Mailchimp does email better than just about anyone, but it needs to stop trying to do everything
June 30, 2023

Mailchimp does email better than just about anyone, but it needs to stop trying to do everything

Eric R. Burgess | TrustRadius Reviewer
Score 7 out of 10
Vetted Review
Verified User

Software Version

Standard

Overall Satisfaction with Mailchimp

At NEON ID, we use Mailchimp as a tool for mass mailing to customers and communicating with brands. We mainly use Mailchimp to bring our customers back to the NEON ID platform to conduct more brand interactions. By sending personalized emails to our customers, we are able to provide them with a better user experience and keep them engaged with our platform - we even experiment with different groups based on their psychometrics so it's helpful to send multiple cohorts slightly different versions so messages appeal to them. Additionally, we also use Mailchimp to communicate with brands and encourage them to use the NEON ID platform for more surveys, to ask questions, and to interact with users who provide their consent.

We value Mailchimp's compliance with GDPR and CCPA, which is why we chose to use the tool. The privacy and security of our users' data is a top priority for us, and Mailchimp's respect for these regulations is a huge deal for us. However, we do not use many of the extra tools that Mailchimp offers because we have HubSpot for CRM. We don't want Mailchimp to keep building out competitive work, and HubSpot provides us with everything we need to manage our customer relationships effectively.

Overall, Mailchimp has been a valuable tool for us at NEON ID, helping us to maintain a strong relationship with our customers and brands while keeping their data secure and private.
  • Parse mailing lists
  • Keep on white lists for email
  • Making it quick to send a mass email
  • Stop trying to be a full marketing suite - this distracts from the core marketing automation
  • More integrations with new AI tools
  • The UI needs a refresh, it feels outdated and slow
  • Mailchimp has allowed us to communicate effectively with thousands of customers with ease.
  • Mailchimp's use during our second year of business helped us expand our list of brands considerably (almost 30% YTD) because of regular interactions that we've launched.
  • Mailchimp ramp-up time is minimal for new users so I can turn things over to junior staff - saving me time and money.
Mailchimp is generally a simpler solution, and I've picked it for multiple companies because of that. I also like that Mailchimp does better on delivery than just about anywhere else. The brand is also fun and powerful.

Mailchimp needs to keep their system clean and not put so many little in-app purchases and all of these extra features I'm getting elsewhere.
Mailchimp has a clean interface and the concepts within the application are really clear. That's why the ramp-up is so easy - they do a great job of avoiding jargon and unnecessary steps in the sending of emails. Designing an email with Mailchimp is as WYSIWYG as you can get, which is a good thing.
I don't know that we've benefited that much from the company's desire to be an all-in-one marketing solution. I've already got the stack that I like, which includes some other great solutions that I prefer to use. Mailchimp's expansion into other elements, which is more obvious since the Intuit acquisition actually reduces the value of the platform for me.
Mailchimp has proven to be a reliable and effective tool for delivering email campaigns. One of the key advantages of Mailchimp is its ability to handle whitelisting, which ensures that emails are not flagged as spam and are delivered directly to recipients' inboxes. In addition, Mailchimp's ability to parse cohorts is powerful and quick, allowing for targeted messaging to specific audiences. This feature has been particularly useful as we segment by psychometrics (one of our key values).

Do you think Mailchimp delivers good value for the price?

Yes

Are you happy with Mailchimp's feature set?

Yes

Did Mailchimp live up to sales and marketing promises?

Yes

Did implementation of Mailchimp go as expected?

Yes

Would you buy Mailchimp again?

Yes

Mailchimp as a free or low-cost solution for small businesses to get an email newsletter or regular comms with customers out is a winner. The simplicity of adding a CSV of people and building an email in the app is good, although it feels like it's gotten slower with the acquisition.

Mailchimp as a CRM and a market platform is too much. I prefer an approach that links the best of the best apps together with integrations as opposed to building out every one of these apps into superapps that do all things.

Also, Mailchimp feels like it is nickel-and-diming us a lot now. Not a fan of that.

Mailchimp Feature Ratings

WYSIWYG email editor
9
Dynamic content
7
Ability to test dynamic content
7
Landing pages
5
A/B testing
9
Mobile optimization
9
Email deliverability reporting
10
List management
5
Triggered drip sequences
8
Calendaring
5
Event/webinar marketing
5
Social sharing and campaigns
8
Social profile integration
Not Rated
Dashboards
9
Standard reports
9
API
6
Integration with Salesforce.com
7
Integration with Microsoft Dynamics CRM
Not Rated
Third-party software integrations
6