OpsGenie is an IT monitoring and incident response platform for development and operations teams, providing alerts and schedule management escalations. OpsGenie is now part of Atlassian since the late 2018 acquisition.
$0
up to 5 users
PagerDuty
Score 8.6 out of 10
N/A
PagerDuty, Inc. (NYSE:PD) provides digital operations management. Serving organizations of all sizes, PagerDuty aims to help them deliver a perfect digital experience to their customers, every time.
Much more pricing friendly than PagerDuty but I haven't done the comparison in years so not sure how pricing/features stack up nowadays. Been very happy with OpsGenie.
We also looked at PagerDuty but decided to go with OpsGenie as it had more features on the plan we needed compared to PagerDuty which would have required us to spend a lot more for what we felt were non-premium features. Everything felt like an add-on - automation for an …
Have done a POC with PagerDuty in the past when evaluating OpsGenie and just liked the clean look and feel of OpsGenie better along with their already extensive list of integrations. The integrations was probably the key deciding factor in us not going with PagerDuty at the time.
I did an evaluation of OpsGenie and found PagerDuty to be more intuitive and at the time PagerDuty had more integrations. I also really believe in PagerDuty's ability to keep an extremely high uptime for their application. Over the last 5 years very few issues and 0 lengthy …
OpsGenie provides a much better cost model for our company, we can now add all the users we need and we are extremely happy with it. Also, their support is very responsive and migrating was pretty easy. Their bi-directional Nagios integration is also very useful.
When compared to VictorOps and OpsGenie, PagerDuty is clearly the best of the breed. It provides a more polished UI, more integrations, and more features than the others, but it's priced at a premium. Smaller teams will probably get more value out of another alternative that …
PagerDuty has better integrations than OpsGenie. One integration that PagerDuty supports that OpsGenie does not is integration into Microsoft Flow. This allows us further opportunity to automate the routing of certain incidents. Other than that, we did not consider any …
There is too little of a difference between OpsGenie and PagerDuty. Both tools are really great and do the job they promise very well. If I had to choose, I'd go with PagerDuty. This is not because of any features or because it's better. It is because I've been using it for the …
My last experience with OpsGenie was the pre-Atlassian acquisition. At the time there was no SLA, which was an immediate showstopper. We had missed alerts as well with OpsGenie, so we switched to PD. I'd have to think with Atlassian owning OG now, that if we had a bake-off …
PD is a set-it-and-forget-it solution. The application is reliable, has many features, and will drag a tech out of the deepest sleep so to put out a fire. OpsGenie is clunky at best. It can work, but the paging is unreliable, the schedule is a nightmare, and the integrations …
most of the team members were familiar with pagerduty and since its battletested and widely adopted and pricing was also competitive hence we have chosen pagerduty
I have not use the 2 technologies for as long as I have used PagerDuty but in my opinion PagerDuty makes things a lot easier. The other tools got the job done and got alerts out but PagerDuty just seemed to make the setup for on-call alert schedules and integrations easier …
Agile Process Engineer , ScrumMaster, Product Owner
Chose PagerDuty
Very similar in features, but we kept PagerDuty, mostly for the integration capability with almost any system, and the cost of up-fitting didn't make sense. Try googling around and you will quickly find that no one on the market has as many capabilities when it comes to …
While more costly than the competitors, PagerDuty has more functionality and is the better tool. There are more integrations, the UI is cleaner, and there are more features and options.
Both the above products (although they could do more, such as alert filtering), were too bulky and cumbersome. Building simple alerts and integrations were time-consuming and more hassle then they should have been. Escalation policies were also difficult and cumbersome to set …
Through our evaluation, we selected PagerDuty, mainly because of its user interface and the ability for support managers to configure it without additional support.
PagerDuty is a powerful incident tracking and alert management system. Its strengths are full functional web-based design, mobile accessible and configurable for a large scale user group. PagerDuty has features for email alerting and customized on call support schedule. The …
OpsGenie and PagerDuty are both IT incident management tools. They also offer on-call schedule and rotation management capabilities. OpsGenie has been acquired by Atlassian to join its IT portfolio, while PagerDuty is a standalone solution.
OpsGenie is an Atlassian IT monitoring and incident response platform, which emphasizes its integrations with the rest of organizations’ tech stacks and the platform’s relatively lower price point. In contrast, PagerDuty’s incident resolution service specializes in alert management and quality customer support for larger organizations and enterprises.
Features
OpsGenie and PagerDuty both offer strong capabilities tailored to their respective user bases.
OpsGenie excels as an integrated tool within businesses’ broader IT ecosystems. Reviewers highlight OpsGenie’s native integrations with 3rd party systems. These integrations also facilitate coordination and communications across different teams for more streamlined IT incident escalation and resolution.
