Likelihood to Recommend The Cisco Meraki Z3 Teleworker appliance was ideal for scenarios where the remote worker spent the majority of their time remote. It alleviates the need for VPN software and gives the IT staff additional visibility into the connectivity of the user. We often encountered scenarios where the users broadband was having issues vs the Meraki network and the tools Meraki provides help to work through these scenarios. The case for the Meraki devices is not as strong for occasional users who cannot justify the cost of the appliance vs just logging in via VPN.
Read full review The best usage scenario for Citrix Netscaler Gateway is in enterprises with a high volume of telecommuting users or in situations where the user needs to access certain applications from anywhere. In our case as a hospital, we need our doctors to access the medical records of the patients and be able to carry out any required action, with a high level of security and with a certain agility.
Read full review Pros Easy setup for remote worker Versatility with WiFi and cable connections Safe to outages with dual wan setup Read full review allows seamless use of 2-factor authentication for heightened security within the VPN, and lowers risk of an external hack because of it. it allows for differing levels of security. access can be set specifically through the VPN so 2 users can use the same site and get different results depending on their active directory security policy. It can grant the ability to launch a single application or an entire VPN envelope David Reese ConnectCare Hospital Billing Claims Application Coordinator
Read full review Cons When Internet is lost and come back we need to reset the Z3 device from the dashboard in order to register the IP Phone to CUCM It would be nice to manage the Z3 device to a local web portal just for TS Max Speed 100Mbps. It would be nice if it could run up to 1GB Read full review I suggest make it more faster because sometimes its lagging but not all the time. When it comes to Notepad I suggest having options for the size of fonts, and color of fonts, to make it look nicer. I suggest making it more user-friendly, and more features so that users can perfectly maximize this tool. Read full review Support Rating Support is pretty good and pretty fast to respond. I can't say I can really complain about the support experience I've had with them, as they've resolved issues within a reasonable time-frame. Of course, they could always be faster and better, but I think for what we pay, it's well worth the money.
Read full review Alternatives Considered At the time of implementation, we were not aware of a comparable product from Cisco or comparative vendor. We had initially deployed the Z1 appliance and had so much success that the transition to the Cisco Meraki Z3 Teleworker was a quick and easy fit for us. The device is easy to deploy and just works.
Read full review The only other SSL VPN type product I have used was Citrix Secure Gateway. Netscaler is a MUCH more feature filled product. CSG was a free add on to older versions of Citrix Metaframe and
XenApp and was specifically just used for securing Citrix infrastructure. Netscaler excels in securing Citrix but can also be used to secure shared apps of all kinds regardless of how they are published. I did do a test run on 2X's product which did include a secure gateway but then base 2X product was not really comparable to Citrix so did not go too far with it.
Read full review Scalability The product is very scalable due to its implementation to the Meraki cloud and SD-WAN capabilities.
Read full review Return on Investment Good visibility for IT team so we can monitor and validate the teleworker traffic Zero Touch Provisioning so we do not need to send a Engineer to configure it. Consumer-grade network security Read full review Our data is secure and protected from the outside world which is priceless. It saves our business money as we can provide our clients with a safe and secure alternative to accessing their data remotely rather than having to take the more expensive route of travelling on-site to gather the data we need. It gives us the opportunity to host on-site training using gated cloud based environments which enhances our business services. The ability to easily change access information, such as a password, after administering a training course gives us the flexibility we need to provide and subsequently restrict access to our training environments to suit our needs. Read full review ScreenShots