Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AI vs. Mimecast Cloud Archive vs. Proofpoint Security Awareness Training

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AI
Score 7.6 out of 10
N/A
Commvault® Cloud is a cyber resilience platform built to meet the demands of hybrid enterprises. It delivers data security and recovery in the cloud, powered by advanced AI, to help organizations see, manage, and recover data wherever it lives.N/A
Mimecast Cloud Archive
Score 9.4 out of 10
N/A
Mimecast Cloud Archive provides an archive storage solution for data retention, as well as search and retrieval of email, attachments and MS Teams conversations. The cloud archiving solution offers search capabilities for employees and automated tools for administrators that simplify management of mailboxes, e-discovery and litigation support.N/A
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
Score 10.0 out of 10
N/A
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training (formerly ThreatSim from Wombat Security) is a cloud-based training platform that simulates threat scenarios (e.g. phishing) and also provides assessment testing developed by Wombat Technologies, which was acquired by Proofpoint in March 2018.N/A
Pricing
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Editions & Modules
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
No answers on this topic
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Free Trial
YesNoYes
Free/Freemium Version
NoNoNo
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
YesNoYes
Entry-level Setup FeeOptionalOptionalOptional
Additional Details
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Features
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Data Center Backup
Comparison of Data Center Backup features of Product A and Product B
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AI
7.1
77 Ratings
17% below category average
Mimecast Cloud Archive
-
Ratings
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
-
Ratings
Universal recovery8.067 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Instant recovery7.064 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Recovery verification7.068 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Business application protection7.572 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Multiple backup destinations5.171 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Incremental backup identification7.077 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Backup to the cloud7.559 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Deduplication and file compression7.575 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Snapshots7.571 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Flexible deployment6.066 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Management dashboard7.567 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Platform support7.067 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Retention options8.065 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Encryption7.564 Ratings00 Ratings00 Ratings
Security
Comparison of Security features of Product A and Product B
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AI
-
Ratings
Mimecast Cloud Archive
-
Ratings
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
9.0
1 Ratings
4% above category average
Single sign-on capability00 Ratings00 Ratings9.01 Ratings
Role-based user permissions00 Ratings00 Ratings9.01 Ratings
Security Awareness Training
Comparison of Security Awareness Training features of Product A and Product B
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AI
-
Ratings
Mimecast Cloud Archive
-
Ratings
Proofpoint Security Awareness Training
9.4
1 Ratings
10% above category average
Training Content Library00 Ratings00 Ratings10.01 Ratings
Multilingual Training Content00 Ratings00 Ratings9.01 Ratings
Training Gamification00 Ratings00 Ratings9.01 Ratings
Industry-Specific Security Training00 Ratings00 Ratings9.01 Ratings
Individualized Security Training Plans00 Ratings00 Ratings9.01 Ratings
Phishing Simulations00 Ratings00 Ratings10.01 Ratings
Security Reporting00 Ratings00 Ratings10.01 Ratings
Best Alternatives
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Small Businesses
Cove Data Protection
Cove Data Protection
Score 9.1 out of 10
Cove Data Protection
Cove Data Protection
Score 9.1 out of 10
Barracuda Email Protection
Barracuda Email Protection
Score 8.7 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
Bacula Enterprise
Bacula Enterprise
Score 9.6 out of 10
Cove Data Protection
Cove Data Protection
Score 9.1 out of 10
Hoxhunt
Hoxhunt
Score 8.9 out of 10
Enterprises
Bacula Enterprise
Bacula Enterprise
Score 9.6 out of 10
Microsoft Exchange
Microsoft Exchange
Score 8.6 out of 10
Hoxhunt
Hoxhunt
Score 8.9 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Likelihood to Recommend
6.5
(79 ratings)
9.4
(26 ratings)
9.0
(46 ratings)
Likelihood to Renew
9.0
(8 ratings)
10.0
(2 ratings)
7.3
(1 ratings)
Usability
7.0
(16 ratings)
7.9
(16 ratings)
8.6
(5 ratings)
Availability
9.1
(1 ratings)
8.5
(16 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Performance
9.1
(1 ratings)
8.0
(16 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Support Rating
8.6
(52 ratings)
7.3
(2 ratings)
8.3
(44 ratings)
In-Person Training
9.1
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Online Training
9.1
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Implementation Rating
9.1
(4 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Ease of integration
9.1
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Product Scalability
9.1
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Vendor post-sale
9.1
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
Vendor pre-sale
9.1
(1 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
-
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
Commvault Cloud powered by Metallic AIMimecast Cloud ArchiveProofpoint Security Awareness Training
Likelihood to Recommend
Commvault
Commvault works well in a large environments with a variety of client types and data classes. With its policy-based configurations, it makes administration of large environments easier when configuring storage and retention, copies, schedules, client configs, etc. Commvault also backs up just about everything you can think of, and works with almost all storage and compute platforms, so there are rarely any cases where Commvault cannot accommodate.
