What users are saying about
4 Ratings
14 Ratings
4 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow noopener'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 9.9 out of 100
14 Ratings
<a href='https://www.trustradius.com/static/about-trustradius-scoring' target='_blank' rel='nofollow noopener'>trScore algorithm: Learn more.</a>
Score 8 out of 100

Likelihood to Recommend

Celtra

Celtra is best suited for rich media, expandable, clickable ad creation. It is valuable in terms of granular reporting as well. However, it is not suitable as a DSP i.e. we really can't make any optimizations through Celtra. It is best used for tracking ads, engagement, and performance metrics especially on mobile devices.
Matthew Stein | TrustRadius Reviewer

Frame.io

By far Frame is the best video review service out there mainly due to how easy it is to introduce to new users, including on the client side. There is not much instruction required in order to share and edit with a client and ask them to start providing feedback - the system is designed to invite users to give notes and that alone is worth the money.
Joel McAfee | TrustRadius Reviewer

Feature Rating Comparison

Ad Network Integration

Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Data Transfer
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
DSP integration
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io

Ad Campaigns

Celtra
9.3
Frame.io
Ad campaign creation
Celtra
9.9
Frame.io
Ad deployment
Celtra
9.0
Frame.io
Display advertising
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Ad display and retargeting segmentation
Celtra
8.9
Frame.io
Sequence targeting
Celtra
8.9
Frame.io

Ad Reporting & Analytics

Celtra
9.8
Frame.io
Ad dashboards
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Ad performance reports
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Ad conversion tracking
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Ad attribution reporting
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Cross-channel ad management
Celtra
10.0
Frame.io
Ad forecasting and optimization
Celtra
9.0
Frame.io

Project Management

Celtra
Frame.io
7.3
Task Management
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Mobile Access
Celtra
Frame.io
7.0
Search
Celtra
Frame.io
7.0

Communication

Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Chat
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Notifications
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0

File Sharing & Management

Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Versioning
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Video files
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Audio files
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Access control
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Advanced security features
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0
Device sync
Celtra
Frame.io
8.0

Pros

Celtra

  • I like that Celtra is under a high-quality price and minimum requirement.
  • It is highly effective and easy to understand; it has competitive performance and a very intuitive interface.
  • The campaigns are phenomenal, and the marketing management is excellent.
  • We have access to excellent analytics and data, and we get to see if our campaigns are failing or not.
  • As for formats, I can pretty much create whatever I want.
David Chamberlain | TrustRadius Reviewer

Frame.io

  • Frame.io provides an intuitive interface for clients to leave detailed feedback on videos they've hired us to produce. Users can leave public or private comments and start and stop on whichever video frames they choose. Users can draw on a frame using a non-destructive marker to make specific feedback (e.g. I don't like that this window is overexposed and is distracting me from looking at the interview). This allows for making nuanced critiques that are otherwise difficult to convey without using screengrabs or long email threads.
  • Frame.io is easy to learn. If a user is new to the application, the software determines this and a short tutorial video pops up and teaches the new user how to interact with the application. It does this without taking the user to a new page and risk confusing a client. The software is simple to use and I never have issues with uninformed or flustered clients because of it.
  • Frame.io makes sharing simple. Producers can send review links within the application or copy and paste the link into an email, whichever their preference. Users can also create live presentations to walk clients through a video as well. I've not used this feature extensively, so I'm unsure of how well it works, but the option is available.
  • Frame.io interacts with video editing software (i.e. After Effects, Premiere Pro) using a plug-in. Before applications like Frame.io, we had to reference emails with timecodes and then decipher what the client is asking to have changed. It was cryptic, and feels archaic in hindsight. Now, the integration between the application and our software is seamless. I can revisit feedback by clicking on a comment in the review window, and it takes me to the exact point of criticism in the timeline. It's so easy to use and saves so much time.
Chris Hecox | TrustRadius Reviewer

Cons

Celtra

  • It is a very click-happy environment, which means there is room for human error
  • The color scheme can make it easy to loose your place
  • There is no bulk editing option so task completion can be lengthy
Matthew Stein | TrustRadius Reviewer

Frame.io

  • Frame.io's permissions aren't great. Each individual project has its own permissions and there is no way to set a general admin permissions to team members thus allowing them to be added to every project.
  • Frame.io sometimes has issues for our clients where they cannot add edits or where their film does not load.
Anonymous | TrustRadius Reviewer

Usability

Celtra

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Frame.io

Frame.io 10.0
Based on 1 answer
I've used other video review systems, Frame was the only one I didn't question how they allowed you to review - I just started reviewing. It's that simple. It's easy to set up projects, invite collaborators, and then provide a final cut for download. It's naturally built for the kind of work that TV/Film & video production companies do.
Joel McAfee | TrustRadius Reviewer

Support Rating

Celtra

No score
No answers yet
No answers on this topic

Frame.io

Frame.io 8.8
Based on 2 answers
I've only reached out to Frame.io a few times but they responded quickly and offered achievable solutions. The fact that I haven't had to reach out to them more is proof that the platform is easy to use, reliable, and can run on its own. The only issues we have had were related to uploading issues on our end.
Anonymous | TrustRadius Reviewer

Alternatives Considered

Celtra

Celtra gave us a reliable and straightforward way to create a marketing creation plan to capture potential customers.
David Chamberlain | TrustRadius Reviewer

Frame.io

We used to use Dropbox as our main point of uploading and holding videos, but it was such a hassle because our edits came separately. It was almost just used as storage, and we had to have a separate email(s) with all of the edits coming from different departments. With Frame.io, the upload takes less time, people can add comments directly on the videos, AND the fact that you can upload new versions and literally use the same link is a total game-changer.
Hilary Hobbs | TrustRadius Reviewer

Return on Investment

Celtra

  • Positive - we have a preferred CPM rate while using Celtra so we are able to save costs there.
  • Positive - no need for outsourcing to other creative agencies so we save more costs
  • Positive - achieving KPIs for our clients ensures more revenue down the road as we establish ourselves as a trustworthy vendor
Matthew Stein | TrustRadius Reviewer

Frame.io

  • Frame.io has cut review time in half for us. When compared to the olden days of email threads for video review, I'll never want to go back. This is a huge time saver.
  • Frame.io gives a high sense of professionalism. I've had multiple clients express their delight with the application. It helps our feedback process, but also keeps our clients happy.
Chris Hecox | TrustRadius Reviewer

Pricing Details

Celtra

General

Free Trial
Free/Freemium Version
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No

Celtra Editions & Modules

Additional Pricing Details

Frame.io

General

Free Trial
Free/Freemium Version
Yes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
Entry-level set up fee?
No

Frame.io Editions & Modules

Edition
FreeFree1
Pro$152
Team$252
EnterpriseContact sales team
  1. For up to 2 users
  2. per user/per month
Additional Pricing Details

Rating Summary

Add comparison