On the other hand, PagerDuty stands out for its alert management and aggregation at scale. It features very flexible and adaptable escalation rules to meet each business’s unique needs. Reviewers also highlight PagerDuty’s alert management and aggregation when wrangling a wide array of alerts across the enterprise.
Limitations
OpsGenie and PagerDuty also have various limitations worth keeping in mind.
OpsGenie has been criticized for its user interface, which some reviewers say is not accessible for some users. In particular, alert administration can be difficult to conduct, such as routing alerts to specific individuals. If alert routing isn’t carefully managed, they can be sent to the wrong personnel, resulting in missed alerts.
In contrast, PagerDuty’s mobile application has been consistently criticized by reviewers. It lacks functionality found in the desktop version, and is not viable as an alternate administrative portal. There are also some 3rd party tools with limited or insufficient integrations.
Pricing
OpsGenie offers 4 packages:
The free version provides basic alerting and on-call management for up to 5 users.
The Essential plan, at $9/user/month, provides additional incident management and alerting, as well as various Jira integrations.
The Standard plan, at $19/user/month, offers unlimited alerting and incident management, including more customization and integrations.
The Enterprise plan, at $29/user/month, provides the full incident management platform and additional reporting capabilities.
PagerDuty offers 5 different plans, each tier adding functionalities on the lower-tier plan:
The Free plan provides on-call scheduling, unlimited API calls, and always-up service for up to 5 users.
The Starter plan, at $10/user/month for up to 6 users, ads unlimited domestic text notifications and escalation policies, as well as 1 year data access and email/chat support.
The Team plan, at $29/user/month, adds unlimited global phone/text notifications, more integrates, response orchestration, and a status dashboard.
The Business plan, at $39/user/month, adds SSO and advanced permissions, advanced integrations, unlimited data access, and phone support.
The Digital Operations plan, priced by quote from the vendor, provides a suite of add-on products, more automation, event management, analytics, and a visibility console.
Incident response is well suited to OpsGenie, and this is where it really shines—whether it's an outage, a security incident, or similar. My experience is mostly with security, and it offers a great audit trail. It minimises the need to cut and paste from different platforms when creating reports and ensures that what was said and what was done (along with any evidence) is persisted and reflected in the incident detail.
I think PagerDuty works great for medical practices. I have used other platforms through other companies, and PagerDuty is by far the best platform. It is because of the different features it has to communicate to other staff members how the call is being handled. It is easy to learn how to use.
OpsGenie New Jira design has made it difficult for those not familiar with that style.
OpsGenie could benefit from nested escalation flows for team schedules. Creating a product alert that uses and Tech Schedule as well as an Incident Manager Schedule that already exists would create less overhead and ease management.
When getting a phone call, PagerDuty doesn't seem to allow acknowledgments of alerts through the phone, which it says it does. I constantly receive a message that it was updated by another person - when in reality, it wasn't.
Smarter notifications. If an alert was snoozed for a time, when it comes back, it sends out another alert. It should, I think, send a message asking if the alert is still an issue and give the option to close.
In general terms OpsGenie is a well done tool for solving the alert incident management, the usability is super ok during the configuration and during the alert. The main opportunity I found is the reporting and analytics section which is a little difficult to understand at a first sight and the refresh is not automatic, some little frictions but frictions at all
The UI is more complex than I would like. Part of the challenge is that most users use PagerDuty infrequently; I don't remember how I changed a policy last time. Another part of the challenge is that some users expect alerting to be a trivial feature, and are reluctant to invest any time in reading the documentation.
PagerDuty is reliable and easy to set up. It gives an effective way to notify the team about critical incidents which results in a faster turnaround time on issues. users can customize their alerts rules based on their preferences. Overall it's effective and easy to use which adds great business value.
We also looked at PagerDuty but decided to go with OpsGenie as it had more features on the plan we needed compared to PagerDuty which would have required us to spend a lot more for what we felt were non-premium features. Everything felt like an add-on - automation for an additional $20 a user per month seemed like a lot on top of the base plan
I have not use the 2 technologies for as long as I have used PagerDuty but in my opinion PagerDuty makes things a lot easier. The other tools got the job done and got alerts out but PagerDuty just seemed to make the setup for on-call alert schedules and integrations easier than the others. This isn't to say the others are difficult, just that PagerDuty was slightly better. I also have noticed that more tools have options to integrate to PagerDuty over the other tools.
Helped us track bugs and issues that came up during product launch periods which reduced overhead that normally came with needing to manually contact the right team members
Prevented last minute breaking issues from falling through the cracks, decreased time to fix by automatically alerting the team members and allowing the product and project teams to easily see what active alerts are in progress