Read full review
Mimecast
If someone is looking for a cloud archive solution, I believe Mimecast Cloud Archive has one of the best. I have worked with a few competitors in the past but the reason we have continued with Mimecast Cloud Archive is because of the capability, cost to value, and support that we receive. They also have other capabilities that can add security to your environment that you can access from the same portal.
Read full review
Proofpoint
Perfect for regular (monthly) training of staff versus a "one and done" annual assignment on Cyber Security. Allows for a greater number of topics to be covered and for creating a "culture" of security awareness among all Staff throughout the entire company. NOT a replacement for IT Security Certifications amongst your technical staff (CISSPs & GSLCs on staff are a must have). Your Proofpoint Account Rep does most of the heavy lifting, but the program still requires "care and feeding" (resources) within your organization - preparing monthly user lists for training assignments and preparing reports for leadership on participation & progress
Read full review
Pros
Commvault
  • Commvault is the Swiss Army knife for data protection in an Enterprise environment. You name the environment and Commvvault has something to protect it. Very helpful in this on-prem/off-prem world that is developing into a DevOps world.
  • Improves our Disaster Recovery
  • Starting to utilize for data migration for VMware in places where Zerto is too expensive
Read full review
Mimecast
  • Sync and Recover is a great tool for when you need to recover emails quickly or in bulk.
  • The archive is nested in the mail protection admin portal, so it is easy to navigate between the recent mail in the protection portal (limited window of time) and the archive when searching for emails during investigations or troubleshooting.
  • The additional protection feature allows scanning of emails that land in the archive. This helps with internal to internal emails that might have been malicious, for instance from a compromised account.
  • The Mimecast for Outlook add-in is nice, although you can access it from the web as well, for seeing your own archives. If users are missing an email, they can look there on their own without submitting an IT support ticket.
  • We do not allow end users to restore their own, but that is a feature that exists as well.
Read full review
Proofpoint
  • Proofpoint has a huge library of phishing emails to choose from. They add new examples every week.
  • The training modules are fun and interactive and keep the user engaged.
  • The posters, and downloadable materials are amazing and really give a great visual to support your security campaigns.
  • The product is easy to use, and Proofpoint Support Staff are always available to help with any issues you have.
Read full review
Cons
Commvault
  • For database restores, it has to restore the entire database in order to recover just one table.
  • Backups of virtual machines with direct attached storage is difficult.
  • I wish it covered cloud assets more thoroughly, like AWS ELBs and Security Groups.
Read full review
Mimecast
  • The system runs slowly at times.
  • There are so many features, it can be difficult to find exactly how to perform some actions.
  • Emails are not automatically shown in their native format when searched you must click on the email and then request it be formatted in the proper format (HTML, plaintext, etc.).
Read full review
Proofpoint
  • The lack of a user rating on "cyber risk" is proving to be an immense difficulty. As we are looking at how to better hold our employees accountable as well as provide increased learning opportunities for those who need it most, it is becoming cumbersome--especially given the fact this is starting to become the standard for Security Awareness companies. The lack of this is resulting in a manual process vs being able to automate and moderate, thus taking up time and resources, which are always at a scarcity. It can also be cumbersome to look across the tools to see how a particular user is doing, vs being able to view all of their data in one space.
