so some things, like accessing old reports, are more intuitive once you learn it though it is not difficult to replicate.

Incentivized

In prior years I would have given them a 9.5 for availability. Unfortunately in 2015 so far this rating has dropped to a 7 overall.
We have experienced far too many interruptions - from admins to employees who rely on it for day to day booking of travel and submission of expense reports. Server errors, slow system response time and spinning wheels are too common place. Those things should be a rare occurrence, not a daily interruption.

While Conur still has great product offerings overall, they are currently not offering world class or best in class product (and customer service) availability. Remaining hopeful they step up and get their A game going again soon.

Incentivized

Performance-wise, it's good, loads pages quickly, and reports are highly accurate and easy to understand. Also, we can generate custom reports as needed, and we have integrated with a few other apps, and we have not seen any downgrade in performance.

Incentivized

I have never had to use customer support when using Concur Expense - the UX could be a bit nicer on the eyes or easier to understand, but there have never been any problems when using Concur Expense that I have had to ask or reach out to customer support to help me with anything.

Incentivized

My Seniors were the ones who taught me about Concur. Concur Support team has sent me training links and answered me in their tickets too. Usually they are helpful and knows their stuff. There are times when webex meetings is conducted for reporting training. They were very patient and took down all the details from me.

Incentivized

I can use it after that training, so it fits the purpose.

Incentivized

There are different implementation teams for each module of the product you purchase, so implementation is not a 'one size fits all' environment. Also, the different implementation teams have different ways of doing things, so Concur could stand some standardization and streamlining in this area. A Project Manager can make or break an implementation so don't be scared to ask for a new one if things are rocky.

Incentivized

ATOmate has the ocr that is far superior to kofax and the client names and amounts on the ato forms are almost 99% captured. This was compared to about 80% with kofax

Incentivized

Klippa is optimised for invoices. Wins hands down.

Incentivized

Expensify and Zoho Expense work for small and mid-size businesses. Big multinationals do not receive benefits from the apps. Coupa is good as a solution for organizations with non-SAP leading systems. If you plan to use SAP ERP as the main/lending system then SAP Concur is the best solution, mainly for its native integration with SAP ecosystem.

Incentivized

This program has been very helpful, user friendly and has been a great asset to use to assist with time management. Not only are leadership involved with using this program but all staff as well. This is also a great way to hold each accountable. Easy startup with not many means for hands on training

Incentivized

• ATOMATE has allowed us to redeploy admin staff to different tasks and we have been cable to expand without needing more staff
• The only downside to it is the admin staff used to keep excel sheets that would be checked off every quarter and the partners used that sheet to keep track of their workflow
• We no longer have to wait for paper correspondence from the ato as most gets picked up by ATOmate

Incentivized

• To early to tell, our app has been delayed due to other COVID related activities.

Incentivized

• Concur's automation has produced impressive efficiency improvements, which have decreased the time and effort required for expense management.
• Manual errors and policy violations have decreased, which has led to cost savings.
• We now adhere to corporate regulations better, which lowers risks thanks to Concur's policy compliance checker.

Incentivized