  • If you are a marketer, the editors for the Phishing Templates and Teachable Moments are quite frustrating. They feel out of date and clunky, as well as not featuring an auto-save, so you could lose the templates you are building. At this point, I have actually started to work in other email creation editors and learning HTML, to better customize and then moving all of the code into the editor. It has thus far proven to be less of a headache. I also do not believe the average user is working on branding their program, creating consistency for easy of navigation, and including additional resources in their teachable moments in the way we currently are. However, as more social science backgrounds continue to enter security awareness, I believe this will move towards the norm.
  • Some of the reporting numbers for Simulated Phishing could be better. For example, telling me how many people acknowledged the teachable moment out of the full email campaign is less meaningful than knowing how many people acknowledged it, from those who actually triggered/were shown the teachable moment.
Read full review
Likelihood to Renew
Commvault
It is serving it's purpose and for companies that have a smaller IT staff, it is not time consuming to manage. Support for the product when needed has been very good and they are responsive when tickets are opened for support. The product is scalable so as we grow we can easily increase the resources as needed on the backend.
Read full review
Mimecast
The product is an excellent tool for our organisation. With one incident in the past it helped clear any wrong doing when an external party had their email hacked. We where able to show that when the email left our org it was in tact with out modification and only after it arrived in the partners org was it changed. This one incident alone has shown how valuable the tool is.
Read full review
Proofpoint
  • The product is great for what we use it for
  • We have a good relationship with our vendor/Proofpoint, which I believe is needed to be successful in Security Awareness and using tools like this
  • The package/service as a whole is incredibly helpful
  • The integrations with Proofpoint's Trap is one of the most valuable things we could do. It turns your entire email user base into members of IT security, to be on the look out to report cyber attacks, and have them pulled out of everyone's email if the email is condemed/found malicious.
Read full review
Usability
Commvault
Have a interface very user friendly. You do not need a lot of training, or any formal training really, to get up and going and use nearly all of the functionality of the product. This facilitates the post-implementation company as it reduces costs with backup specialists and any trained analyst can take care of its infrastructure. One negative point is not all the options and features are in the HTML view.
Read full review
Mimecast
The archive is easy to use and the searching is highly customizable. You can easily search based on timeframe, sender, recipient, words, phrases, and attachments. The ability to search keywords within attachments, body, and subject line is incredibly helpful. We're able to quickly and easily find what we're looking for.
Read full review
Proofpoint
Overall, PSAT is integral to what we do. PSAT is a helpful tool to help us improve our employees ability to recognize, report, and respond to phishing. It works for us to use a longterm partner, who is incredibly helpful/supportive, and also bringing Proofpoint's greater cybersecurity & attack intelligence into PSAT. Honestly, we are pretty happy and would make the choice to go with PSAT again (we evaluated the major players in the space via Gartner's Magic Quadrant). The team behind the products are excellent and the product of itself is both intuitive and expansive. This combination allows us to reach our 10k+ employees who are located in over 20 countries
Read full review
Reliability and Availability
Commvault
Commvault Complete Backup & Recovery is designed to provide organizations with flexible and scalable software.
Read full review
Mimecast
There is never an issue. Everytime I have needed to access my own personal search archive or globally search across the whole business it works each time. I cannot recall a time where the service was down when needed to be used and all our staff use it daily.
Read full review
Proofpoint
No answers on this topic
Performance
Commvault
Commvault Complete Backup & Recovery is designed and provide to organizations with flexible and scalable software
Read full review
Mimecast
The stability of the tool is the biggest factor, it has a fantastic uptime and the loading speed is exceptional. Long gone are the days of waiting for Outlook to open up a traditional PST archive, I can simply click, find what I need and go, usually, before outlook has opened the archive. It is an exceptionally efficient tool.
Read full review
Proofpoint
No answers on this topic
Support Rating
Commvault
I would rate Commvault's support as an 'average' support. Now that we have a very experienced guy working with Commvault, most of the time we can fix or do anything by ourselves. We had some issues with their support taking a really long time to respond and fix some issues in the past. In most cases we ended up appealing to the community, other peers, or Commvault's SE team.
Read full review
Mimecast
It does a good job. The support team of the product was good and responsive and was also able to fix the issues I was experiencing at the time. It isn't perfect and takes some time to set up properly in the environment but once set up the product does what it is supposed to do which is what you are paying for.
Read full review
Proofpoint
Proofpoint support has always been above average. A lot of companies provide a customer service manager for your account but few have proved as connected as Proofpoint. The CSM was able to give us a good start with the product and checked in periodically. I found them always helpful with any questions and very knowledgeable about the platform.
Read full review
In-Person Training
Commvault
Traning is very easy very helpful
Read full review
Mimecast
No answers on this topic
Proofpoint
No answers on this topic
Online Training
Commvault
Commvault training is very important and very helpful full for immplementation.
Read full review
Mimecast
No answers on this topic
Proofpoint
No answers on this topic
Implementation Rating
Commvault
Plan well and make sure you collect all the required information and details before going for implementation. Organize it in step by step or break the setup into different modules to make it simple.
Read full review
Mimecast
We used Mimecast professional services for the implementation and it was flawless as we were migrating from a competitor's product. The only downside was the amount of time required to ingest all the data as this was coming from a few different sources and in some cases it took months to migrate and index all the content. Apart from that the process was very well guided, with plenty of communication all throughout and without any major issues or downtime.
Read full review
Proofpoint
No answers on this topic
Alternatives Considered
Commvault
In the past it has been necessary to leverage multiple products to provide a complete data protection solution. Commvault Complete Backup & Recovery has been able to mirror the functions of competitive products while increasing functionality and management. Commvault Complete Backup & Recovery works cleanly in disparate environments that leverage dissimilar technologies and products.
Read full review
Mimecast
One of the big features of Mimecast is the ability to send large files. We used to use CItrix Sharefile for this but switched over to Mimecast's LFS for one large reason...since we are archiving all of our mail in Mimeast anyway we would have wanted these attachments, even if large, also available to if we go back to look at old emails. However just for usability sake I think Citrix Sharefile's large file send is more polished and probably works a little better. We just choose to use the Mimecast so we had a one stop shop when it came to email archiving
Read full review
Proofpoint
All three products have the pros and cons. Since we use other Proofpoint products, TAP, TRAP, etc. the integration with PSAT is much better. The other products do not integrate with TRAP nearly as well as PSAT.
Read full review
Scalability
Commvault
Commvault Complete Backup & Recovery is designed to provide organizations with flexible and scalable software
Read full review
Mimecast
No answers on this topic
Proofpoint
No answers on this topic
Return on Investment
Commvault
  • I am not privy to ROI, but just having confidence and trust that Commvault will back up whatever needs backing up, and that we will always be able to restore it quickly, allows our technical people to concentrate on the problem at hand, knowing that we do not have to worry about the safety of the data. This saves time for some very expensive human resources and shortens schedules by eliminating a whole class of data safety and disaster recovery issues.
Read full review
Mimecast
  • I can't put an exact dollar figure on it but Mimecast makes our company more efficient when it comes to email search and discovery.
  • Being heavily regulated it's great to have peace of mind when we're audited and I can just say we have Mimecast. Check that box off!
  • We were quite relieved when Mimecast stopped inbound attachments infected with WannaCry.
  • I enjoy the benefits of a cloud service so I don't have to manage hardware, deal with upgrades, or figure out complicated licensing schemes.
Read full review
Proofpoint
  • I don't have any tangible numbers to provide, but we definitely have an increase in the number of staff reporting suspicious emails and fewer people clicking on phishing emails.
  • The cost we are paying per employee (<$2 pp)is low enough that we can consider this a "benefit" we offer to our employees. The knowledge gained can also be applied to your personal life with similar threats.
Read full review
ScreenShots

Mimecast Cloud Archive Screenshots

Screenshot of Screenshot of